Showing posts with label Innovation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Innovation. Show all posts


'How Innovation Works' by Matt Ridley, offers a systematic examination of this incredibly important but poorly understood phenomenon. What is innovation? According to Ridley, it is much more than invention (something often mistaken for innovation). Invention is the act of discovering an idea; it is merely a beginning, an inception point. Innovation is much more, it is when the invention is taken into the world and made practical. Innovation is the creative reconfiguration of multiple inventions and ideas into something new. Innovation is the act of fully exploring the consequences of that new thing and disseminating and integrating it into society and general use. 

Matt Ridley argues that we need to see innovation as an incremental, bottom-up, fortuitous process that happens as a direct result of the human habit of exchange, rather than an orderly, top-down process developing according to a plan. Innovation is crucially different from invention, because it is the turning of inventions into things of practical and affordable use to people. It speeds up in some sectors and slows down in others. It is always a collective, collaborative phenomenon, involving trial and error, not a matter of lonely genius. It still cannot be modelled properly by economists, but it can easily be discouraged by politicians. Far from there being too much innovation, we may be on the brink of an innovation famine.

Matt Ridley, 5th Viscount Ridley, is a British science writer, journalist and businessman. He is best known for his writings on science, the environment, and economics.


Key learnings

Innovation isn’t an instantaneous creative act practiced by lone geniuses. It’s actually a long, messy, and complicated process. Innovation occurs when chance encounters and serendipitous insights are shared, remixed, and built upon by countless individuals. New inventions are slowly and incrementally improved over time as people find practical uses for novel ideas. If we want more innovation in the future, we need to foster the open exchange of knowledge and take big risks as individuals, organizations, and nations.


Innovation is a complex, messy, and collective process

The Industrial Revolution – the giant leap in productivity that kicked off the modern era – began when humans first harnessed the power of steam to automate work. To do this, they used a new machine called the atmospheric steam engine. So, who do we thank for this astounding achievement? A man named Denis Papin. Or, wait, maybe we should thank Thomas Savery. Or, hold on, maybe a fellow called Thomas Newcomen deserves our praise? The truth is, all three men deserve some credit, but none of them can claim all of it. That’s because, around 1700, Papin, Savery, and Newcomen all produced their own working models of the atmospheric engine. To this day, it’s unclear who was truly first or how much each inventor influenced the others.

We often associate a new invention with a single creator. However, that’s an oversimplification of how innovation operates. Even the most creative people don’t work in a vacuum. They’re always influenced by the tools, technologies, ideas, and social structures that surround them. This often means multiple forces contribute to an innovation, even when one person takes the credit. Let’s consider the case of the atmospheric steam engine. This relatively simple device heats and cools water in a metal cylinder. The changing pressure caused by steam creates movement that can be used for work, like pumping water out of mines. Could Papin, Savery, or Newcomen have invented this completely on their own? Not really. The basic ideas behind the device were already hot topics of discussion in scientific circles at the time. Papin and Savery, both educated men, refined their thinking by exchanging letters and papers with other inventors. Moreover, Newcomen, who built the most successful version of the engine, relied on previous advances in blacksmithing technology to complete his machine. Thus, each man’s invention was also a product of their backgrounds and influences.

This principle applies to all innovation. While Thomas Edison gets credit for inventing the light bulb in 1879, the truth is, more than 20 other creators patented similar contraptions in earlier decades. All these thinkers were responding to ideas and technologies circulating at the time. Of course, some of these attempts were better than others, but none of these innovations happened in complete isolation.


Medical innovations offer high risks and even higher rewards

While the atmospheric steam engine kicked off the Industrial Revolution, medicine evolved with its own innovative procedures, like the following: Step one: Find someone recovering from smallpox. Carefully scrape some pus off one of the many open lesions caused by the disease. Step two: Using a knife or needle, cut an open wound into your own skin. Not too deep, but deep enough to draw blood. Step three: Rub the infected pus into your wound.

This technique is called engraftment. In most cases, it’ll make you immune to smallpox. If it seems gross and dangerous now, just imagine how it appeared to a European in the 1700s. They didn’t have a scientific understanding of why it worked, yet it did work. So, as the century progressed, the practice caught on. It saved countless lives and eventually led to the discovery of modern-day vaccines.

An interesting fact about innovation is that the biggest revelations don’t always come from deliberate discovery or sound scientific theory. Instead, they develop piecemeal over time through random chance, as well as trial and error, as people look for practical solutions to their problems. In the medical field, this is a particularly risky process, but it has resulted in many life-saving practices.

Consider Jersey City’s water supply. In 1908, rapid industrial development tainted the city’s water with unsanitary runoff. The result was serious outbreaks of cholera and other diseases. In a rush to fix the problem, Dr. John Leal added chloride of lime, a disinfectant, to the water. At the time, adding chemicals to drinking water was considered repulsive. Local citizens were outraged. But Leal had heard rumors of it working in European cities, so he tried it anyway. Within months, the experiment paid off, and disease rates plummeted. Soon, communities all around the country were following Jersey City’s example.

Are such open-ended experiments occurring today? Of course. Take the example of electronic cigarettes, also known as vaping. For many, picking up a vaping habit is the first step toward quitting smoking. Since tobacco use is a major cause of death, this could save many lives. Yet, we don’t fully know the health effects of vaping, so their use remains controversial. In some countries, like the United Kingdom, government agencies encourage their use. In contrast, other countries, like Australia, have banned it. Which country takes the right stance on this innovation? That remains to be seen.


Travel innovation is all about incremental improvements

The Salamanca, the Puffing Billy, the Sans Pareil. These names sound silly now, but in the early 1800s, each represented a small step toward improving the way we move. You see, at the dawn of the nineteenth century, the horse was the king of transportation. However, inventors believed a machine, the steam-powered locomotive, could take its place. The tricky part was figuring out how to build one. So, engineers tried a great deal of different designs, giving each new prototype a bold new name. Not every device succeeded, but some made subsequent improvements in speed, safety, or reliability. By 1829, the Rocket, a locomotive built by Robert Stephenson, was capable of transporting 13 tons of cargo at 30 miles an hour – and the world was on its way to a railway boom.

Throughout history, humans have always looked for faster, more reliable ways to travel. However, no new mode of transportation ever emerged in a completely perfect form. For example, the sleek, efficient machines that carry us around today are the result of countless individuals making innumerable small design improvements over time.

Look at the evolution of today’s automobiles. Most rely on the internal-combustion engine for power. Isaac de Rivaz, a Franco-Swiss artillery officer, built this machine’s earliest ancestor back in 1807. It ran on hydrogen and oxygen and was loud, clunky, and prone to explosions. In 1860, a Pennsylvanian man named Jean Joseph Lenoir updated the design to run on petroleum. This was a step-up, but the device was still very inefficient.

Next, in 1876, Nikolau Otto, a grocery salesman, refined the machine by adding a four-step cycle of compression and ignition. Dubbed the four-stroke engine, this model allowed for smoother operation. This design was adopted by the German inventor Karl Benz. In 1894, he amped up the engine’s power and used it to drive a three-wheeled machine called the Motorwagen.

While the Motorwagen was a hit with the rich, it remained a novelty. It took another inventor, Henry Ford, to bring the automobile to the masses. In 1909, his assembly-line manufacturing process made the Model T car affordable to more people. Soon, cars were one of the most popular forms of transportation around. It took decades of slow, steady improvement, but the engine had finally conquered the horse.


Some innovations aren’t solid things but simply good ideas

The humble potato is the basis for so many popular snacks and dishes we love today, but this wasn’t always the case. At least, it wasn’t in Europe. That took some innovation. First cultivated more than 8,000 years ago in the Andes Mountains of South America, the potato didn’t arrive in the Old World until the mid-1500s. However, for decades, Europeans regarded potatoes with suspicion. The church in England banned them. People in France believed they caused leprosy. Still, slowly, people learned to love this robust, nutrient-rich crop. The idea of eating potatoes first caught on in Belgium. Then the idea spread throughout the entire continent. By the 1800s, most European countries had made the potato a new staple of their cuisine.

Often, the concept of innovation gets reduced to invention. That is, we think of innovation as the process of making new tangible items like labor-saving machines or electronic gizmos. However, some of the most influential innovations of all time aren’t objects at all. Instead, they’re ideas that open up new ways to approach the world or solve problems.

One intangible innovation you use every day is the Arabic numeric system, more commonly known as numbers.
Yes, even the idea of using 1s, 2s, and 3s was once revolutionary. This counting system was first developed by Indian scholars around 500 AD. It was then adopted by Arab traders in the ninth century, and finally found a foothold in Europe in the 1200s thanks to an Italian author known as Fibonacci. Fibonacci advocated for using Arabic numerals because they were more practical than the Roman numerals popular at the time. Their key advantage was their positional system. While the Roman numeral V always means five, the Arabic five changes value based on its position in a sequence. So, a five followed by a zero means 50, a value ten times greater.

This seems like a small change, but it opens a whole new world for mathematics. With Arabic numbers, it’s possible to do more advanced calculations like multiplication, division, and algebra. It’s also much easier to keep financial records and do accounting. Adopting the idea of Arabic numbers was an innovation essential to launching Europe into a new age of trade, commerce, and scientific discovery.



