Showing posts with label Decision Making. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Decision Making. Show all posts

 


"Nudge" by Richard H. Thaler and Cass R. Sunstein is a book that explores the concept of nudges and how they can be used to influence people's choices for the better. A nudge refers to any aspect of the choice architecture that alters people's behavior in a predictable way without forbidding any options or significantly changing their economic incentives.

Richard H. Thaler (b. 1945) is a professor of Behavioral Science and Economics at the University of Chicago. Cass R. Sunstein (b. 1954) is a professor at Harvard Law School and serves as an advisor to president Barack Obama.




Summary & Key Learnings

The book argues that small changes in the way choices are presented can have a significant impact on people's decisions. By understanding the two systems that drive human thinking—the automatic system (quick and instinctual) and the reflective system (slow and deliberate)—the authors explain how human behavior is influenced by both conscious and unconscious factors.

Thaler and Sunstein introduce the concept of libertarian paternalism, which suggests that it is possible to influence people's behavior in a way that improves their overall well-being without limiting their freedom of choice. They believe policymakers have a responsibility to design choice architectures that nudge individuals toward better decisions.

Throughout the book, the authors present various examples and case studies to illustrate how nudges can be applied in different contexts. They discuss topics such as encouraging saving through the Save More Tomorrow program, improving school choices for parents, personalising social security investments, and even privatising marriage contracts.

The key premise of the book is that by carefully designing the choice architecture and considering the automatic and reflective systems at play, policymakers can help people make better decisions in areas such as finance, health, education, and more. The book advocates for the use of nudges to create an environment that leads to improved outcomes and individual well-being.


We often make bad decisions based on either too little or overly complex information.

Why do we so often make decisions that aren’t really the best choices for us? In many cases, we simply have too little or too much information, or we can’t foresee the consequences of our actions. It’s only when we have, and can process, the right amount of information that we are in a place to make rational decisions.

For example, when we have to choose an ice cream flavor at an ice cream shop, we usually make that decision rather quickly. We see which flavors there are and we know from experience that strawberry ice cream tastes better than mango, i.e., we have all the necessary information and can process it rapidly.

However, we feel differently in more serious situations, like when deciding whether to take out a loan. After all, there are all different kinds of loans: purchases on account, deferrals, consumer loans, securities, preliminary financing, interim financing, and many more. Some of them have a fixed interest rate, others a variable; all of them have different additional costs. And this information isn’t exactly laid out in plain writing. Usually, it’s hidden in the small print on the bright and colorful advertisement.

In other words, even when we are privy to all the relevant information, it can still be difficult to sort it all out and compare the services objectively. Situations like this can make us feel completely overwhelmed.


Human beings act mainly on gut feelings.

When we see a laughing baby, we can’t help but smile. That “decision” to smile is made unconsciously; our response occurs entirely on its own. But when we want to figure out the answer to 347 x 12, we confront this task in a conscious way, because finding the answer requires an effort and takes some time. These examples illustrate two different systems of thought: In the case of the baby, we are using our Automatic System, i.e., our gut instinct. In the case of the math problem, we are using the rational or Reflective System. We don’t have the time or energy to reflect upon every little action we take on an average day, which is why we often let our Automatic System govern our actions. It works well a lot of the time – but not all the time.

Grounded in simplifications, the Automatic System is often supported by a weak scaffolding of spontaneous emotions and subjective experiences. For instance, when we estimate our own likelihood of suffering from a stroke, the first thing we think about is the amount of people we know who’ve already had one. If we don’t know anybody who’s had a stroke, we automatically assume that there’s only a low risk that we’ll have one. And so, even if our own risk is actually extremely high, we don’t take any precautions. In other words, our gut feeling has led us first to a misjudgment and then to an unwise decision.


Sometimes we make faulty decisions because we succumb to temptation or act without thinking.

If you offer a long-time smoker a cigarette while she’s in the process of quitting, it’ll be difficult for her to resist the temptation. Although she’d like to quit and knows how bad it is for her, she’ll probably end up bumming a smoke. The reason for this unwise response is a lack of will: despite her intentions, the temptation is simply too great. A certain degree of thoughtlessness also takes hold of us in such situations.

For example, experiments have shown that bigger portions cause us to eat more. If we have a big portion in front of us, we eat more of it than we should – even if it doesn’t taste good. In one experiment, researchers sent their test subjects to the movies. Before they entered the theater, the subjects received a bag of stale popcorn – half got a small bag, the other half a medium-sized bag. Although most of the participants later stated that the stale popcorn didn’t taste good, they ate a lot of it anyway – and the people with the big bags ate even more of theirs.


Some companies exploit the human tendency to make the wrong decisions.

If companies want to be successful, they have to sell products and earn profits. And to do that, they have to fulfill their customers’ needs. Whether that has positive or negative consequences on customers doesn’t matter to some companies – their main concern is whether customers are buying. Sometimes companies don’t just satisfy the needs that customers already have – they can create new needs in their customers too.

For example, many people can’t help themselves in the face of temptation and don’t think twice about the consequences when making spur-of-the-moment decisions. Companies use this knowledge to tempt their customers into buying more than they originally intended. This is the core approach of companies that promote XXL-sized portions instead of normal ones, and the availability of these over-sized portions is one of the reasons why so many people eat far too much.

Trial subscriptions to periodicals are another case where companies exploit human weakness. You can sign up and receive the periodical for free for a certain amount of time, but, if you don’t terminate your subscription within the cancellation period, it is automatically renewed, and you continue receiving the periodical – and paying for it.


Nudges are subtle changes in context that help us avoid making bad decisions.

How can we keep ourselves from making the wrong decisions? With nudges, or little pushes in the right direction. Nudges are not “no-nos” or clever advertising messages. Rather, they are subtle actions that make it easier for us to act in the way that is best for us without dictating a specific behavior. Simply put, nudges leave us free rein while making it easier for us to choose the right thing. Displaying fruit in clearly visible spots and putting junk food in less prominent ones in a cafeteria is a nudge: we have the choice between buying an apple and a candy bar, but the arrangement of the products prompts us to go for the healthier apple.

Of course, nudges can also be used for less righteous purposes, e.g., by companies who want to suggest certain purchasing decisions. Companies have been using nudges for a long time – in supermarkets, for example, the shelves at eye level usually contain the most expensive goods. But the example of the fruit being prominently displayed in the cafeteria shows that nudges can also help people choose healthier and better alternatives.



Defaults are highly effective nudges that cause people to automatically do what’s best for them.

Considering that we don’t rack our brains every time we make a decision, decision-making situations should be designed so that automatic responses produce a positive outcome. The e-mail service Gmail does just that with its attachment reminder. If words like “please find attached” are written in e-mail text but no file has been attached, the e-mail program automatically recognises it and asks the user, “Did you want to send an attachment?” This little nudge can save people a lot of time and trouble.

Companies could choose a similar system to assist their employees to make wise decisions about, e.g., enrolling in company pension-scheme programs. Since most people are naturally inclined to laziness and don’t really want to change their status quo, enrolling in a company pension-scheme program should not be optional. It would be much better to set up the program so that all employees are automatically enrolled in the scheme – and have to explicitly object if they do not want to be. Companies should choose defaults guaranteeing that employees do the right thing even when the employees do nothing at all.


Nudges are most useful when we have too many choices or when the future is at stake.

The most opportune time to use nudges is in situations where it’s particularly difficult for us to make the right decisions. Making the wrong decision is easy when we have an immediate pay-off and don’t feel the negative consequences until later. We take that second piece of cake and drink that cocktail after work because they give us pleasure in the moment and we only feel the negative effects later – when we step on a scale at the end of the month, or wake up the next morning with a headache.

Another cause of bad decision-making is when we don’t have previous experiences to refer to. At some point or another, we have to decide on which insurance company we want to use. Since we only make this decision once or twice in our lives, we can’t refer to earlier experiences to assess which insurance company would be best for us. And even after choosing a health insurance company, there is yet another decision to be made: which policy? For example, if an insurance company offers many different policies, but some customers who just want general coverage are having difficulty choosing which policy would be best for them, the company could offer a recommended “default policy” – say, one that covers more than 80% of a person’s entire medical costs. This helps the less insurance-savvy customers choose a policy that covers a wide range of treatments for the most common medical problems.



Many people use nudges to achieve their goals.

At the end of each year, many of us come to the conclusion that, yet again, we didn’t manage to stick to our New Year’s resolutions: the number on the scale is higher than last year and the ashtray is still full. And yet some people are successful. How did they do it? Generally, the people who are able to stick to their resolutions do so by using nudges to keep them from making the wrong decisions throughout the year: they place bets with their friends, take advantage of public weigh-ins, or use Internet programs tailored to help them monitor their progress and stay on target.