Our desire to communicate drives rapid innovation

Baltimore, Maryland, 1843. The Whig Party holds a convention and nominates Henry Clay for president. It’s big news, and usually, it would take a train more than an hour to deliver the results to Washington, DC. But, this year, the message arrives in seconds. How? Thanks to the telegraph, a brand-new invention installed by Samuel Morse. It transmits information by sending electrical signals through a suspended wire. It’s the first practical innovation in the emerging field of electrified communication technology. The telephone arrives a few years later, in 1876. The wireless radio soon follows in the 1890s.

By the turn of the century, distant people are more connected than ever before. However, this is just the beginning. Over the following decades, innovations in communication and information technology will revolutionize the world. Before Morse tapped out the first dots and dashes through a telegraph, communication was either conducted face-to-face or through physical objects like letters and books. Ideas spread more slowly, and accessing information depended on which printed materials you could actually get your hands on. However, the advent of electronic communication like the telegraph, telephone, and eventually computers changed everything – and fast.

It’s hard to overstate how quickly new communication technology was adopted. The first telegraph line was completed in 1844. By 1855, there were 42,000 miles of lines in the United States alone. By the end of the 1870s, telegraph cables stretched across the Atlantic and Pacific oceans. Broadcast radio has a similar trajectory. It began with a single station in 1900 and grew to be the dominant form of public communication by the 1930s.

Computers also became an essential part of daily life at an astounding rate. This is partially due to how quickly computer technology improved and miniaturized. A computer’s processing ability is determined by how many transistors it has. Incremental improvements make transistors smaller and easier to produce, steadily allowing for more transistors to be housed in less space. This phenomenon is sometimes called Moore’s Law. So, in 1975, the average computer chip had 65,000 transistors. Today, that number is in the billions, and they’re much cheaper.

With the internet now connecting all the world’s computers, sharing information is easier than ever. This innovation has changed the political landscape by giving a huge amount of power to those who control communication technology. Now, the world’s most influential companies are search engines like Google and social media empires like Facebook.


Innovation relies on chance, collaboration, and recombination

The non-stick pans in your kitchen, the Gore-Tex coats worn in extreme environments, the fluorine gas chambers in the first atomic bombs. What do these all have in common? They’re all innovations based on polytetrafluoroethylene or PTFE. PTFE was first synthesized in 1938 – by accident. A scientist researching refrigerants stored tetrafluoroethylene gas at sub-zero temperatures. The chemical solidified into a hard substance that was unusually stable and heat-resistant. It didn’t work as a refrigerant, but other scientists found that in other contexts, it could be used for so much more. This story of PTFE is useful because it demonstrates the complex way innovation actually works.

Every story of innovation is different, but if you look closely, you’ll see they often follow a similar pattern. Many of the greatest innovations begin with a bit of serendipity. Someone has a lucky break, an unusual insight, or random occurrence. Then, others pick up on the discovery and apply it to new situations. Through trial and error, they apply the new idea or invention in different contexts until they find a practical use.

Consider the modern practice of using DNA as forensic evidence in criminal cases. No one set out specifically to create this innovation. Instead, it began in 1977, when Alec Jeffreys, a scientist at Leicester University, tried to develop a method using DNA to diagnose diseases. While collecting samples, he saw that DNA was a lot like fingerprints – that is, everyone’s genetic code was different. A chance discovery.

Meanwhile, the local police were struggling to solve a grisly murder. They wondered if Jeffery’s discovery could help solve the mystery. So, the scientist and the police worked together. They began collecting and analyzing more than 5,000 genetic samples from local suspects. They then compared them to DNA found at the crime scene. Eventually, they found a match. Case closed.

Because so much innovation follows this same pattern, it’s possible to identify conditions where it’s more likely to happen. Innovation thrives when people can cross paths, mingle, and exchange ideas. That’s why, throughout history, universities, trading hubs, and major cities have consistently produced novel innovations. By bringing different people with different expertise, perspectives, and cultures together in one place, these contexts foster the type of interactions that push innovation forward.


Innovation doesn’t always come from the top down

In 1924, the British government wanted to build a civilian airship capable of traveling across oceans. This raised the question: should the task be handled by the government or by private industry? They decided to try both approaches. Parliament contracted a government lab and a private firm, Vickers, to build two ships. How did this experiment play out? Well, by 1930, Vickers had designed the R100, a light, fast, and efficient aircraft. It traveled to Canada and back with no problems. Meanwhile, the government lab built the R101, a heavier, more costly ship. On its maiden voyage to Karachi, Pakistan, it only made it to France before crashing, killing 48 passengers.

These two very different outcomes illustrate an important point. When it comes to innovation, direct government oversight and control isn't always the answer. There’s a popular notion that innovation requires guidance and funding directly from the state. This argument posits that private industry, in a constant quest for easy profits, will avoid the costly research and development necessary to create truly new ideas. Instead, firms will hoard their patents and simply rehash old products. But is this true? Not exactly. While it’s true that government-directed research makes great discoveries, it often takes the ingenuity of private enterprise to turn them into practical innovations. Consider the internet. The basic components of computer networking were created by the Defense Advanced Research Project Agency, an American government lab. However, the world wide web didn’t take off as a household necessity until private firms like Cisco began to experiment with the technology in the 1980s and 1990s.

This dynamic occurs because big government projects often aren’t sensitive to the needs or desires of everyday people. Additionally, they can be slow to adopt new, outside-the-box ideas. However, big companies can also suffer this tendency. That’s why even giant firms are sometimes usurped by plucky start-ups.

Remember Kodak? This company was once the undisputed master of the photography industry. Film cameras were their flagship product. So, in 1975, when one of their scientists built an early version of a digital camera, his innovation was ignored. The higher-ups just didn’t see the potential in his bulky, electronic gizmo. Yet, smaller companies did. And they developed their own products, which took over the market. Thus, Kodak missed the digital photography revolution and filed for bankruptcy in 2012.


Innovation will always face resistance

Take a stroll through your grocery store’s dairy aisle. Here, you’ll see a wide selection of both butters and margarines sitting side-by-side in perfect harmony. The choice of spread is up to you. This wasn’t always the case. When margarine was first invented in 1869, it caused an uproar. The oily spread was both cheaper and more stable than butter. The dairy industry, fearing the competition, launched a vicious campaign against it. The National Dairy Council even faked studies showing it was dangerous. By the 1940s, two-thirds of American states had banned this innocuous staple.

Of course, the fervor eventually subsided, and margarine became an accepted foodstuff. Yet, this butter battle shows that even harmless new creations can stoke controversy. When a truly novel idea or invention arrives on the scene, it will often be rejected. This is because everyday people often fear change. Also, established industries don’t want to risk losing their supremacy. This is why horse breeders fought against tractors, ice-harvesters tried to stifle refrigeration technology, and some musicians initially wanted to ban radio stations from playing recorded music.

One way interest groups try to slow innovation is by sowing fears about safety and security. Consider the case of genetically modified organisms or GMOs. GMOs, such as vitamin-A-enriched golden rice, have the potential to bring cheaper nutrition to people all over the world. Yet, groups ideologically opposed to genetic modification, like Greenpeace, lobby hard against their production, citing sometimes flimsy evidence that these foods are dangerous.

Another way innovation is held back is through the overly aggressive application of intellectual property laws. When applied correctly, these laws, such as copyrights and patents, incentivize innovation by giving creators exclusive use of their ideas for a short time. This allows the original innovators to profit.

Yet, as we know, innovation requires sharing ideas and building on the work of others. Unfortunately, copyrights have been steadily extended, making this process more difficult. In the United States, a copyright used to last 14 years. In 1976, it was extended to last the life of the author plus 50 years. In 1998, 50 was extended again to 70 years. These laws no longer benefit the original creator post-mortem, but they do keep good ideas locked away from potential new uses.


Innovation is lacking in the West but booming elsewhere

In much of the world, the past few centuries have been filled with astounding leaps in innovation. In mere generations, Western countries have gone from largely agrarian economies to electrified, industrialized powerhouses. Even now, every day seems to bring novel developments in sectors like communications and computer technology.

Yet, alongside these changes, other sectors are strangely stagnant. In the realm of transportation, not much has changed. In 1958, the average commercial aircraft traveled at 600 miles per hour. Today, they move at roughly the same rate. There have been upgrades around the margins to aspects like fuel efficiency, but the fundamentals are untouched.

The business world, too, is less dynamic. In the United States, new businesses made up 12 percent of the economy in 1980. In 2010, they only accounted for 8 percent. Across the Atlantic, things are even staler. Looking at Europe’s 100 most valuable businesses, only two of them are younger than 40 years old. Most industries seem more focused on protecting current profits than bold new ideas.

So, where is innovation occurring? Mostly in rising nations like China. For the past few decades, this country has poured resources and manpower into urbanization and new technologies. Now Chinese firms like Tencent and Alibaba are at the forefront of growth industries like social media and financial services. Moreover, Chinese universities are making huge strides in fields like gene editing and artificial intelligence.

Can the Western world keep up? Maybe. It would require a renewed spirit of innovation. Companies will need to take more risks, workers will need to put in more hours, and governments will need to foster the free and open exchange of ideas that fueled past booms. All that, plus a little luck, will put innovation back on the agenda.