On the website Stickk.com, more than 100,000 people have signed so called commitment contracts with themselves to achieve their goals. After signing up on the website, you state your goal, set milestones with specific deadlines, and have the option to put money on your success. If you achieve your goal, you get your money back. If not, your money goes to whatever institution or person you initially selected (one particularly motivating recipient, for example, might be the rival team of your favorite football team). This successful website is an example of how nudges can be harnessed to help you modify your behavior and fulfill your ambitions.



States and other institutions should use nudges to encourage wise decisions.

Nudges encourage individuals to make better decisions – and this often benefits more than just the individual alone. An entire society benefits when the majority of its members make wise decisions. If fewer people smoke or are overweight, healthcare costs decrease – and everybody wins.

Even though a nudge may cost us something at first, the longer term benefits are generally not long in coming. In the area of environmental protection, the mere act of instating a public obligation to report carbon emissions has the power to change peoples’ behavior. This obligation doesn’t explicitly forbid companies to exceed a certain limit of pollutant emissions. Instead, it acts as a nudge by creating incentives to voluntarily cut down on emissions (especially because environmentalists frequently use such information to publicly denounce polluters). The reporting obligation thus creates a sort of emission-cutting competition – without using any legal coercion.

As the dollar-a-day program shows, nudges can also reduce the amount of unwanted teenage pregnancies. Many young mothers who’ve already had a child as a teenager often get pregnant again shortly thereafter. In order to tackle this issue, several US cities pay teenage mothers one dollar for every day they don’t get pregnant. This program is actually cheaper for taxpayers than the costs of supporting the children of the young mothers.

Companies also use nudges to keep their customers from making mistakes. If we forget to put on our seat belt in a car, the car beeps at us until we buckle up. If our gas tank is almost empty, a warning light blinks to remind us to stop and fill it up. These little things don’t force us to fasten our seat belts or fill our gas tanks: they do, however, prevent us from accidentally forgetting.


People often make unwise decisions, but the slightest of changes – so-called nudges – can give people incentives to make better decisions. That’s why countries and private institutions should also use nudges.

The questions this book answered:

How and why do we make the wrong decisions?
  • We don’t always make decisions that are best for us in the long run.
  • We often make bad decisions based on either too little or overly complex information.
  • Human beings act mainly on gut feelings.
  • Sometimes we make faulty decisions because we succumb to temptation or act without thinking.
  • Some companies exploit the human tendency to make the wrong decisions.

How can nudges help us deal with this problem?
  • Nudges are subtle changes in context that help us avoid making bad decisions.
  • Defaults are highly effective nudges that cause people to automatically do what’s best for them.
  • Nudges are most useful when we have too many choices or when the future is at stake.

How can each and every one of us use nudges?
  • Many people use nudges to achieve their goals.
  • States and other institutions should use nudges to encourage wise decisions.


 

'Influence' explains in detail the fundamental principles of persuasion. How do you get people to say yes? How do other people get you to say yes? How are you manipulated by sleek salesmen, clever marketing folks and sneaky confidence tricksters? This book will help you understand the psychology behind their techniques, enabling you to unleash your own persuasive powers, while also defending against their tactics of manipulation.

Influence has been authored by Robert B. Cialdini, PhD a Professor Emeritus of Psychology and Marketing at Arizona State University. He also acted as a visiting professor at Stanford University and the University of California at Santa Cruz. Influence is based on 35 years of evidence-based research into the phenomena of influence, manipulation and persuasion. Dr. Cialdini also runs a consultancy based on teaching and implementing the ethical business applications of his research.




Summary & Key Learnings

Chapter 1 - Levers of Influence: (Power) Tools of the Trades
Chapter 2 - Reciprocation: The Old Give and Take
Chapter 3 - Liking: The Friendly Thief
Chapter 4 - Social Proof: Truths Are Us
Chapter 5 - Authority: Directed Deference
Chapter 6 - Scarcity: The Rule of the Few
Chapter 7 - Commitment and Consistency: Hobgoblins of the Mind
Chapter 8 - Unity: The "We" Is the Shared Me
Chapter 9 - Instant Influence: Primitive Consent for an Automatic Age

This book teaches you the 6 fundamental principles of manipulation and the most relevant persuasion techniques that compliance professionals employ. It will help you defend yourself from deceit, but also put these techniques to use yourself, should you need to flex some persuasive muscle. In many situations, we humans like to avoid thinking about how we should react by using predictable shortcuts to guide our decisions. Compliance professionals like advertisers, con artists and salespeople take advantage of these preprogrammed human reactions to elicit the response that’s in their best interests, not ours. Specifically, they leverage the principles of reciprocation, scarcity, consistency, social proof, liking and authority. Since we cannot stop using these shortcuts that mostly serve us well, we must instead learn to defend ourselves against the manipulators who abuse them.


Chapter 1 - Levers of Influence: (Power) Tools of the Trades

Ethologist, researchers who study animal behavior in the natural environment, have noticed that among many animal species, behaviour often occurs in rigid and mechanical patterns. Called fixed-action patterns, these mechanical sequences are noteworthy in their similarity to certain automatic responses by humans. For both humans and subhumans, the automatic-behaviour patterns tend to be triggered by a single feature, or trigger feature, can often prove valuable by allowing an individual to decide on a correct course of action without having to analyse carefully and completely each of the other pieces of information in the situation.

The advantage of such shortcut responding lies in its efficiency and economy; by reacting automatically to a normally informative trigger feature, an individual preserves crucial time, energy, and mental capacity. The disadvantage of such responding lies in its vulnerability to silly and costly mistakes; by reacting to only a piece of the available information (enven a usually predictive piece), an individual increases the chances of error, especially when responding in an automatic, mindless fashion. The chances of error increase even further when other individuals seek to profit by arranging (through manipulation of trigger features) ti stimulate a desired behaviour at inappropriate times.

Since dealing with the complexities of life means having to rely on shortcuts, we must identify and defend ourselves against the manipulators who would trick us into wrongly using those shortcuts. The following chapters introduce the 6 basic psychological principles that we use as shortcuts, and which can be exploited for persuasion which are: reciprocation, scarcity, consistency, social proof, liking and authority.

Perceptual contrast is the tendency to see 2 things that are different from one another as being more different than they actually are. It is a lever of influence used by some compliance practitioners. For example, real estate agents may show prospective home buyers one or 2 unattractive options before showing them a more attractive home, which then seems more attractive than it would have if shown first. An advantage of employing this lever of influence is that its tactical use typically goes unrecognised.


Chapter 2 - Reciprocation: The Old Give and Take

According to sociologists and anthropologists, one of the most widespread and basic norms of human culture is embodied in the rule of reciprocation. The rule requires that one person try to repay, in form, what another person has provided. By obligating the recipient of an act to repayment in the future, the rule allows one individual to give something to another with confidence that it is not being lost. This rule forms the foundation of all societies, for it allowed our ancestors to share resources, safe in the knowledge that they would be reciprocated later. 

And if someone does us a favor and we do not return it, we feel a psychological burden. This is partially because, as a society, we are disdainful of those who do not reciprocate favors; we label them as moochers or ingrates and fear being labeled as such ourselves. The desire to reciprocate is intense that people are so keen to rid themselves of the burden of reciprocity that they will often perform much larger favors in return for small ones.

So how can you fight back?

Reciprocity plays a fundamental role in the way societies and social relationships work, so you can’t forego the principle entirely. But you can learn to identify and resist deliberate attempts to abuse it.

Start by getting into the habit of asking yourself if the favors you receive are really genuine, or if they could be attempts to manipulate you. Think about whether you actually want to donate your money to that nonprofit organization, or if you only feel obliged because they handed you a gift on the street. And don’t worry about not reciprocating “favors” that are really manipulation attempts in disguise; favors warrant favors in return, but tricks do not.


Chapter 3 - Liking: The Friendly Thief

People prefer to say yes to individuals they like. Recognising this rule, compliance professionals commonly increase their effectiveness by emphasising several factors that increase their overall likability.

One feature is physical attractiveness.
Although i has long been suspected that physical beauty provides an advantage in social interaction, research indicates the advantage may be greater than supposed. Physical attractiveness engenders a halo-effect that leads to the assignment of other traits such as talent, kindness, and intelligence. As a result, attractive people are more persuasive both in terms of getting what they request and changing others' attitudes. 

A second factor that influences liking and compliance is similarity.
We like people who are like us, and we are more willing to say yes to their requests, often in an unthinking manner. 

Another factor is praise.
Compliments generally enhance liking and, hence, compliance. 2 particularly useful types of genuine compliments are those delivered behind the recipient's back and those selected to give the recipient a reputation to live up to, by continuing to perform the desired behaviour.