Image - Bright spark: detail of an 1879 illustration depicting Thomas Edison's lightbulb 
CREDIT: Getty Images

 


In 'The Serendipity Mindset - The Art and Science of Creating Good Luck', Christian Busch explains that serendipity isn’t about luck in the sense of simple randomness. It’s about seeing links that others don’t, combining these observations in unexpected and strategic ways, and learning how to detect the moments when apparently random or unconnected ideas merge to form new opportunities. Busch explores serendipity from a rational and scientific perspective and argues that there are identifiable approaches we can use to foster the conditions to let serendipity grow.

Drawing from biology, chemistry, management, and information systems, and using examples of people from all walks of life, Busch illustrates how serendipity works and explains how we can train our own serendipity muscle and use it to turn the unexpected into opportunity. Once we understand serendipity, Busch says, we become curators of it, and luck becomes something that no longer just happens to us—it becomes a force that we can grasp, shape, and hone. Full of exciting ideas and strategies, The Serendipity Mindset offers a clear blueprint for how we can cultivate serendipity to increase innovation, influence, and opportunity in every aspect of our lives.

Dr Christian Busch, is an internationally known expert in the areas of innovation and entrepreneurship. He is the Director of the Global Economy Program at New York University’s Center for Global Affairs, and also teaches at the London School of Economics. A cofounder of Leaders on Purpose and the Sandbox Network – and former co-director of the LSE’s Innovation Lab – he has worked with senior executives around the world.


Key Learnings

Optimism. Open-mindedness. Curiosity. Perseverance. Adaptability. These are some of the core qualities of the serendipity mindset. With this mindset, you can seek out and embrace the unexpected and use these unusual moments to make new and exciting connections. When you begin to see the world with this frame of mind, you’ll begin to see that each and every day is filled with the unexpected, and chances to spark new serendipitous ideas and innovations. This holds true for businesses as well. With a few changes to culture and environment, you can begin to set the stage for more innovation and fortuitous events to transpire.


There are several kinds of serendipity, but they're all different than "blind" luck of the draw - they're about creating "smart luck"

What is serendipity? The word itself dates back to 1754 when British writer Horace Walpole used it to describe a kind of discovery that was made unexpectedly, by accident, or through a certain foresighted wisdom known as 'sagacity'. This definition has more or less stood the test of time. However, think of serendipity as a positive occurrence, one made when your actions collide with chance. This means serendipity is different from pure chance, or luck on its own.

Generally speaking, there are three types of serendipity:

1. The first is Archimedes Serendipity. 
This is when you’re looking for a solution to a specific problem and the solution arrives in an unexpected way.
The name comes from the story of how Archimedes solved the problem of King Hiero’s crown. King Hiero had hired a goldsmith to make a crown – and he’d given him a precise amount of gold to make it from. The goldsmith forged the crown, and it weighed exactly as much as the gold he’d been given, but King Hiero grew suspicious. What if it was a forgery? So Hiero called upon the brilliant Archimedes to test its authenticity. Archimedes thought it over. And during his brainstorming, he went to the public baths. Here, serendipity struck. Archimedes noticed how the water levels rose as people lowered themselves into the baths – and, in a flash, he knew how to test the crown. Gold is denser than silver. This means that, if a pure-silver crown and a pure-gold crown weighed the same amount, the pure-silver crown would be larger. And a larger crown would displace more water than a smaller crown. Thus, Archimedes correctly reasoned, if Hiero’s crown had been diluted with silver, it would displace more water than if it were pure gold.

2. The second type of serendipity is Post-It Note Serendipity. 
This is when a solution is unexpectedly found for a problem that wasn’t even being considered at the time.
The name comes from the Post-It note. They were invented when Dr. Spencer Silver, a researcher for 3M, was trying to develop a new type of strong glue. One attempt fell short. It wasn’t very sticky at all. But Silver was curious to discover the potential for this weak glue. It eventually became the perfect ingredient for the Post-It Note.

3. The third type is the Thunderbolt Serendipity. 
As the name suggests, this is when you’re struck by a solution out of nowhere. You weren’t examining any specific problem or researching any particular solution. You were just going about your day when out of the blue an idea and exciting new opportunity presented itself.

Sometimes, serendipity might be a combination or variation of these types. But no matter what, these aren’t cases of blind luck. Hitting upon serendipity is something you can facilitate, as long as you have the right mindset.


Serendipity is usually about connecting dots that have previously remained elusive

How we interpret or look back upon serendipity is important. In fact, it can make a big difference in the likelihood of serendipity occurring in the future. For example, we shouldn’t think of serendipity as a singular event, even if it is one of those thunderbolt experiences. Instead, we should think of it as a process. Often serendipity is the result of seeds that were planted weeks, months, or years in advance. And it always requires something of you – whether it’s noticing a value that hasn’t been seen before, or drawing a conclusion that hasn’t been reached before.

One of history’s famous accounts of serendipity was the discovery of penicillin. One day, Dr. Alexander Flemming returned to the lab to find that some of the petri dishes had accidentally been left uncovered, sitting on a windowsill. He’d been working with an infectious bacteria and was surprised to find that the dishes had become moldy, and around that mold, the bacteria had vanished. Now, some doctors would have just focused on the mistake of leaving the dishes uncovered and gotten back to what they were doing in the first place. In fact, other scientists had already noticed that mold could kill bacteria, but they didn’t connect the dots and explore this any further.

But Flemming was curious. He saw the opportunity here. He was open to the possibilities and shared his ideas with trusted colleagues. This curiosity and openness was key to the serendipitous results. So, this is one of the first things to be aware of when it comes to cultivating the right mindset: being perceptive, curious, open-minded, and eager to see opportunities where others might see only negativity. This also requires an observant and perceptive attitude – the kind that not only notices something unusual, but can connect that bit of information with something else.


Being attuned and alert to serendipity means letting go of ingrained biases

Do you ever find yourself being a glass-half-empty type of person? It can happen to the best of us. In fact, having biases and preconceptions goes hand-in-hand with human nature, but that doesn’t mean it’s helpful in life. As far as serendipity goes, having strict, unbending preconceptions can be a big hindrance.

There are four biases that can stand in the way of serendipity:

1. The first is underestimating the unexpected. 
This is the kind of attitude where someone believes life is full of the predictable, the boring, and the expected. This attitude has been especially prevalent in the business world. Traditional strategy has generally centered around stability, and repeating what has worked in the past. But given the amount of data we now have access to, and how fast things are changing, it’s become clear that no matter how much you try to plan and prepare, the unexpected always happens.

2. The second bias is conforming to the majority. 
Again, this is a very natural bias to have. It’s safe and comfortable to stick to the majority opinions and ways of doing things. But this can easily lead to a self-censoring herd mentality that isn’t conducive to taking advantage of unexpected developments. Christian Busch works as a consultant for businesses, and one of his practices is to find a high-traffic spot somewhere in an office where he can sit at his laptop and eavesdrop on what people are saying. It might be next to a break room or the water cooler. It gives him a chance to get a sense of what the culture is like at the company. Is it one that promotes free-thinking or stifles it? If people are getting together and talking about how foolish it was for someone to speak up at a meeting and propose a new idea, then he knows this is a bad culture for serendipity and innovation.

3. The third bias is post-rationalism. 
A big reason for being skeptical about serendipity is that we tend to look back at an unusual occurrence and spin it into something predictable. This is related to “hindsight bias,” and it’s a very human thing to do. It’s more comfortable to think of everything that happens as being a sensible part of an ongoing narrative, not as a bunch of random, chaotic events.

4. The fourth bias is functional fixedness. 
This is when you develop skills or a certain expertise and that becomes the only way you want to do things. In other words, you want every problem to have one solution.


To stay alert and motivated, remain focused on a meaningful north star.

What motivates you on a day-to-day basis, money or something more meaningful? Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs was developed by the philosopher Abraham Maslow over 50 years ago, but it’s left a lasting impression and continues to influence many of today’s social theories.

In short, Maslow’s hierarchy suggests that people are first motivated by basic things like food and shelter. Once that is covered, people are then motivated by sex and relationships, and only later on, when all the lower needs are met, are they concerned with loftier things like existential fulfillment. It sounds logical, but this is an idea that is currently being challenged.

There’s a good reason for people wanting to be purpose-driven rather than money-driven: it feels a lot better and is more rewarding in the long run. Putting your true values to the side in order to show up for your day job can be exhausting. It takes energy to hide your true self from nine-to-five every day. The better path is to be authentic, stay true to yourself, and find a way to mix purpose with a paycheck. This is important for serendipity as well, because an exhausted mind isn’t going to be eager to spot the unexpected and make valuable connections. Instead, it’s the focused mind – one that is fixed on a north star, or a guiding principle that cultivated serendipity.

Ideally, your north star is an ongoing purpose, interest, or curiosity that can continue to inspire you indefinitely. It could be as simple as helping those who are marginalised or disenfranchised.
With your north star in place, your serendipity will always have a purpose – you’ll always have a direction on how to act. So when the unexpected does arise, you’ll be well prepared on how to take advantage of it.


You can increase the chances of serendipity in simple ways.

Essentially, you want to create possibilities, and you can do this in a number of ways, no matter what your current circumstances are. There are many people who’ve sent out a mass email to everyone in their contact list, or to people they’ve never met, in the hopes of having a serendipitous result. You may be surprised to know how often this works. Other times, it may be a chance meeting in an elevator or in a Zoom conference, but such encounters require an optimistic willingness to take chances, be sociable, and introduce yourself. Patience is also required. Sometimes, it may take years before the business card you handed someone turns into a case of life-changing serendipity. 


There are easy steps for planting the seeds for serendipity to occur.

Having a strong and healthy network of diverse people helps plant the seeds for serendipity. This kind of network doesn't need to be massive, by it does need to be regularly maintained. While conferences and online platforms can be good for establishing casual connections, meaningful ones need to be kept in good condition through periodic emails, conversations, or some kind of communication to make sure they don't wither away.


Serendipity can take time to develop, so patience is often required.

Another characteristic of the serendipity mindset is grit, or perseverance. The road to serendipity is often paved with rejection, failed experiments, and near misses. Many entrepreneurs will tell you that they were turned away countless times before they finally found the idea that clicked with investors. You need tenacity. Not only because it can take time for the right opportunities to present themselves, but because it often takes time for your brain to connect those important dots. While having a good supply of diverse people around you can be a vital part of setting the stage for serendipity, it also takes patience and perseverance.


Fostering serendipity involves creating a safe space for the mixing of new ideas from diverse minds.

Increasingly, a lot of businesses are wanting to facilitate as much serendipity as possible. They know that things are changing fast these days and relying on stability and consistency just doesn’t make sense anymore. So, what kind of culture and structures do make sense? Basically, you don’t want the kind of company where people are ridiculed for coming up with new or ambitious ideas. You want to create a safe space, where people not only feel free to speak their minds, but where they can also feel free to experiment and fail without fear of being reprimanded or losing their jobs.

This kind of environment often needs to be inspired from the top down. So it’s up to the leaders to tell everyone that the company needs their voices and ideas in order to succeed. If serendipity is to occur, it’s going to require the free sharing of ideas.

Many companies are also forgoing the usual hierarchical structure to empower employees and get them to feel comfortable with making their own decisions. This is also a good move for fostering serendipity, as sometimes the window of opportunity for taking advantage of serendipitous moments is fleeting and requires quick action. 

Businesses are also taking down the walls that used to exist between different departments, and perhaps no company offers a better example of this than the animation studio Pixar. Understanding that mixing diverse ideas is key to innovation, the studio was purposefully designed to maximize cross-pollination between the three main departments – animators, executives, and computer scientists. Built around a central atrium, it forces these three departments to mix and mingle every day.

Ensuring your employees can interact and share feedback is vital. But it’s also important to listen to the customer. Don’t ignore feedback, even if it’s negative. With the serendipity mindset, problems, complaints, failures can be triggers for the most wonderful and creative outcomes.



Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy is a book on economics, sociology, and history by Joseph Schumpeter. It's one of the most famous, controversial, and important books on social theory, social sciences, and economics. Back in the 1920s, economist Joseph Schumpeter asked himself, 'Could socialism be an alternative? Should capitalism last forever? And is that even possible? In the quest for answers he came to a startling conclusion: by its very nature, capitalism is bound to destroy itself. In this book Schrumpeter gives his definition of democracy, his theory of creative destruction and his emphasis on entrepreneurship, much of his ideas have defined the economic theory of the twentieth century.

Joseph Alois Schumpeter (1883-1950) was an Austrian-trained economist, economic historian, and author. He is regarded as one of the 20th century's greatest intellectuals. Schumpeter is best known for his theories on business cycles and the development of capitalist economies, and for introducing the concept of entrepreneurship. For Schumpeter, the entrepreneur was the cornerstone of capitalism—the source of innovation, which is the vital force driving a capitalist economy.




Key Learnings

Capitalism is constantly evolving. It’s driven by a process of creative destruction, and that means that products, production methods, technologies, and markets restructure themselves incessantly. As capitalism progresses, these transformations increasingly threaten its very foundations, such as entrepreneurship and competition. At the same time, these changes can open up society and culture to socialist ideas. Capitalism will ultimately self-destruct and pave the way for socialism. Such socialism, given certain conditions, is in principle entirely operable – although running a democratic socialist society may present a challenge.


Karl Marx’s economic theories were prophetic – but they’re too stationary to account for modern capitalism.

In the social sciences, no figure looms larger than the German economist and philosopher Karl Marx. With his famous argument for an inevitable revolution, spearheaded by the working class, Marx became the great prophet of socialism. Indeed, for its proponents, Marxism is something like a religion. For better or for worse, they view absolutely everything through its lens. Why is that? Well, it’s in part because Marx’s ideas were indeed prophetic, or at least very much ahead of their time. For example, Marx was one of the first thinkers to suggest that what shapes our societies, actions, and attitudes is the economy. He was also among the first to recognise the cyclical nature of economic processes. He recognised that economic crises were inevitable and occurred at regular intervals. 

Schumpeter, recognised the prophetic qualities of Marx’s work – and he agreed that the great German thinker contributed greatly to the field of economics. But he maintained that there were quite a few problems with Marx’s conception of capitalism.

Marx argued that history is essentially all about a struggle between two – and only two – classes. On the one hand, there’s the working class, or proletariat. Its members sell their labor to the capitalists, or the bourgeoisie. These are the people who own the means of production. According to Marx, the capitalist system encourages business owners to make laborers work longer and longer hours, without necessarily paying them for it. Business owners therefore extract “surplus value” from the work of the proletariat. This is the foundation of profit – and over time, the proletariat loses out; the poor become even poorer. Enterprises, meanwhile, tend to become less and less profitable.

Schumpeter pointed to a few problems with Marx’s theory. 
  • First, it leaves no room for a third class of people essential to capitalism: entrepreneurs. Capitalism is driven by smart and energetic people who don’t necessarily belong to the bourgeoisie, but wish to ascend to it. With their ideas and innovations, entrepreneurs are constantly revolutionising the system from within. 
  • For Schumpeter, another issue is that Marxism is too stationary. It cannot explain the constantly evolving phenomenon that is modern capitalism.
  • Finally, Schumpeter sees no evidence that capitalism fuels oppression and poverty, as Marx held. In fact, capitalism has actually improved the lives of most people living under it.


Capitalism is responsible for great social and intellectual progress.

It would be foolish to diminish the progress that societies have made under capitalism. Indeed, in The Communist Manifesto, Marx himself praised capitalism’s many achievements. He argued that capitalism was a necessary historical stage, unavoidable before the triumph of socialism.

The most obvious form of progress that capitalism enables is, of course, economic. One way to measure this is to look at a country’s total production of all goods and services in a year. Let’s take the US, for instance. From the Industrial Revolution through to the 1940s – Schumpeter’s time – this total kept increasing, at an average of about 2 percent per year. With it, people’s average income also increased. And what’s more, contrary to Marx’s predictions, the income gap between the rich and the poor didn’t really widen – at least not until well into the twentieth century.

Capitalism’s economic progress made life better for many in myriad ways. As disposable incomes grew, for example, people began to spend more on personal goods and services that enriched their lives. And it wasn’t just that people started to earn more; their money actually went farther and farther. A car, for example, cost considerably less in proportional terms in the 1940s than it did in the 1900s. On top of this, products just kept getting better. That’s because companies weren’t just competing with each other on price – they also focused on quality and general standards. Think about something as simple as white stockings, for instance. In the nineteenth century, they were largely the preserve of royalty. By the 1940s, they were ubiquitous – even factory girls could afford them. 

Alongside all this progress, something else happened: capitalism, as such, became less costly. For example, practices like child labor and sixteen-hour workdays that defined the Industrial Revolution are generally gone. All in all, then, big business and even monopolistic practices have largely improved our lives. And capitalism didn’t just accelerate material progress. It also encouraged us to develop a certain economic rationality. The basic cost-profit calculation, which lies at the heart of capitalism, is now applied in such diverse fields as space exploration, medicine, beauty, and even justice. This “rationalization” of society gradually replaced the magic and mysticism of the old days. 

Finally, capitalism encourages hard work, innovation, and invention. This means that we have capitalism to thank for our high standard of living, our rational mindset, and our greatest inventions, such as refrigerators, airplanes, and even radio and television. 


Capitalism feeds on a process of creative destruction.

Capitalism itself is constantly progressing. Since it first developed, it has been expanding, accelerating, and transforming. And this is no accident. Indeed, this constant change is in the very nature of the capitalist system. For one, businesses and entrepreneurs are in constant competition with each other – or at least in constant fear of competition. This encourages them to restructure, invent, and innovate at an accelerating pace. You’re never safe at the top for long. Your business strategy may have worked yesterday, but it could easily fail tomorrow. 

And so every year we see the rise of new markets, new consumer goods, new methods of production. None of this innovation comes from nowhere: the novelty always destroys the old structures and grows right through them. Schumpeter popularised a new term, which he used to describe capitalism’s constant transformation from within. He called it the process of “creative destruction” – and, in his view, many economic theories, including Marxism, failed to take it into account.