Increased familiarity through repeated contact with a person or thing is yet another factor that normally facilitates liking. 
This relationship hold true principally when the contact takes place under positive rather than negative circumstances. One positive circumstance that works especially well is mutual and successful cooperation. A fifth factor linked to liking is association. By connecting themselves on their products with positive things, advertisers, politicians, and merchandisers frequently seek to share in the positivity through the process of association. Other individuals as well (sports fans for example) appear to recognised the positive effect of simple connections and try to associate themselves with favorable events and distance themselves from unfavorable events in the eyes of observers.

How do we protect ourselves against likability manipulation? 
A good step is to ask ourselves whether we have come to like someone or something unusually strongly in a short time. If so, this could be due to some form of manipulation, and alarm bells should ring.


Chapter 4 - Social Proof: Truths Are Us

The principle of social proof states that one important means people use to decide what to believe or how to act in a situation is to examine what others are believing or doing there. The principle of social proof can be used to stimulate a person's compliance with a request by communicating that many other individuals (the more, the better) are or have been complying with it. Therefore, simply pointing to the popularity of an item elevates its popularity.

Social proof is most influential under 3 conditions:

1st condition is uncertainty.
When people are unsure, when the situation is ambiguous, they are more likely to attend to the actions of others and to accept those actions as correct. In ambiguous situations, for instance, the decisions of bystanders to offer emergency aid are much more influenced by the actions of other bystanders than when the situation is a clear-cut emergency.

2nd condition under which social proof is most influential involves "The many."
People are more inclined to follow the lead of others in proportion to the others' number. When we see multiple other performing an action, we become willing to follow because the action appears to be more (1) correct/valid, (2) feasible, and (3) socially acceptable.

3rd condition is similarity.
People conform to the beliefs and actions of comparable others, especially their peers - a phenomenon we can call peer-suasion. 

When communicators are not able to use existing social proof because their idea, cause, or product does not have widespread support, they may be able to harness the power of future social proof by honestly describing trending support, which audiences expect to continue.

Recommendations to reduce our susceptibility to faulty social, proof include cultivating a sensitivity to counterfeit evidence of what similar others are doing and recognising that the actions of similar others should not form the sole basis for our decisions.


Chapter 5 - Authority: Directed Deference

Renowned psychologist Stanley Milgram conducted a study in the 1960s showing that volunteers would administer potentially lethal electric shocks to others simply because they were told to do so by an authority figure. Although no one was harmed, the experimenters were surprised by the results. In the Milgram studies, we see evidence of strong pressures for compliance with the requests of an authority. Acting contrary to their own preferences, many normal, psychologically healthy individuals were willing to deliver dangerous levels of pain to another person because they were directed to do so by an authority figure. 

From birth, we’re taught to always obey figures of authority, be they teachers, doctors or police officers. Unfortunately, this tendency to comply with authority is so ingrained and powerful that we don’t bother to think or challenge perceived authority figures before obeying them. It is adaptive to obey the dictates of genuine authorities because such individuals usually possess high levels of knowledge, wisdom, and power. For these reasons, deference to authorities can occur in a mindless fashion as a kind of decision-making shortcut.

When reacting to authority in an automatic fashion, people have a tendency to do so in response to mere symbols of authority rather than to its substance. 3 kinds of symbols effective in this regard are titles, clothing, and trappings such as automobiles. In studies, individuals possessing prestigious forms of one or another of the symbole (and no other legitimising credentials) were accorded more deference or obedience by those they encountered.

Authority influence flows from being viewed as either in authority or an authority. But the first of these types, merely being in charge, has its problems. Ordering people to do things often generates resistance and resentment. The second type of authority, being viewed as highly informed, avoids this problems, as people are usually willing follow the recommendations of someone who knows more than they do on the matter at hand.

The persuasive effect of being seen as an authority is maximised by also being seens as a credible such authority - one perceived as both expert (knowledgeable on the relevant topic) and trustworthy (honest in the presentation of one's knowledge). To estable their trustworthiness, communicators may admit to a (usually minor) shortcoming of their case, which ca be swept aside later by the presentation of outweighing strengths.

It is possible to defend ourselves against the detrimental effects of authority influence by asking 2 questions:

Is this authority truly an expert?
How truthful can we expect this expert to be?

The first directs our attention away from symbols and toward evidence for authority status. 
The second advises us to consider not just the expert's knowledge in the situation by also his or her trustworthiness. With regard to this second consideration, we should be alert to the trust-enhancing tactic in which communicators first provide mildly negative information about themselves. Through this strategy, they create a perception of honesty that makes all subsequent information seem more believable to observers. 


Chapter 6 - Scarcity: The Rule of the Few

According to the scarcity principle, people assign more value to opportunities that are less available. The use of this principle for profit can be seen in such compliance techniques as the "limited number" and "deadline" tactics, wherein practitioners try to convince us that if we don't act now, we will lose something of value. This engages the human tendency for loss aversion - that people are more motivated by the thought of losing something than by the thought of gaining something of equal value.

When does scarcity become a powerful influence on our decision-making?

Two conditions need to be fulfilled:

  1. First, we tend to want something more if its availability has decreased recently than if it has remained steady over time. This is why revolutions tend to happen when living conditions deteriorate sharply rather than when they are consistently low; the sudden drop increases people’s desire for something better, so they take to the streets.
  2. Second, competition always sets our hearts racing. Whether in auctions, romances or real-estate deals, the thought of losing something to a rival often turns us from reluctant to overzealous. This is why, for example, real estate agents often mention to buyers that several other bidders are also interested in a given house, whether true or not. In fact, a competitive situation can induce a “feeding frenzy” for a scarce good, even among seasoned negotiators.

To counter the eagerness that arises from scarcity, we should always consider whether we want the item in question because of its use to us (for example, its taste or function), or merely because of an irrational wish to possess it. When scarcity is being used against us, the answer will often be the latter.


Chapter 7 - Commitment and Consistency: Hobgoblins of the Mind

Psychologists have long recognised a desire in most people to be and look consistent within their words, attitudes, and deeds. This tendency for consistency is fed from 3 sources. 
  1. First, good personal consistency is highly valued by society.
  2. Second, aside from its effect on public image, generally consistent conduct provides a beneficial approach to daily life.
  3. Third, a consistent orientation affords a valuable shortcut through the complexity of modern existence. By being consistent with earlier decisions, one reduces the need to process all the relevant information in future similar situations; instead, one merely needs to recall the earlier decision and to respond consistently with it.
Within the realm of compliance, securing an initial commitment is the key. After making a commitment (that is, taking an action, stand, or position), people are more willing to agree to requests in keeping with the prior commitment. Thus, many compliance professionals try to induce people to take an initial position that is consistent with a behaviour they will later request from these people. Not all commitments are equally effective in producing consistent future action. Commitments are most effective when they are active, public, effortful, and viewed as internally motivated (voluntary), because each of these elements changes self-image. The reason they do so is that each element gives us information about what we must truly believe.

Commitment decisions, even erroneous ones, have a tendency to be self-perpetuating because they can "grow their own legs." That is, people often add new reasons and justifications to support the wisdom of commitments they have already made. As a consequence, some commitments remain in effect long after the conditions that spurred them have changed. This phenomenon explains the effectiveness of certain deceptive compliance practices such as "throwing the low-ball."

Another advantage of commitment-based tactics is that simple reminder of an earlier commitment can regenerate its ability to guide behaviour, even in novel situations. In addition, reminders do more than restore the commitment's vigor, they appear to intensify it by strengthening one's related self-image.

To recognise and resist the undue influence of consistency pressures on our compliance decisions, we should listen for signals coming from 2 places within us: our stomachs and our heart or hearts. 

  • Stomach signs - appear when we realise we are being pushed by commitment and consistency pressures to agree to requests we know we don't want to perform. Under these circumstances, it is best to explain to the requester that such compliance would constitute a brand of foolish consistency in which re prefer not to engage.
  • Heart-of-heart signs - are different. They are best employed when it is not clear to us that an initial commitment was wrongheaded. Here, we should ask ourselves a crucial question: "Knowing what I now know, if I could go back in time, would I make the same commitment?" One informative answer may come as the first flash of feeling registered. 

Commitment and consistency tactics are likely to work especially well on members of individualistic societies, particularly those who are over 50 years old, who, hence, should be particularly wary of their use. 


Chapter 8 - Unity: The "We" Is the Shared Me

People say yes to someone they consider one of them. The experience of "we"-ness (unity) with others is about shared identities - tribe-like categories that individuals use to define themselves and their groups, such as race, ethnicity, nationality, and family, as well as political and religious affiliations.

Research into "we"-groups has produced 3 general conclusions.
  1. Members of these groups favour the outcomes and welfare of fellow members over those of nonmembers,
  2. "We"-group members also use the preferences and actions of fellow members to guide their own, which enhances group solidarity.
  3. Finally, such partisan tendencies have arisen, evolutionarily, as ways to advantage our "we"-groups and, ultimately, ourselves.
These 3 constants have surfaced in a wide range of domains, including business, politics, sports, and personal relationships.