For example, many economists seem to think that capitalism functions best in a state of “perfect competition.” This view is, of course, idealised, and it simply assumes that all companies in a market produce exactly the same product and compete only on price. Some economists say that big business practices have derailed the structure of perfect competition. But that view presupposes that such a state can exist in the first place. Schumpeter thought that such analyses were facile. He didn’t believe that the state of perfect competition ever existed. To him, competition was not based only on price – it also took into account product quality and advertising. And, above all, he viewed capitalism as a process. To him, the system was subject to constant innovation and destruction. So, then, you can’t really understand capitalism if you don’t take into account the process of creative destruction. And that means that capitalism has never really been static.


There’s nothing to prevent socialism from working.

For most of history, socialism has been considered the only viable alternative to capitalism. In a socialist society, the means of production are controlled by just one central authority, rather than by many private actors. Can this system work in the real world? Many economists have had their doubts.

In a commercial system like capitalism, the economy is controlled through constant competition. Companies, entrepreneurs, and bankers set prices, decide what to buy and sell, and hire and fire people. This means that, in theory at least, a capitalist market regulates itself. A socialist market is different. Instead of self-regulation, it relies on an external force – such as, for example, a political authority. One of its jobs could be to provide people with vouchers, each representing a citizen’s share of all goods produced in a country’s economy. In theory, this value is easy to set: you simply divide the total of all goods by the overall number of claimants.

Some economists, though, think that there’s a flaw in that plan. Here’s their question: Without price competition, how would you gauge the demand for a certain product? In capitalism, after all, prices have a really important role to play: they regulate supply and demand. But Schumpeter saw no problem with implementing a similar system under socialism. For example, the government could set up a pricing authority for each industry whose decisions would be based on customer demand. And as for consumers themselves, they could even receive different “incomes,” depending on how much they worked. Some of that may sound a lot like capitalism. But there’s a key difference here, and that’s the lack of competition. A socialist economy is not shaped by internal market forces. Instead, the way it works is all down to its central authority.

Logically, then, there’s no reason why socialism cannot work. Some economists acknowledge this, but they claim that there’s a difference between theory and reality. In practice, they say, socialism is simply inoperable. For one, a government could never have sufficient information to run a whole economy smoothly. But here’s Schumpeter’s counterargument: government’s decisions are no harder than those that businesses have to make under capitalism. Whatever the system, running it will always involve guesswork. For Schumpeter, the case is clear: of course socialism can work. But the questions is whether it’s compatible with democracy.


We need to update our definition of democracy to account for the realities of elections.

How well do socialism and democracy go together? Before we explore this, we need to ask ourselves what democracy is.

Is it some sort of ultimate good, as many people believe? Can it be an end, in and of itself, rather than a political method? Imagine a society that makes a democratic decision to reinstate witch hunts. Clearly, that would be appalling. So should we really consider democratic processes inherently good or bad? Often, democracy is simply defined as “rule by the people.” But as soon as we probe this formula, it begins to fall apart. First of all, most democracies don't involve all people – children and convicts, for example, are often barred from voting.

As well, in a democracy, people don't "rule" directly. Instead, they delegate their power to leaders who supposedly represent their interests. But here’s what often happens: as soon as these delegates get into office, they begin putting their own ambitions first.

The classical definition of democracy is a bit more complex. It says that democracy is a method of arriving at political decisions for the common good, by letting people elect their own leaders. But that presupposes that a common good is something that people can agree on rationally. And it also suggests that people can work out among themselves how to put decisions into practice. In our complex societies, that is clearly not the case. Even if we agreed that everyone deserves to be healthy, for example, people would still debate the benefits of vaccination.

In reality, we all have interests and values that are varied, irrational, and impulsive. Some of these values aren’t even our own – instead, they’ve been sold to us by advertisers or politicians. So, clearly, we need a new definition of democracy. How about this definition: Democracy is a way of making political decisions by letting individuals compete for people’s votes, in order to gain the power to implement those decisions. This definition may work better than the classical doctrine. For one thing, it makes room for the crucial element of democratic leadership – the fact that it’s politicians who rule countries, not voters themselves. Second, it makes clear that the role of the people isn’t to be the government, but to choose the government. And last, it leaves room for the fact that no democratic government can represent all people – just a majority of them. 


Socialism may be as compatible with democracy as capitalism – under certain conditions.

Throughout history, many socialists have said that theirs is the only path to “true democracy.” But some believe that it’s OK to use undemocratic methods – such as violence and terror – to create a socialist society.

There’s no direct relationship between socialism and democracy. They are neither mutually exclusive nor necessarily entwined. In Russia, for example, socialism was enforced by very undemocratic methods. But in Belgium, the Netherlands, and even England, socialist parties readily embraced democracy.

So what are the conditions under which a democracy can thrive? And is there anything that precludes socialism from creating them – especially after capitalism has laid the economic groundwork?

  • The first condition for the success of democracy is the availability of high-quality leaders. This means that the political sphere of a country should be accessible and appealing enough to attract the right kind of people – individuals who are smart, conscientious, and capable.
  • The second condition is that political decisions made democratically should stay within an appropriate range. The government should decide some things about public life, but not all of them. In fact, there’s no need to make all decisions democratically. For example, most countries appoint supreme courts outside the democratic process.
  • The third thing necessary for democracy is a well-functioning bureaucracy. It needs to be efficient enough to take care of all the mundane but important work that goes into democratic decision-making. 
  • And finally, a democracy only works smoothly if all people accept the way decisions are made, and are able to tolerate differences in opinion.
Schumpeter believed that democracy emerged as a by-product of capitalism’s rationalist ideology. But the four conditions for it can exist in either system – socialist or capitalist.

No system is perfect
, of course. For example, democratic decision-making can be inefficient in large and complex societies. In a socialist country, this may be an even bigger problem. After all, if you can’t make efficient decisions, how can a central body run an efficient economy? So it's possible for Socialism and democracy to coexist.


The key features of capitalism will ultimately lead to its self-destruction.

Let’s turn to the central question: Can capitalism survive?

Schumpeter answers this question with a resounding 'No'. He thinks that the very success of capitalism will be its undoing. It will create conditions for its own destruction and a socialist takeover. 

But how?

As we’ve already seen, capitalism uses the mechanism of creative destruction to push social and technological progress. But progress can only go so far. What happens if one day we find all human needs completely satisfied? What if we lose the motivation to keep pushing?

Under capitalism, progress is becoming increasingly automated and predictable. For example, capitalist progress diminishes the figure of the business owner. Instead, it hands over control to an impersonal structure of managers, executives, and stockholders. In such a world, where running a business becomes an abstraction, why even try? 

As the cost of living increases, and as businesses focus on small niches, not revolutionary innovation, there’s less and less incentive for true entrepreneurial leadership. Instead, there is growing demand simply for administration of already-existing processes. But this is something that socialism does just as well as capitalism.

Capitalist progress also erodes the mechanisms that used to protect the bourgeoisie. For example, it encourages a taste for anti-bourgeois ideas. The rationalist ideology of capitalism creates a critical frame of mind – and, in the end, it inevitably turns against itself. For evidence, just think of the many bourgeois intellectuals who now align themselves with the working class and are growing more and more hostile toward capitalism. 

And there’s another way in which capitalism destroys the very ground that nurtures it. The trend to rationalise everything has contributed to the decline of the traditional family unit. As this trend grows, more and more people will feel inclined to conduct a cost-benefit analysis of having children. As a result, they may well decide to remain child-free. If you don’t have children, you don’t really need long-term investments like property. And that gives you the incentive to earn, and save, less. That's no good for the constant economic growth that capitalism requires.

And so, just as capitalism raises our standard of living, gives us more leisure time, and makes us better educated, it also weakens our motivation. This is self-defeating and can destroy the very structures that underpin the capitalist system. Schumpeter believed that capitalism would, eventually, destroy itself and pave the way for socialism. But maybe that’s nothing to worry about – especially if we can figure out how to consolidate socialism with democratic values.


 


'Bounce Back - How to Fail Fast and be Resilient at Work' is written by Business Psychologist Dr Susan Kahn, this book shows you how to embrace failure. Failing fast, failing well, and learning how to be agile and resilient at work is a vital part of being a successful and innovative leader. This book is packed with practical exercises, case studies and it shows you how to invest in your resilience in a deliberate way, and empower you to face risk head-on. From learning how to respond well to critical feedback, to understanding cultural attitudes to failure around the world, this book attempts to help you, to be stronger and resilient.



Key Learnings

Success paradoxically means embracing failure. Falling short is a great way of learning, and it builds resilience over time. Add psychological clarity, physical wellbeing, stoic philosophy and a clear sense of purpose into the equation to be set for success. 

Refrain negative situations
We often look at the world in black and white terms: some things are clearly 'good' while others are simply 'bad'. 'Turning the Obstacle Upside Down' is a good exercise in helping you notice this. The idea is to reframe difficult situations as a sources of insight and development. 


If you want to succeed, you should accept that you’re going to fail time and again.

Whatever the industry, professionals and organisations benefit when they learn from their failures. This is because, contrary to conventional wisdom, failure doesn’t make you less intelligent or able. In fact, the most accomplished and talented individuals and institutions routinely experience failure. They recognise that, as the psychologist Denis Waitley puts it, failure isn’t an “undertaker” – it’s a teacher.

Take it from basketball star Michael Jordan, one of the most successful players in the history of the sport. Looking back, Jordan sees his career as a series of failures. He missed over 9,000 shots, 26 of which were potential game-winners. He failed time and again. “That,” he said, “is why I succeed.” Then there’s JK Rowling, one of the world’s most respected authors. Before Harry Potter became the global sensation it is today, her books were rejected by dozens of publishing houses. Or take Netflix. The on-demand video streaming service was first pitched to Blockbuster in 2000 for a fraction of its current value. Blockbuster turned it down. 

These kinds of failures provide a valuable lesson on the importance of self-belief and determination. Just think of Thomas Edison, the inventor of the lightbulb. He famously regarded each failure as a step in the right direction. With all these failed attempts he had found 10,000 ways that wouldn’t work. But even though failure is so important, not everyone will respond to it in an encouraging and supportive way. Some stakeholders, like bosses or clients, will inevitably be upset. So it’s very important to develop a system that encourages risks and failures, but which also avoids a breakdown in relations. Call it fail fast.


“Fail fast” can teach both individuals and organisations to make the most of failure.

The concept of fail fast comes from systems design. There, it denotes a technology that immediately reports issues likely to cause serious problems further down the line. When this happens, operations are halted so that the flaw in the process can be addressed. The idea was later taken up by businesses to describe the way they stress-test products early on. This gets failure out of the way, and it can prevent years of wasted investment. This is something we can also implement in our own day-to-day work.

There’s only one surefire way to avoid failure: don’t try anything new – ever. But playing it safe is a recipe for stagnation. We thrive when we feel challenged and excited by what we’re doing. Conversely, we stop producing our best work when we get caught in a familiar routine. So why do so many of us fall into the trap of familiarity? Well, once we’ve developed our expertise and become highly competent by mastering challenges, we suddenly become risk-averse. Being an expert feels good, and we’re reluctant to leave that hard-won comfort zone. After all, when we embrace a new challenge, we have to accept that we’re not experts in this new area. This in turn reintroduces the scariest prospect of all – failure. 

This is where fail fast comes in. The idea is pretty simple: the sooner we try something new, the lower the stakes will be if we fail. This makes it easier to get the dreaded experiment out of the way and gain valuable new insights. It also means we’re less likely to fail the next time around. Implementing fail fast systems is increasingly important in today’s world. As Sunnie Giles argues in The New Science of Radical Innovation, the twenty-first century work environment is characterised by four factors: volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity – or VUCA for short. In this climate, failure is certain. The organisations best placed to thrive don’t just tolerate this reality; they embrace it. In practice, this means that leaders encourage experimentation and set moderate challenges. These challenges encourage creative solutions while keeping the stakes tolerably low. But there is more to workplace resilience than failing fast. We also have to understand ourselves better. 



Your unconscious shapes your behaviour, and exploring your inner motivations can help you become more resilient.

It’s easy to assume that what we’re able to see is all there is to see. At work, for example, we might notice a manager ignoring a colleague’s contributions and inwardly condemn this disrespectful behaviour. What we can’t see, though, are the unconscious drivers of this behaviour. Maybe this manager is envious of the person proposing ideas. Or maybe he thinks that it’s his duty as a manager to have all the good ideas. Ultimately, it’s these unseen factors that explain how we act. 

Like icebergs, the greater part of who we are is below the surface. It is the hidden part of ourselves – the unconscious – that determines who we are. This idea goes back to the work of Sigmund Freud. According to Freud, our unconscious is a kind of repository of repressed childhood memories. And it shapes the way we behave. Let’s say we felt unsafe, envious, neglected, or abandoned in our early years. These feelings are likely to play an important role in how we view and act in the world as adults. Unconscious thoughts influence us in two ways. The first is called transference. Here, our response to individuals and events is shaped by past experiences. Say you find yourself blushing when the chair speaks to you at a board meeting. There’s a good chance that’s because his tone unconsciously reminded you of being humiliated by your teacher as a child.

Then there’s projection – attributing your own thoughts and feelings to someone else. This often happens when you feel those thoughts and feelings are wrong. You might feel hateful toward a colleague. This is an unacceptable thought, so you might make it palatable by deciding that they hate you. Essentially, you’ve projected your hatred onto the other person.

The best way to keep these kinds of unconscious thought patterns in check is to explore your inner motivations. Knowing who you are and why you respond to people and events in the way that you do will allow you to interact more productively and avoid unnecessary conflicts. This in turn will help you become more resilient. To do this, get into the habit of reflecting on workplace encounters that left you feeling wounded. Jot down everything that hurt you, and see if you can face the painful memory it brought back. Making unconscious thoughts conscious is the best way to break out of unhelpful behavioural patterns.


Sleep is the key to building physical resilience.

There are thousands of scientific reports demonstrating the health benefits of getting a good night’s sleep. Unfortunately, this is something fewer and fewer of us are doing. The World Health Organisation reports that a sleep-loss epidemic is sweeping through industrialised nations. This is a cognitive and emotional time bomb. Inadequate sleep wreaks havoc on our ability to concentrate, carry out complex tasks, and acquire new information.

Sleep loss also takes its toll on our resilience. Without the sustenance of sleep, we are both mentally and emotionally weaker. This makes us grumpy, irritable, and much likelier to lash out. Think of an infant crying its heart out. Their mother or father might explain that “they’re just tired.” As adults, we’re socially aware enough not to throw a tantrum in public. But we’re just as impacted by our lack of sleep as a bawling toddler.

World-renowned neuroscientist Matthew Walker’s 2017 book, Why We Sleep, talks about adopting a few simple tricks to getting enough sleep. If you’re getting less than seven hours of sleep a night, Walker argues, it’s time to start avoiding stimulants like caffeine and nicotine. These can take up to eight hours to work through your body, and they seriously undermine your ability to nod off. Alcohol should also be avoided. While a nightcap might make you feel relaxed, it robs you of deep sleep – the most restorative and restful part of the sleep cycle. This is also true of heavy meals eaten too close to bedtime. And remember, humans are creatures of habit, so it’s a good idea to go to bed at the same time every day. 


Resilience isn’t just about positivity – it’s also helpful to think about everything that could go wrong.

If you want to build your resilience, many argue, you need to embrace the power of positive thinking. This is a popular idea found in self-help books, therapies, and on social media. It says that if we’re positive enough, there’s nothing we can’t do, from losing weight to landing that dream job. There’s nothing wrong with a can-do attitude, of course – the reason these books and ideas are popular is because they do help lots of folks. But positive thinking isn’t the only approach. 

Sometimes, dwelling on negatives can be just as helpful. Granted, mulling over all the reasons you might fail doesn’t sound like a compelling strategy to build resilience. But here’s the thing: confronting the likelihood of falling short can be liberating.

This notion is at the heart of Stoicism, a philosophical creed that goes back to the ancient Greeks. This doctrine has two key components.

The first is death. Stoics, as followers of this school of thought are called, emphasise the briefness of life. This might sound depressing, but they believe this focus actually relieves us of a burden. They reason that once you concentrate your mind on the certainty of dying, it becomes easier to embrace life and not put off until tomorrow what you can do today. This also applies metaphorically. Think of what “death” might mean in your work. What is the worst possible outcome? The loss of employment, your reputation, clients, or money? If you knew that these things would eventually happen, how would that affect your choices today?

Then there’s the lesson of the influential Greek philosopher Epictetus, born in 341 BCE. As Epictetus saw it, few things cause more misery than change and disruption. This is because we fear the unknown and assume the worst.  So Epictetus argued that it’s best to only consider the changes that you’re presented with. If thinking through the worst possible outcomes is not really helping you plan for them but just making you anxious, change tack. Stop stressing about possibilities, gossip, or what could happen. Prepare for change once it becomes a reality. 

Together, these lessons strike a balance – anticipate the worst and plan for it, but really focus only on what’s actually happening, not on “what ifs.”


Purpose makes us resilient and gets us through periods of hardship. 

When we’re clear about why we’re doing what we’re doing, we are much more likely to be resilient. It is this sense of “why” that gets people through grueling seven-day weeks in the early stages of establishing their business, or keeps them on course during a marathon. In other words, the conviction that our tasks are meaningful gives us the courage to push through adversity.


Only you can define what kind of work is meaningful.

The Japanese have a special word for the sense of purpose that gets you out of bed in the morning: ikigai, meaning “a reason for being.” This is something you do not just for money but also because it matters. As the saying goes, “If you do something you love, you’ll never have to work another day in your life.” This is true enough, but first you have to find your purpose.

Committing to a working life of purpose takes courage. Doing what matters to you, after all, is deeply personal. It might lead you down a path that will surprise your family, friends, and peers. This can cause friction, but it’s worth doing all the same. We only get one chance at life. Doing what you care about is an opportunity that shouldn’t be passed up lightly. The question, then, is how to find out what a working life of meaning and purpose would look like for you. To help you do that, there are a couple exercises to try.

Your ikigai encompasses both your personal values and your professional abilities. To find work that allows you to combine these two things, you’ll need to ask yourself four questions.

  • First off, what do you love doing? 
  • Secondly, what are you good at? 
  • Thirdly, what does the world need? 
  • Lastly, what can you be paid for? 

Think of your answers as a Venn diagram; you’ll find your ikigai where all four circles overlap. 