The perception of belonging together with others is one fundamental factor leading to feelings of "we"-ness. This perception is generated by commonalities of kinship (amount of genetic overlap) as well as by commonalities of place (including one's home, locality, and region). 

The experience of acting together in unison or coordination is a second fundamental factor leading to a sense of unity with others. Shared musical experience is one way people can act together and feel consequent unity. Other ways involve repeated reciprocal exchange, joint suffering, and co-creation.

It may be possible to use the unifying effects of belonging together and acting together to increase the odds of getting together as a species. It would require choosing to share, with out-group members, family experiences in our communities, and friendship experiences in our social interactions.

Other kinds of connections involving national identity, mutual enemies, joint emotional experience, and shared perspective can also lead to feelings of unity with out-group members; unfortunately, they are often short-lived. However, focusing concentrated, repeated attention on such connections may make them more enduring by increasing their perceived importance.


Chapter 9 - Instant Influence: Primitive Consent for an Automatic Age

Modern lift is different from that of any earlier time. Owing to remarkable technological advances, information is burgeoning, alternatives are multiplying, and knowledge is exploding. In this avalache of change and choice, we have had to adjust. One fundamental adjustment has come in the way we make decisions. Although we all wish to make the most thoughtful, fully considered decision possible in any situation, the changing form and accelerating pace of modern life frequently deprive us of the proper conditions for such a careful analysis of all the relevant pros and cons. More and more, we are forced to resort to another decision-making approach - a shortcut approach in which the decision to comply (or agree or believe or buy) is made on the basis of a single, usually reliable piece of information. The most reliable and, therefore, more popular such single triggers for compliance are those described in the book. they are commitments, opportunities for reciprocation, the compliant behaviour of similar others, feelings of liking or unity, authority directives, and scarcity information.

Because of the increasing tendency for cognitive overload in our society, the prevalence of shortcut decision-making is likely to increase proportionately. Compliance professionals who infuse their requests with one or another of the levers of influence are more likely to be successful. The use of these levers by practitioners is not necessarily exploitative. It only becomes so when the lever is not a natural feature of the situation but is fabricated by the practitioner. In order to retain the beneficial character of shortcut response, it is important to oppose such fabrication by all appropriate means.


 


In 'The Serendipity Mindset - The Art and Science of Creating Good Luck', Christian Busch explains that serendipity isn’t about luck in the sense of simple randomness. It’s about seeing links that others don’t, combining these observations in unexpected and strategic ways, and learning how to detect the moments when apparently random or unconnected ideas merge to form new opportunities. Busch explores serendipity from a rational and scientific perspective and argues that there are identifiable approaches we can use to foster the conditions to let serendipity grow.

Drawing from biology, chemistry, management, and information systems, and using examples of people from all walks of life, Busch illustrates how serendipity works and explains how we can train our own serendipity muscle and use it to turn the unexpected into opportunity. Once we understand serendipity, Busch says, we become curators of it, and luck becomes something that no longer just happens to us—it becomes a force that we can grasp, shape, and hone. Full of exciting ideas and strategies, The Serendipity Mindset offers a clear blueprint for how we can cultivate serendipity to increase innovation, influence, and opportunity in every aspect of our lives.

Dr Christian Busch, is an internationally known expert in the areas of innovation and entrepreneurship. He is the Director of the Global Economy Program at New York University’s Center for Global Affairs, and also teaches at the London School of Economics. A cofounder of Leaders on Purpose and the Sandbox Network – and former co-director of the LSE’s Innovation Lab – he has worked with senior executives around the world.


Key Learnings

Optimism. Open-mindedness. Curiosity. Perseverance. Adaptability. These are some of the core qualities of the serendipity mindset. With this mindset, you can seek out and embrace the unexpected and use these unusual moments to make new and exciting connections. When you begin to see the world with this frame of mind, you’ll begin to see that each and every day is filled with the unexpected, and chances to spark new serendipitous ideas and innovations. This holds true for businesses as well. With a few changes to culture and environment, you can begin to set the stage for more innovation and fortuitous events to transpire.


There are several kinds of serendipity, but they're all different than "blind" luck of the draw - they're about creating "smart luck"

What is serendipity? The word itself dates back to 1754 when British writer Horace Walpole used it to describe a kind of discovery that was made unexpectedly, by accident, or through a certain foresighted wisdom known as 'sagacity'. This definition has more or less stood the test of time. However, think of serendipity as a positive occurrence, one made when your actions collide with chance. This means serendipity is different from pure chance, or luck on its own.

Generally speaking, there are three types of serendipity:

1. The first is Archimedes Serendipity. 
This is when you’re looking for a solution to a specific problem and the solution arrives in an unexpected way.
The name comes from the story of how Archimedes solved the problem of King Hiero’s crown. King Hiero had hired a goldsmith to make a crown – and he’d given him a precise amount of gold to make it from. The goldsmith forged the crown, and it weighed exactly as much as the gold he’d been given, but King Hiero grew suspicious. What if it was a forgery? So Hiero called upon the brilliant Archimedes to test its authenticity. Archimedes thought it over. And during his brainstorming, he went to the public baths. Here, serendipity struck. Archimedes noticed how the water levels rose as people lowered themselves into the baths – and, in a flash, he knew how to test the crown. Gold is denser than silver. This means that, if a pure-silver crown and a pure-gold crown weighed the same amount, the pure-silver crown would be larger. And a larger crown would displace more water than a smaller crown. Thus, Archimedes correctly reasoned, if Hiero’s crown had been diluted with silver, it would displace more water than if it were pure gold.

2. The second type of serendipity is Post-It Note Serendipity. 
This is when a solution is unexpectedly found for a problem that wasn’t even being considered at the time.
The name comes from the Post-It note. They were invented when Dr. Spencer Silver, a researcher for 3M, was trying to develop a new type of strong glue. One attempt fell short. It wasn’t very sticky at all. But Silver was curious to discover the potential for this weak glue. It eventually became the perfect ingredient for the Post-It Note.

3. The third type is the Thunderbolt Serendipity. 
As the name suggests, this is when you’re struck by a solution out of nowhere. You weren’t examining any specific problem or researching any particular solution. You were just going about your day when out of the blue an idea and exciting new opportunity presented itself.

Sometimes, serendipity might be a combination or variation of these types. But no matter what, these aren’t cases of blind luck. Hitting upon serendipity is something you can facilitate, as long as you have the right mindset.


Serendipity is usually about connecting dots that have previously remained elusive

How we interpret or look back upon serendipity is important. In fact, it can make a big difference in the likelihood of serendipity occurring in the future. For example, we shouldn’t think of serendipity as a singular event, even if it is one of those thunderbolt experiences. Instead, we should think of it as a process. Often serendipity is the result of seeds that were planted weeks, months, or years in advance. And it always requires something of you – whether it’s noticing a value that hasn’t been seen before, or drawing a conclusion that hasn’t been reached before.

One of history’s famous accounts of serendipity was the discovery of penicillin. One day, Dr. Alexander Flemming returned to the lab to find that some of the petri dishes had accidentally been left uncovered, sitting on a windowsill. He’d been working with an infectious bacteria and was surprised to find that the dishes had become moldy, and around that mold, the bacteria had vanished. Now, some doctors would have just focused on the mistake of leaving the dishes uncovered and gotten back to what they were doing in the first place. In fact, other scientists had already noticed that mold could kill bacteria, but they didn’t connect the dots and explore this any further.

But Flemming was curious. He saw the opportunity here. He was open to the possibilities and shared his ideas with trusted colleagues. This curiosity and openness was key to the serendipitous results. So, this is one of the first things to be aware of when it comes to cultivating the right mindset: being perceptive, curious, open-minded, and eager to see opportunities where others might see only negativity. This also requires an observant and perceptive attitude – the kind that not only notices something unusual, but can connect that bit of information with something else.


Being attuned and alert to serendipity means letting go of ingrained biases

Do you ever find yourself being a glass-half-empty type of person? It can happen to the best of us. In fact, having biases and preconceptions goes hand-in-hand with human nature, but that doesn’t mean it’s helpful in life. As far as serendipity goes, having strict, unbending preconceptions can be a big hindrance.

There are four biases that can stand in the way of serendipity:

1. The first is underestimating the unexpected. 
This is the kind of attitude where someone believes life is full of the predictable, the boring, and the expected. This attitude has been especially prevalent in the business world. Traditional strategy has generally centered around stability, and repeating what has worked in the past. But given the amount of data we now have access to, and how fast things are changing, it’s become clear that no matter how much you try to plan and prepare, the unexpected always happens.

2. The second bias is conforming to the majority. 
Again, this is a very natural bias to have. It’s safe and comfortable to stick to the majority opinions and ways of doing things. But this can easily lead to a self-censoring herd mentality that isn’t conducive to taking advantage of unexpected developments. Christian Busch works as a consultant for businesses, and one of his practices is to find a high-traffic spot somewhere in an office where he can sit at his laptop and eavesdrop on what people are saying. It might be next to a break room or the water cooler. It gives him a chance to get a sense of what the culture is like at the company. Is it one that promotes free-thinking or stifles it? If people are getting together and talking about how foolish it was for someone to speak up at a meeting and propose a new idea, then he knows this is a bad culture for serendipity and innovation.

3. The third bias is post-rationalism. 
A big reason for being skeptical about serendipity is that we tend to look back at an unusual occurrence and spin it into something predictable. This is related to “hindsight bias,” and it’s a very human thing to do. It’s more comfortable to think of everything that happens as being a sensible part of an ongoing narrative, not as a bunch of random, chaotic events.

4. The fourth bias is functional fixedness. 
This is when you develop skills or a certain expertise and that becomes the only way you want to do things. In other words, you want every problem to have one solution.


To stay alert and motivated, remain focused on a meaningful north star.

What motivates you on a day-to-day basis, money or something more meaningful? Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs was developed by the philosopher Abraham Maslow over 50 years ago, but it’s left a lasting impression and continues to influence many of today’s social theories.

In short, Maslow’s hierarchy suggests that people are first motivated by basic things like food and shelter. Once that is covered, people are then motivated by sex and relationships, and only later on, when all the lower needs are met, are they concerned with loftier things like existential fulfillment. It sounds logical, but this is an idea that is currently being challenged.

There’s a good reason for people wanting to be purpose-driven rather than money-driven: it feels a lot better and is more rewarding in the long run. Putting your true values to the side in order to show up for your day job can be exhausting. It takes energy to hide your true self from nine-to-five every day. The better path is to be authentic, stay true to yourself, and find a way to mix purpose with a paycheck. This is important for serendipity as well, because an exhausted mind isn’t going to be eager to spot the unexpected and make valuable connections. Instead, it’s the focused mind – one that is fixed on a north star, or a guiding principle that cultivated serendipity.

Ideally, your north star is an ongoing purpose, interest, or curiosity that can continue to inspire you indefinitely. It could be as simple as helping those who are marginalised or disenfranchised.
With your north star in place, your serendipity will always have a purpose – you’ll always have a direction on how to act. So when the unexpected does arise, you’ll be well prepared on how to take advantage of it.


You can increase the chances of serendipity in simple ways.

Essentially, you want to create possibilities, and you can do this in a number of ways, no matter what your current circumstances are. There are many people who’ve sent out a mass email to everyone in their contact list, or to people they’ve never met, in the hopes of having a serendipitous result. You may be surprised to know how often this works. Other times, it may be a chance meeting in an elevator or in a Zoom conference, but such encounters require an optimistic willingness to take chances, be sociable, and introduce yourself. Patience is also required. Sometimes, it may take years before the business card you handed someone turns into a case of life-changing serendipity. 


There are easy steps for planting the seeds for serendipity to occur.

Having a strong and healthy network of diverse people helps plant the seeds for serendipity. This kind of network doesn't need to be massive, by it does need to be regularly maintained. While conferences and online platforms can be good for establishing casual connections, meaningful ones need to be kept in good condition through periodic emails, conversations, or some kind of communication to make sure they don't wither away.


Serendipity can take time to develop, so patience is often required.

Another characteristic of the serendipity mindset is grit, or perseverance. The road to serendipity is often paved with rejection, failed experiments, and near misses. Many entrepreneurs will tell you that they were turned away countless times before they finally found the idea that clicked with investors. You need tenacity. Not only because it can take time for the right opportunities to present themselves, but because it often takes time for your brain to connect those important dots. While having a good supply of diverse people around you can be a vital part of setting the stage for serendipity, it also takes patience and perseverance.


Fostering serendipity involves creating a safe space for the mixing of new ideas from diverse minds.

Increasingly, a lot of businesses are wanting to facilitate as much serendipity as possible. They know that things are changing fast these days and relying on stability and consistency just doesn’t make sense anymore. So, what kind of culture and structures do make sense? Basically, you don’t want the kind of company where people are ridiculed for coming up with new or ambitious ideas. You want to create a safe space, where people not only feel free to speak their minds, but where they can also feel free to experiment and fail without fear of being reprimanded or losing their jobs.

This kind of environment often needs to be inspired from the top down. So it’s up to the leaders to tell everyone that the company needs their voices and ideas in order to succeed. If serendipity is to occur, it’s going to require the free sharing of ideas.

Many companies are also forgoing the usual hierarchical structure to empower employees and get them to feel comfortable with making their own decisions. This is also a good move for fostering serendipity, as sometimes the window of opportunity for taking advantage of serendipitous moments is fleeting and requires quick action. 

Businesses are also taking down the walls that used to exist between different departments, and perhaps no company offers a better example of this than the animation studio Pixar. Understanding that mixing diverse ideas is key to innovation, the studio was purposefully designed to maximize cross-pollination between the three main departments – animators, executives, and computer scientists. Built around a central atrium, it forces these three departments to mix and mingle every day.

Ensuring your employees can interact and share feedback is vital. But it’s also important to listen to the customer. Don’t ignore feedback, even if it’s negative. With the serendipity mindset, problems, complaints, failures can be triggers for the most wonderful and creative outcomes.


 


'How to do Nothing' is an action plan for thinking outside of capitalist narratives of efficiency and techno-determinism. “Time is money.” It’s an age-old adage, but it’s taken on new relevance in today’s digitally-driven, 24/7 economy. Whether it’s work or self-improvement, we’ve come to believe that we should have something to show for our time. Anything that doesn’t produce value in those terms is simply too expensive. Writer and artist Jenny Odell, thinks it’s time to take a different approach. Never switching off, is a recipe for a bland and shallow existence where we simply follow the crowd and fail to do our own thinking. The result? A world of mediocrity, misery, and selfishness. Odell’s alternative is deceptively simple – doing nothing. Above all, this is a question of attentiveness. Learning to direct and focus our attention is a way of opening up an entirely new and deeper experience of the world around us. In the age of social media and its all-out assault on our attention, this is an act of resistance that might just change everything. This book will teach you why social media makes us behave like brands; what nature can teach us about attention; and how attentiveness to others can make us more empathetic.

This book is a New York Times Bestseller and was favorited by Barack Obama in 2019. The book is written by Jenny Odell, an artist, and writer who teaches at Stanford University and has been an artist-in-residence at Facebook, the Internet Archive, and the San Francisco Planning Department.


Key learnings

After the defeat of once-powerful labor movements in the 1980s, a new idea emerged: that all of us are capitalists. This notion eroded the separation of work and leisure. In today’s economy, every hour of the day is potentially monetizable, meaning that we’ve come to see “doing nothing” as a luxury we just can’t afford. That, however, is a mistake. When we pause and really engage with the world, we can find deeper, more satisfying meaning in everyday experiences.


When work and leisure become indistinguishable, doing “nothing” looks like a waste of time.

In the 1880s, American laborers began pushing for an eight-hour workday. They didn’t just want more time to heal their sore muscles, though. As a popular trade union song of the era put it, the purpose of the struggle was to secure “eight hours of work, eight hours of rest, and eight hours of what we will.” This was a demand for a life outside work – the right to do nothing in particular for at least one-third of the day.

In the twentieth century, reformers made the eight-hour workday a reality. Their laws remain in effect, but the distinction they drew between work and leisure looks increasingly shaky today. It was long assumed that economic risk was the business of capitalists and investors. Workers were expected to clock in, get the job done, and go home. Do that, they were told, and their positions and wages would be safe. This arrangement lasted as long as labor movements could enforce it through strikes and political pressure. That ended in the 1980s after a series of historic losses defanged once-powerful trade unions and workers’ parties.

In his 2011 book 'After the Future', the Italian philosopher Franco Berardi links these defeats to the emergence of a new idea – that we are all capitalists. This means that we can’t expect economic security. Just as companies navigate perilous markets in search of opportunities, we must compete against each other for one-time jobs or gigs. The way to thrive in this ultra-competitive gig economy is simple – never switch off. This isn’t just what critics like Berardi say, however. Take a notorious 2017 advertising campaign for Fiverr, a platform that helps users find freelancers to complete mini-jobs. As their ads put it, “doers” in today’s world “eat coffee for lunch,” run on sleep deprivation and happily interrupt sex to take calls from clients. Fiverr’s suggestion that these were good things was widely ridiculed, but the company hit upon one of the essential features of the gig economy – the disappearance of the boundaries between work, rest, and leisure. This shouldn’t surprise us. If the day consists of 24 potentially monetizable hours, time becomes an economic resource that’s just too valuable to be spent doing “nothing” or what you will.