You can also try a more creative approach. Imagine you are a manager at a firm that’s hiring, and you walk through the door. Try to describe yourself. What does your contribution to the company entail? Why does it matter? What are the top three points about your work that you’d emphasise? If this is still too vague, try condensing this description of why your work is important even further, into a 140-character tweet. 

Finally, there's another approach: think about what’s working well for you right now, and use that as a launching pad to think about your purpose. To do this, keep a journal for a week. Each night, right before bed, write down three good things about your day. Once you’ve jotted these down, think about why those things went well. Chances are, you already know what you find meaningful. This exercise will just help you bring that out into the open. 



Zero to One is a book for anyone interested in innovative products and services. This book was written in 2014 and it goes through the experiences, philosophy and advice of Peter Thiel, one of the world's foremost venture capitalists. Thiel co-founded PayPal and was the first outsider to invest in Facebook. His unique approach to business will attempt to show you how to predict the future and make it a successful one for your start-up. Some of the things you will discover in this book are why monopolies are actually good for innovation and why your startup needs to go from "0 to 1," not "from 1 to n". 




Summary & Key Learnings


1. The Challenge of the Future

2. Party Like It's 1999

3. All Happy Companies Are Different

4. The Ideology of Competition

5. Last Mover Advantage

6. You Are Not a Lottery Ticket

7. Follow the Money

8. Secrets

9. Foundations

10. The Mechanics of Mafia

11. If You Build It, Will They Come?

12. Man and Machine

13. Seeing Green

14. The Founder's Paradox

Conclusion: Stagnation or Singularity?


The key learnings from this book:
A start-up's success is not a matter of luck. You can pursue the future you want as long as you're able to challenge established conventions. Then once you obtain a monopoly by being better at something than everyone else, success will follow on its own.

Actionable advice:
Dominate one niche at a time.

When you've found the unusual idea to base your start-up on don't go too broad too quickly. Find a small niche where you can do something better than any of your competitors. Once you've established a monopoly there you can expand to other markets later.


1. The Challenge of the Future

The introduction of the book begins with the question "What important truth do very few people agree with you on?" Thiel's approach for this question stems from the phrase, "Brilliant thinking is rare but courage is in even shorter supply than genius." Go from zero to one by building a revolutionary startup or constructing the future. When we talk about the future, we don't just think of the passage of time, but the progress made during that time. This progress, that is, the differences from the present, is what really defines the future.


More specifically, it can be divided into horizontal and vertical progress:


Horizontal progress comes from expanding on existing ideas and innovations. Here' globalisation is a common driver because it helps spread eixting ideas to more people.


Vertical progress, however, comes from creating something new that didn't exist before like a new technology or method.


Horizontal progress is going from one to n whereas vertical progress is going from zero to one. 


Example of horizontal progress would be mass-producing phones and distributing them to developing countries. An example of vertical progress would be building a smartphone from a regular one.


Vertical progress is hard to predict because you have to imagine something that doesn't exist yet. That's why you can only predict future progress is you're able to see the present differently. A person who can think outside established conventions can see and change the future.

Thiel ends the chapter by asking "Why Start-ups?" A start-up is the largest group of people that you can convince of a plan to build a different future. So how can you prepare for the different and unknown circumstances that await you in the future? Today, many people think indefinitely and try to prepare themselves for all possible future events. This approach is futile however, because the future holds far too many unknowns and variables. 

A more effective approach is making a focused effort to achieve the future that's best for you, thus becoming the architect of your own future. Success is the product of focus, dedication and determination. If success were nothing but a product of luck, we wouldn't see serial successes like Steve Jobs or Thiel founding several prosperous businesses. It's crucial to keep in mind when founding a start-up, startups only have one best future and attaining it demands a concerted effort. Why only one? Because a start-up will only be successful under very specific conditions: there's only one best market for the company's product, only one best time to launch it, and so on. In order to strike when the conditions are just right, you must make a conscious choice to pursue the future in question. The main difficulty likes in figuring out just what the ideal conditions for your start-up are. In other words, which future are you aiming at? When choosing your future, remember you can only see the future by looking beyond established conventions.


3. Party Like It's 1999

This chapter begins with summaries of certain time periods:


1. 1990 - Economical migration of investments in the USA "from bricks to clicks"


2. 1997 - Economical crash in Thailand


3. 1999 - Launch of the Euro


4. 1998 - 2000 - Dot.com mania


Paypal was created with a goal to create a new digital currency. As the idea evolved, the currency became a method for transferring funds via email. The concept was revolutionary. Many merchants swarmed to the new products as this technology allowed them to receive funds more efficiently compared to their former predecessors. The company shortly after build, learned a hack for cultivating new clients by using $10 incentives. This quickly gained enough traction to get significant funding in 2000 before the dot.com crash.



3. All Happy Companies Are Different

This chapter highlights the similarities and differences between happy companies and failing companies. 


"All happy companies are different: each one earns a monopoly by solving a unique problem. All failed companies are the same: they failed to escape competition."


"What valuable company is nobody building?" A valuable company is the summation of created value in addition to value captured. The main takeaway for aspiring entrepreneurs (who have the hope of changing the world for the better) with your company is that you must create and capture value. 


Thiel tries to distinguish the differences between a Monopoly (which he believes is not evil) vs a Perfect Competition (arguably dangerous for business vitality). Both companies are trying to disguise themselves as something else as well (usually the opposite to what they are).


When people hear the word "monopoly," they tend to think of large, evil companies unfairly squeezing out the competition. Thiel believes this is inaccurate. Conventional wisdom holds thta competition is the ideal economic stimulus, encouraging companies to improve on each others' product. However, it's actually monopolies that drive innovation. If you have a monopoly, it doesn't necessarily mean the competition is being treated unfairly. Rather, you're just doing something so much better than them that they can't survive. Similar, if you create something new that no other company can copy, it's not necessarily a bad thing.


Google clearly has a monopoly over the search-engine industry, having faced no competition whatsoever in the twenty-first century. This might seem unfair to other companies who'd like to compete, but it's certainly been good for everyone likes using Google's powerful search engine. Monopolies can drive progress, they encourage other businesses to come up with better solutions and oust the current dominant company. For example, if a company wants to compete in the search-engine market today, it needs to invent a better search engine than Google. It if does, it will be the consumers that benefit. Having a monopoly allows you to set your own prices, which in turn ensures high profits. If your product is no better than your competitors', you'll have to set your prices low to entice customers away from the competition, which erodes profit margins.



Firm A - disguised as a monopoly: Google has a monopoly on search but emphasises the small share of global online advertising, and other miscellaneous business models. 

Firm B - disguised as a perfect competition: A local restaurant 
to find fake differentiators by being the “only British restaurant in Palo Alto” yet they are using inaccurate metrics. The real marker would be “restaurants” not “restaurant type.”


4. The Ideology of Competition

This chapter describes the business world to be heavily analogous to war. MBAs often attribute their tactful success to the knowledge acquired from books such as “The Art of War”. The analogy is further supplemented by the metaphorical wartime language.

“Why do people compete?”
Marx model: Since we are inherently different and possess distinct goals, and
Shakespeare model: All competitors are more-or-less similar (ex: Montague vs Capulet)

Placing emphasis on the wrong attribute in business (like in war) can lead to the toxic realisation that the root problem truly lies in the similarities. For example, while Microsoft and Google were obsessively competing with each other Apple emerged and surpassed both.

This chapter referenced examples of Square competitors. This illustrated the negative consequences of competition. The act itself is likely to limit vision and focus energy on obsessive hostility. As a result, copying is promoted.


The best way to resolve conflict (competition) is to merge with your competitors. This is when Thiel decided to work with Musk, despite their initial differences. It’s easier to monopolise the bigger you are or the more targeted your audience.


5. Last Mover Advantage

There are two important time periods in the evolution of an emerging market for creating an effective monopoly; the first mover, and the last mover.

Thiel placed weight on understanding the proper business valuation process (and how to differentiate valid valuations compared to inflated valuations).

The equation for the value of a business today is the value of earnings in the future. Here is an example using the previous definition.

Twitter vs New York Times
Twitter $24Bn valuation (2013 IPO) = 12 * NYT market cap

Why does a new company surpass a veteran institution?
  1. Twitter is generating more cash flow (not even profit at times), and
  2. Twitter holds the monopoly of the future while publishing houses are failing to evolve effectively (improve or invent: “Anything You Want”).

So what exactly makes monopolies so successful? Typically, monopolies share some combination of four beneficial characteristics:

What defines a monopoly?
  1. Proprietary technology They have a technological advantage, their proprietary technology works much better than anyone else's - usually at least 10 times better. Google's search algorithms, for example are much faster and have better predictive power than anyone else's which makes it very difficult for a competitor to supplant them.
  2. Network effect (start with a hyper-niche market. If you think its too big it is). Monopolies enjoy network effects, meaning the more people are using their product, the more useful it is. An example is, Facebook wouldn't be very useful if none of your friends where signed up. What makes it valuable to you is the fact that many of the people in your network can be found there. This means that newcomers face an uphill battle when trying to lure customers away from monopolies with broad existing customer-bases.
  3. The economy of scale (SaaS vs employee labor-intensive). Monopolies benefit from economies of scale: cost savings gained by producing something on a large scale instead of a small one. Say you own a bakery and have a fixed costs like rent, heating and electricity totalling $1000. In this bakery, you can product between 1 and 10,000 buns a month, while the fixed costs remain the same. The more buns you sell, the more you can spread out those fixed costs meaning that the effective cost incurred per bun is less. Since monopolies are the largest producers in the their industry, economies of scale allow them to offer customers more attractive prices than newcomers, further strengthening their position. 
  4. Excellent Branding (Apple Branding to stay continual trend). Monopolies often have strong brands that can't be replicated. Apple, for example is the strongest tech brand in existence. While many other companies have tried to emulate its sleekly designed products and store, they just haven't seen the same level of success because they lack Apple's powerful brand.