Social media makes us behave like one-dimensional brands.

If we are all capitalists, it makes sense that we spend much of our time behaving like corporations. Thanks to social media, this work never ends. Even our leisure is numerically sifted and appraised via likes on Facebook and Instagram. We monitor the performance of our personal brands as though we were analyzing shares on the stock market. This profoundly alters the way we act when we’re online.

In his 1985 book 'No Sense of Place', the technology expert Joshua Meyrowitz explored the effect of electronic media on social behavior. Despite its age, it’s an eerily prescient analysis of social media. In the 1950s, Meyrowitz went on a three-month trip. When he returned, he was eager to talk about his adventure. He didn’t tell everyone the same story, however. His parents heard the “clean” version, his friends got the racier one, and his professors were given the “cultured” narrative.

All these different editions were equally true – they were just tailored to different audiences or contexts. But now imagine his parents had thrown a surprise party on his return and invited all these groups. Meyrowitz ventures that this would have gone one of two ways: he would have either offended one group or created a new account “bland enough to offend no one.” This is context collapse – the fact that everyone is always in the same room at the same time. The disappearance of different contexts goes even further in our own digital age. Today, our online audience knows so much about us that it’s extremely difficult to project different definitions of ourselves to different groups. The result? Awkward acts, like taking unpopular positions or admitting mistakes in public, come to be seen as weaknesses and liabilities. Ultimately, this means we create a version of ourselves that’s acceptable to everyone at all times – a personality with the edges smoothed off.

This isn’t just a race to the mediocre bottom, though. It also runs against something that’s completely normal and human – changing over time. But that’s the point. Social media isn’t designed to foster human expression and dialogue. It functions as a tool for personal brand management, and the two pillars of any brand identity are internal coherence and continuity over time.


If we want to live more meaningful lives, we need to reappraise what is valuable.

Today’s economy doesn’t have an off button. Every moment of every day is a financial resource to be captured, optimized, and appropriated. Snooze and you can expect to lose. But despite this obsession with creating measurable value and optimizing every facet of life, many people still recognize a different truth. This holds that meaning is often the product of accidents, chance, and serendipitous encounters – the very “off-time” our 24/7 cult of productivity attempts to eliminate.

In the fourth century BC, the Chinese philosopher Zhuang Zhou penned a story called “The Useless Tree.” In it, a carpenter comes across a large and ancient oak. He deems this tree to be worthless because its old, gnarled branches aren’t any good for timber. Later, the tree appears in the carpenter’s dreams and quizzes him on his definition of usefulness. Timber trees, the oak argues, are very “useful,” yet these trees are invariably felled in their prime by humans. “If I had been of some use,” the oak then asks, “would I have grown this large?” Uselessness, it seems, can be useful after all – you just have to take the oak’s perspective. This point, the oak concludes, is missed by those who only see potential timber when they look at trees.

Zhuang’s oak has a real-life counterpart. The hills above San Francisco Bay near the author’s home in California were once full of towering, thousand-year-old Sequoia redwoods. During the 1850s gold rush, however, loggers felled all these ancient giants – except for one. Today, this wizened redwood is known as “Old Survivor,” and it has a lesson for us. Old Survivor was able to escape the fate of its neighbors for two reasons. First off, it was too twisted to entice loggers. Secondly, it was perched on a steep, rocky slope that reinforced the idea that cutting this tree down just wasn’t worth the bother. In other words, Old Survivor was too weird and too difficult to proceed easily toward the sawmill.

This is a great example of what the author calls resistance-in-place – making yourself into a shape that resists being appropriated by the dominant system. Just as the worth of trees doesn’t have to be measured by their suitability for timber, value in our lives doesn’t have to be measured in terms of productivity. 


Doing nothing allows you to truly pay attention to the world.

One evening in 2015, just before sunset on a cliff overlooking the Pacific ocean, a greeter checked guests into an area of foldout chairs cordoned off with red rope. After being shown to their seats and reminded not to take photographs, they watched the sunset. As it disappeared below the horizon, they applauded and refreshments were served. This strange scene was part of an artwork by Scott Polach entitled 'Applause Encouraged' and it neatly encapsulates an important aspect of doing nothing. Polach’s work didn’t create the sunset – it drew attention to it. This makes the work a great example of what the author terms 'attention-holding architecture'. This is a framing device that encourages the kind of sustained contemplation that habit, familiarity, and distraction often close off.

Attention-holding architecture comes in different forms. One of the author’s favorite examples is a public garden near her Oakland home, the Morcom Amphitheater of Roses. Nestled into the side of a hill, the bowl-shaped garden contains dozens of branching paths that wind their way through and around roses, trellises, and oak trees. There are hundreds of ways to navigate this space and just as many places to sit. It’s designed to hold your attention – the garden wants you to stay awhile and lose yourself in its sights and fragrances. It’s also possible to think about this concept in a more abstract way. Take the practice of deep listening. This was developed by American musician and composer Pauline Oliveros as part of her search for inner peace during the turbulent years of the war in Vietnam. According to Oliveros, hearing, and listening refer to different things. The former is simply the physiological means of perceiving sound. Listening, by contrast, means directing your attention to sound and its psychological significance. Deep listening, in other words, is a metaphorical architecture encouraging us to be more receptive to the world.

You can see how this works if you think about birdwatching. Oftentimes, when the birds are hidden, birdwatchers aren’t actually watching anything – they’re listening. And the first step toward being able to distinguish different birdsongs is breaking a wall of meaningless sound into discrete units. Like the sunset, these sounds are already there, but they only become perceptible and meaningful when you stop and do nothing but pay close attention to the world.


The brain usually only notices a tiny part of the data it processes, but silence can help widen your perspective.

Attention is like breathing. It’s always there, in the background. When you do notice it, you might be surprised to discover how shallow it is. And just as mindful breathing can train you to consciously deepen your breath, it’s possible to train yourself to be more attentive. The trick is realizing just how much your brain is already processing. In the 1990s, Arien Mack and Irvin Rock, two psychologists based at Berkeley University, designed an experiment to get to the bottom of 'inattentional blindness' – the things we don’t see because we’re not paying attention. They asked subjects to look at a cross on a screen and say if one of the two lines was longer than the other. This was just a decoy, however. As participants studied the crosses, small stimuli flashed up on their screens. When these were within the area circumscribing the cross, subjects were aware of them. When they fell outside this area, they went unnoticed.

The idea that we notice things when they’re in our field of vision makes intuitive sense, but there’s more to it than that. When stimuli outside the area took particularly distinctive forms like a subject’s name, they did notice it. But when these stimuli were made less distinctive, like spelling out “Janny” instead of “Jenny,” they once again went unnoticed. Mack and Rock concluded that the brain processes far more information than they had assumed and was only deciding later on whether stimuli would be perceived or not. This suggests that attention is like a key – it’s the means by which the door dividing unconscious and conscious perception is unlocked. So how do you find this strange key? Well, try embracing silence. 

Take the composer John Cage’s work 4’33”, a three-movement piece in which a pianist sits in front of her instrument without playing a single note. Every time it’s performed, the audience becomes attuned to the ambient sounds of a concert hall. Suddenly, they hear the musical potential of a cough or a scraping chair. This was Cage’s intention. As he put it, “everything we hear is music.”Walk down the street with this idea in your mind and there’s a good chance you’ll experience familiar scenes with newfound clarity. Like taking a conscious deep breath after years of shallow breathing, you might just wonder how you’ve never really heard any of these sounds before.


Choosing to be attentive to others takes the sting out of frustrating everyday experiences.

Imagine you’re sitting in your car at an intersection. You’re late for work and the traffic is hell today. Then, just as the light turns green, another car suddenly dashes in front of you and cuts you off. How do you react? Chances are, you’re going to focus on your own experience – in this case, the inconvenience caused by someone else’s reckless selfishness. But say you learned that the other driver was rushing their injured child to the hospital – you’d probably look at the situation differently, right? In most cases, it’s impossible to know what really motivates other people’s actions, but considering the possibilities can improve your experience of the world.

In 2005, the American novelist David Foster Wallace gave a commencement speech at Kenyon College, Ohio. In it, he offered graduating students a bleak sketch of what adult life had in store for them. Time and again, he said, they would find themselves in hideously, fluorescently lit supermarkets at the end of long days at work and terrible traffic jams. When this happened, they would have two choices.The first was to see the world only from their own point of view. When you do this, everything is about your own hunger, tiredness, and desire to get home. From this perspective, other people – whether it’s other road users, fellow shoppers, or sales clerks – appear simply as obstacles. This, Wallace suggested, is a surefire recipe for irritation and misery.

But there is an alternative. When you pause to pay attention and think through other people’s possible motivations, you begin to see that their lived realities are just as complex and deep as your own. The woman in front of you who just snapped at you, for example, might not always be like this. She might just be having a rough day. Maybe her dad just died, or an unexpected bill left her short for the month.It doesn’t really matter whether this is true. The point, Wallace argued, is that this kind of attention to possibilities transforms the way you perceive others. Rather than seeing them as things in your way, you begin to see them as fellow inhabitants of a shared space in which your interests are no more or less important than anyone else’s. This ultimately makes it possible to experience even a crowded, loud, slow, consumer-hell-type situation as meaningful.




The End of Power: From Boardrooms to Battlefields and Churches to States, Why Being in Charge Isn't What It Used to Be, written by Moisés Naím, discusses the decline of power in established leaders and institutions. The book's overall theme points out while it is becoming easier to get power, it is also becoming harder to use it to control others and harder to keep it once you have it. Naim suggests that globalisation, economic growth, a growing global middle class, the spread of democracy, and rapidly expanding telecommunications technologies have changed our world. He says these developments have created a fluid and unpredictable environment which has unsettled the traditional dominions of power.

Moisés Naím is a best-selling author, and an internationally syndicated columnist. He is the editor of the influential magazine Foreign Policy, published by the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Foreign Policy magazine is a leading publication on international politics and economics. Naim has written extensively on economic reforms, the political economy of international trade and investment, and globalisation. He was formerly Venezuela's minister of trade and industry.





Personal note:
It’s interesting that this book was written in 2013 and it’s as though it predicted a lot of the events that have happened not long ago, in particular the dissipation of power in politics, such as Trump’s takeover of the Republican party and Brexit. Another interesting thing that I found in the book, Naim talks about when power changes hands quickly, the players become inefficient. When power dissipates, even mature democracies can be left unable to react to the fast-paced challenges of the twenty-first century. I can see that in my home country Australia. Australia is guilty of burning through so many prime ministers, Scott Morrison replaced Malcom Turnbull who replaced Tony Abbott who replaced Kevin Rudd who replaced Julia Gillard. The so often changing of the guards leads to the weakening of power. The absence of a powerful international authority makes it near impossible to reach the agreements necessary to make important global changes, in particular the reduction greenhouse gas emissions. Another thing that Naim talks about that rings true is, the erosion of power reduces the incentive to invest time and effort in crucial issues, because those issues’ long term consequences aren’t immediately apparent. Instability makes engaging in long-term learning and improvement an unattractive proposition. Instead, players prefer short-term goals. This is evident in the world’s shocking lack of preparation and disorganised response to the coronavirus pandemic. A lot of these learnings seem prophetic when you think of it in the context that it was written in 2013. It’s interesting to see that the trends noted are continuing to happen however, I hope more of the positive trends of the erosion of power outweigh the negative in the years to come.


Key learnings

The erosion of power has led to many important freedoms, but has also made the world more dangerous. As power continues to be spread between more and more people, societies will have to re-evaluate whether the costs of democratised power outweigh the benefits of centralisation.


Power is crumbling everywhere.

Protesters have taken to Wall Street and other public places around the world to voice their concerns about the increasing concentration of wealth and power among the “one percent,” who in their view only grow more powerful as time progresses. Reporters and foreign relations experts have long made predictions about America’s decline and China’s rise to power. Yet when we examine political relations more closely, we see that something much more fundamental is happening to the distribution of power in the world. But first, what is power exactly?

In essence, power is the ability to make others do what you want them to do. Parents exert power when they make their kids eat their vegetables before they can have dessert. Power is at work when Barack Obama motivated large numbers of young people to become engaged with party politics in the 2008 presidential elections.

But power is also relational, and the traditional barriers that reinforced the position of the mighty and prevented potential rivals from becoming significant challengers are weakening rapidly. These barriers permeate our society. They are military arsenals, access to resources, available capital, brand recognition, the moral authority of a religious leader and the rules governing elections. Any challenger to power has to overcome them.

Yet while these barriers have always been present, they’ve become less and less stable over the last three decades. Capital moves more quickly, military weapons and training are increasingly available, the knowledge-base of academia is being democratised, and so on. Consequently, the traditionally powerful are having difficulty maintaining their position. Today, even the most powerful people and organisations can be ruined in a heartbeat. Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation, for example, was trashed practically overnight. The once esteemed Tiger Woods had his reputation dragged into the gutter just as quickly.One has only to look to the length of asymmetrical wars, such as Vietnam or the War on Terror, to see how flimsy something as seemingly cut and dried as military might can be. But why has the nature and distribution of power changed so drastically?


Things become more difficult to control when we have more of them.

Today, all kinds of “things” have increased dramatically in quantity. There are four times as many nations today as there were in the 1940s. The amount of wealth in emerging countries has risen enormously, and the number of products in the world market has followed suit. Not only do we have more, but those things that are the most important to us have also improved dramatically. For instance, people today live longer and more healthily than ever before. Life expectancy has risen, and fatalities from infectious diseases and armed conflicts have decreased. People are increasingly informed and educated, literacy rates have risen noticeably and people throughout the world are connected in unprecedented numbers.

And as we become more numerous and our lives become more fulfilled, we also become more difficult to control. Exploitation relies on destitution, and those who no longer have to fight for their daily survival and have received an education are more likely to make higher demands of their leaders, while also being less easy to force into submission.

What’s more, the immense amounts of information, goods and choices make it impossible to exert strict control over any one domain. When people have more control over what they buy, how they vote, what they read, whom they talk to, where they go, what they think, etc., they become difficult to control. This is true no matter whether they’re voters, soldiers, customers or believers. Those in power thus face new dilemmas: How do you ensure loyalty when choice is more plentiful? How can you coerce someone when force is costly and risky? How can you exert authority when people are less dependent and vulnerable?


Today’s world citizens enjoy unprecedented and uncontrollable mobility.

(Although, maybe not so much since the coronavirus pandemic, this was written in 2013)

During the Cold War, East Germany’s Berlin Wall and border inhibited its citizens’ access to West Germany. This was an internal power play: the Wall was a crucial aspect to the state’s campaign to control the people. Had they had the chance, many East Germans would have likely emigrated to the West in pursuit of a higher standard of living. Today, a wall would not have been enough to cut them off from the world. Nowadays, people, goods, money and ideas can travel at previously unimaginable speeds at a fraction of the cost. Just think: the price of airline tickets that enable transcontinental travel within mere hours has dropped dramatically in recent decades. The price of shipping cargo is ten times lower than it was in the 1950s and money transfers continue to get cheaper. According to the UN, 214 million people migrated across the world in 2010 – 37 percent more than 20 years ago. The amount of money these immigrants send back home exceeds the world’s total foreign aid by five times. Government experts have a much harder time keeping track of these funds than they do foreign aid packages.

A further cost of this increased mobility is governments’ inability to control their citizens. Looking back to East Germany: if citizens managed to flee, they were locked out, unable to come back and spread Western ideas or vote. Today, in contrast, it’s common practice for expatriates to take part in national elections, like Turkish citizens living in Germany, Mexicans in the United States or Sudanese and Senegalese emigrants. In an age of mobility people have a new way of voicing discontent: they can vote with their feet. If they don’t like the circumstances in one country, company or church, they can easily go elsewhere. That’s exactly what East German citizens did in 1989 when they crossed the border en masse into the West and brought down the socialist government within months.


As mentalities change, everything that can be questioned will be.

In recent decades our notions of what is important have undergone a radical change. Formerly poor countries with an emergent middle class, for example, have to manage the expectations of these wealthier citizens who expect more from life than full bellies and a roof over their heads. As a result, liberal values, such as individual freedom, transparency, the right to property and fairness, have spread far and wide. Take marriage, for example, which was cemented as a traditional conservative institution. For hundreds of years, there was a wide consensus across most cultures that marriage was the highest bond two people could have, a holy vow that could never be forsaken without unspeakable shame.Within a handful of decades this age-old belief has become almost obsolete. Divorce rates are on the rise, and not only in liberal Western societies. Even the conservative Persian Gulf State of Kuwait has a divorce rate of 37 percent. In the United Arab Emirates it’s 26 percent.

The increasing demand for the implementation of liberal values goes hand in hand with a waning trust in the authorities to fulfil these demands. We can see how this happened in the United States, for example, where until the mid-1960s 75 percent of the population trusted their government to do what is right most of the time. In recent decades that number has plummeted to between 20 and 35 percent. This is quite poor for a system in which the citizens elect their own leaders. Even more radical discontent with authorities was exemplified by the uprisings across the Arab World in 2011, when leaders or dynasties whose power had gone unchallenged for decades were suddenly forced to step down, fight their own people or flee.


Political power is increasingly being shared.

The more people are involved in decision-making, the less influence each individual has. The same applies to the political power of nations and political leaders. Governments are losing power on many levels. Nations are increasingly having to share power among themselves, and the triumph of democracy throughout the world has led to higher power sharing within the nations themselves. In 1947, for instance, there were only 67 sovereign states worldwide. Today the UN alone counts 193 members. In the 1970s there were more than twice as many autocracies as democracies. Today that ratio has been reversed four to one.

Additionally, there is a tendency toward more frequent elections, which give more power to the electorate and increase pressure on political leaders to act. With frequent elections, politicians have to consider the effects of their actions or face early retirement.What’s more, due to the increasing fragmentation of political organisation, political leaders are finding their freedom to act has narrowed. Today, power is divided between more players, meaning that individuals have more opportunities than ever before to exert political pressure outside the boundaries of traditional political institutions.

The cultural and organisational barriers that separated political elites from everyone else are crumbling. Today, advances in technology and communication allow almost anyone to join the political arena and even become a major player. For instance, while it took journalists two years to finally bring down President Nixon over the Watergate scandal, today, thanks to the internet, anyone can start a scandal, and every low-level government employee can leak important documents.This added transparency has eroded voters’ trust in politicians while making those politicians acutely aware of the danger of public blunders. This further reduces their freedom of action and leaves them unable to effectively respond to challenges, which consequently makes them even less effective leaders.


Even the meek have substantial power in foreign relations.

Although we all know about the various insurgencies and guerrilla groups around the world, what’s surprising is just how powerful these micropowers have become. These micropowers are actors with relatively meager resources competing with other actors that possess an abundance of resources. The proliferation of weapons and military training to non-state actors has risen dramatically in recent years.Today, nonstate actors like al-Qaeda or Islamic State have relatively easy access to weapons that can shoot down planes, sink ships, or worse. As a result, they can inflict harm that is highly disproportionate to the low cost of these weapons. Combat skills no longer require traditional military training, either. Today, you can learn these skills at a rebel camp in Syria, a madrassa in London or a computer school in Tehran, thus eroding the state’s monopoly on combat skills. As a result of these developments, micropowers are increasingly able to significantly challenge megapowers in asymmetrical armed conflict.

The weaker side of every asymmetrical conflict between 1800 and 1849 won only 11.5 percent of wars. Compare this to the time period between 1950 and 1998, when they won 55 percent. This is partly due to the blurred lines between soldier and civilian. Traditional armies are easily identified and targeted by their gear and uniform. The opposite is true for the militias found in urban and guerrilla warfare, which makes it difficult for traditional armies to hit the “right” targets.

What’s more, micropowers now have new instruments of diplomacy available to them. For example, smaller states can challenge the decisions of broad coalitions through their veto power. The European Union, for instance, in contrast to the United Nations, grants single member states significant veto power. Even a country as tiny as Luxembourg can tie up a decision.Traditional, long-term alliances are also shrinking and being replaced with coalitions of the willing, i.e., short-term alliances formed to quickly reach a particular short-term goal.


Individual and corporate wealth are fluctuating enormously.

We’ve seen how changes in power dynamics have affected civic society. But what about businesses? They, too, have seen some major changes. Traditionally, large companies that sell a great variety and quantity of products could easily outcompete their smaller rivals. Unlike smaller companies, large companies could afford to invest in production technology to gain an edge. Companies with numerous branches could easily compensate for deficits in one area by moving capital to another branch. Moreover, investors were more likely to entrust their capital to larger companies, believing them to be more likely to pay them back.

Customers also used to prefer well-known brands with a reputation to unknown brands of unpredictable quality. For example, in 1947 the United Fruit Company started labeling their bananas with the name “Chiquita,” and created some advertising stories around it to increase sales. Chiquitas quickly became perceived as the “ultimate bananas,” and the brand was so successful that in 1990 the company officially changed its name to Chiquita. However, as the traditional barriers to entry erode, smaller players are becoming more competitive. Increased access to information and cheaper technology have helped small businesses to work under conditions that emulate those of their large-scale counterparts. Crowdfunding, for example, and other special instruments give them the high mobility of capital that used to be the privilege of larger companies.

In addition, consumers are increasingly willing to embrace new products from fresh, young brands with no scars or stretch marks. This could be due to the amazing rate at which today’s companies end up with muddled reputations. A 2010 study found that all companies’ are 82 percent likely to face a crisis that damages their reputation within the next five years, compared to a chance of only 20 percent in 1990.In the world of business, as with politics and war, the old dynamics of power have swung in favour of the smaller players.


Small churches, charities and media organisations challenge the big players in their fields.

The tremendous impact of crumbling power structures can also be found in areas that are less directly connected to political power, like religion and media. For starters, the religious landscape is becoming increasingly fragmented. New Evangelical, Pentecostal and charismatic Protestant churches draw Christians away from traditionally powerful religious institutions, such as the Catholic church.

Individuals are also becoming more influential in the world of philanthropy, upsetting the primacy of established charities. As of 2012, 81 American billionaires had signed the Giving Pledge, promising to donate most of their fortunes to charity. Many of them, including Bill and Melinda Gates, have established their own foundations, thus diversifying the field of existing charities. In addition, in response to the 2010 earthquake in Haiti hundreds of thousands of cellphone users donated millions of dollars by sending a simple text message. As individuals become increasingly capable of sending small amounts of money exactly where they want it to go, large charities lose the power to direct and control philanthropy.

Finally, new information technology allows everyone to be a reporter. The inexorable spread of the internet and camera-equipped smartphones has enabled billions of people to record, edit and publish their own news free from the control of established publications.Consider that in the United States, 15 newspapers disappeared every year from 2006 to 2011. On the whole, the industry has diminished by 43 percent since 2000. Where information was once controlled and disseminated by a few established sources, now anyone with a camera phone can be a reporter.


The decay of power yields certain benefits, but ultimately produces dangerous challenges.

The erosion of power certainly brings with it positive aspects: societies are freer, voters are better able to express discontent, ideas can move more freely and increased market competition benefits consumers worldwide. However, it also comes with some serious risks. For one, the decay of power breeds disorder and frustration. One of the state’s primary responsibilities is to guarantee a minimum level of stability and predictability, and a certain amount of power is necessary to accomplish this.

When power dissipates, even mature democracies can be left unable to react to the fast-paced challenges of the twenty-first century. For example, the absence of a powerful international authority makes it near impossible to reach the agreements necessary to make important global changes, such as reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

When power changes hands quickly, the players become inefficient. The large organisations that our societies rely on, such as political parties, companies, churches and universities, have accumulated a long history of learning through experience, which new players simply don’t have.

What’s more, instability makes engaging in long-term learning and improvement an unattractive proposition. Instead, players prefer short-term goals. Consider, for example, that if a company’s future is uncertain, they’re likely to launch products tomorrow for quick profit instead of launching an improved version in a month.

As a result, the erosion of power reduces the incentive to invest time and effort in crucial issues, because those issues’ long term consequences aren’t immediately apparent. For instance, when there are millions of self-made journalists reporting on every little thing, it’s hard to find the issues that are actually important. Low-effort contributions like pushing a “Like” button, donating $1 with a text message or signing an online petition take away resources from more effective solutions. A doctor can do a lot more for a crisis region by traveling there with Doctors Without Borders than she can by “liking” some posts on Facebook.


Participating in politics, understanding power, and resisting simple propaganda can shield us from harm caused by the end of power.

So how can we embrace the positive aspects of the erosion of power without falling prey to its threats? A good place to start is by simply changing our perspectives on the distribution of power. For example, when we talk about changes in power relations between major players, such as the United States and China, we often ignore the radical changes that contextualise this shift in power. While China is supposedly “on the rise,” the power of nation states in general – and the big players in particular – is on the decline. China’s power is simply declining at a slower rate than that of the United States.

Second, be skeptical of the terrible simplifiers described by historian Jacob Burckhardt, i.e., those who would rather play on our irrationality than make serious arguments. Weakened political institutions, short attention spans and political frustration make it easy for leaders with dangerous ideas to stir up popular support without rational arguments. We must be on a constant lookout for these terrible simplifiers and be vigilant in refusing their influence.

Finally, we must increase political participation by strengthening political parties and leaders. The failure of international political cooperation – e.g., the inability to meaningfully reduce greenhouse gas emissions – is rooted in the weakness of political leaders at home. If we can strengthen our political parties by rebuilding them in a way that fits into our highly networked world, i.e., by making them flatter and less hierarchical, then we can increase their effectiveness and trustworthiness. 

If political parties and leaders are once again perceived as transparent, accountable and indispensable, they can reclaim their ability to inspire and mobilise the masses. Parties strengthened by public trust and participation can give our leaders the tools they need to respond to the global challenges of the twenty-first century.




© Christine Calo 2021. Please do not reproduce without the expressed consent of Christine Calo. Powered by Blogger.