How can we build a monopoly?
  1. Actively attempt to seek a hyper-niche target market that has little to no competitors. Serve them, and do it well (all that matters == customer: “Anything You Want”),
  2. Once you have dominated the market expands to the nearest adjacent market. Similar to Amazon selling CDs, DVDs then everything else,
  3. Do not disrupt current giants. PayPal worked with Visa. Everyone won, and
  4. Attempt to make the last great development in a specific market and reap all the benefits of a mature ecosystem.


6. You Are Not a Lottery Ticket

Can you control your future?

On the rare possibility that you are able to truly know the future with extreme accuracy then you may be able to control it. However, the reality is the future is random and uncertain. So don’t attempt to master it.

Thiel draws a graph to help illustrate the outcome of the future; better or worse.

  1. Indefinite pessimism: Since the 70s most of Europe forfeited authority to join forces without proper structure and order. The inevitable crash is indefinite so they ensue into a vacation mania.
  2. Definite pessimism: Economic growth is not quick enough for China. The rich place money internationally, and the poor preparation for the definite inevitable (soon). Not sustainable growth.
  3. Definite optimism: The Western world before the 70s. Major milestones were executed: Empire State Building, Panama Canal, Apollo program.
  4. Indefinite optimism: Effortless progress creates entitlement. Wealth accumulation overshadowed engineering innovation.

Thiel argues that to be successful one (a company) should not practice the development of a mediocre skillset and call it “well-rounded”. Rather focus, like the definite optimist, on one particular interest and dominate, build your monopoly.


7. Follow the Money

The 80/20 rule is applicable for startup success.

The Pareto principle is evident when observing the money trail. Venture capitalist aims to profit from companies in round series funding. Yet few companies achieve exponential growth. Most fail while few essentially breakeven.


8. Secrets

This chapter talks about the elusive topics of hidden secrets that need discovering. In today's high-tech world it's tempting to think that there's no more room for vertical progress or that there aren't any new ideas to be had. But this is a dangerous misconception that can keep you from being successful. In face, the world still has plenty of secrets - that is, things that are important by which most people don't know about or agree with. This makes them hard - but not impossible to discover. Often, the secrets are so deeply embedded in society that it might take generations to discover them. Just consider slavery which  a few centuries ago, was a common socially acceptable phenomenon. To put it differently, back then, the fact that slavery is wrong was by and large a secret.

For tech companies, the best secret is to have better technology than their competitors because it can make their position as market leaders unassailable. You need to find and chase thee kinds of secrets otherwise you'll just be another provider of horizontal progress offering conventional products in a competitive market.


What happens when a company stops believing in secrets?

Here is what happens to a company that stops believing in secrets. The case of Hewlett-Packard demonstrates the importance of having better technology. In the 1990s, the company had the best technology and used it to bring out one innovative product after the other, such as an affordable colour printer and an all-in-one printer, copier and fax machine - a truly wild idea at the time. But when the company stopped chasing secrets and inventing new products in the 2000s, it lost half its market value.
  1. 1990 company worth $9Bn
  2. 2000 after a decade of inventions (first affordable color printer, first super-portable laptops) worth $135Bn
  3. 2005 worth $70Bn (failed merge with Compaq, failed consulting/support shops)
  4. 2012 worth $23Bn as a result of an abandoned search for technological secrets.

The emphasis of this section is not to have secrets and hide or protect them from others, like some sort of IP. Rather, a company hoping to change the world is a company that will have secrets that once revealed will revolutionise a whole industry, advancing the movement towards an optimistic future.

Every great business is built around a secret that’s hidden from the outside such as inner workings of Google’s PageRank algorithm, Apple iPhone in 2007, etc…


9. Foundations

We tend to think of monopolies as behemoths towering over their competitors but of course, they don't start out that way. Building a successful monopoly takes time. This is especially true when it comes to profits. It can take years for a start-up to become profitable. But even if the company doesn't initially make profits it can still have value because value is determined by the profits it will make over its entire lifespan. PayPal is a case in point: in 2001, it wasn't making any profits. The calculated value of the company back then, most of it came from profits that were expected to come in more than ten years later. The lesson here is that you can't expect to be top dog in your business from the get-go. You need to be prepared to stick around for the long run. That's what will make you profitable.

How can you make your start-up a profitable monopoly? 

You need to start small and then expand bit by bit. You don't need to be the very best in every business, just your business. It's important to define your market as narrowly and specifically as possible. That'll make it easier for you to become its dominant player. After you've obtained a monopoly in this niche you can move on the next broader market. From the very beginning Amazon founder Jeff Bezos had the ultimate goal of becoming the world's greatest online retailed but he started much more narrowly selling nothing but books. Only after Amazon conquered the book market did it expand to other categories likes CDs and videos, and from there to other products. So contrary to what many think, Amazon' success hardly happened overnight.

Every company needs to lay a solid foundation to survive in the long run so when you start out on the long road of building up a business, the first days are absolutely crucial. 

The first key component in this foundation is finding the right people. Typically, start-ups are so so small that every single person on the team plays an important role. That's why before making an investment in a company, Thiel not only makes it a point to analyse the skills and vision of the people involved but also their personal connections. He's seen firsthand what weak personal ties can do to a team. Before co-founding PayPal with Luke Nosel, Thiel had invested in a company that Nosel had started with someone he barely knew. Eventually, their personal differences took the whole venture down along with Thiel's investment.

Another key factor in a strong foundation is ensuring that the different interests of the various company owners are balanced. After all, the founders and investors may have very different interests, but the company shouldn’t have to suffer from such misalignments. For example, the founders of the company may wish to develop their products patiently, whereas the board of directors usually wants to bring in profits as soon as possible. While these interests aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive, they can sometimes cause conflict, so it’s crucial to define a way of resolving such conflicts early on.

Finally, start-ups should also try to instill a strong culture in their teams because it helps everyone work effectively together. Company culture doesn’t consist merely in the perks you offer to your employees, like a pool table and a soda machine, but rather the relationships that people have. A good example of a strong company culture could be seen at Paypal, where the team was so close that many of them went on to start new companies together later.

The complementary personalities and skill sets allow for the elixir of success. Thiel stresses the importance of the co-founder’s compatibility.
  1. Ownership: Who legally owns a company’s equity? (founders, employees, investors)
  2. Possession: Who actually runs the company on a daily basis? (managers)
  3. Control: Who formally governs the company affairs? (board of directors which includes founders)

He talks about the appeal of having fewer heads on the board. Public companies are mandated to have a minimum amount but Thiel often prefers to have a board of 3.

Thiel uses another easy analogy for startup culture. You are either on the bus or off the bus. An individual who prioritises the drawing of salary over the positive contribution to the growth of the value of the company’s equity is an individual who is seeking to extract value otherwise.

The association with the value being given by a cash salary creates short term thinking with an employee. Drawing a high salary as a CEO creates the concept of attachment towards the title as it is correlated with such money (wrong mindset) and also promotes other employees to desire such payment (wrong mindset). The goal is for a company to proportionally give the right amount of equity to promote long term thinking and incentivize the employee to build value with the future in mind and the right amount of cash salary to keep the immediate now satisfied (basic needs + Lil extra).



10. The Mechanics of Mafia

The purpose of this chapter is to create and foster a strong culture within the companies ecosystem. Company culture is similar to a cult, minus the overzealous dogmatism.

The 4 integral dimensions used to construct an effective company culture.
  1. Imagery: Using branded clothing, merch, stickers and other miscellaneous items/events help show others in your company that you belong in the same tribe and shows commitment,
  2. Slogans: Slogans, catch-phrases, and idioms are great tools to build strong relations among members of the team. Think also of a group focused exercise where you may participate in a saying or exercise in unisons to trigger that hive mentality,
  3. Advocacy: This is essentially advocating and broadcasting the main problem you aim to focus on tackling (usually mission), in addition to philanthropic-like activities, and
  4. Obsession: Find like-minded people — simple. Use active employees to recruit other like-minded people who are equally obsessed with solving the same problem as you.

The goal is to create and foster a strong company culture. Cult participants are usually misinformed fanatics. We want fanatics who are enthusiastic about our problems and mission. You don’t mind others calling you a mafia of sorts either.


11. If You Build It, Will They Come?

When most people hear the word “salesperson,” they think of a man in a cheap suit going door to door hawking vacuum cleaners: not a very flattering image.But in business, sales is a vital necessity. Many people, especially those enthusiastic about technology, would prefer to focus on product innovation, but innovative products are worthless unless they’re sold. And there’s no product on earth that people will buy without you selling it.

To sell your product effectively, you need good distribution. This not only includes your sales channels but also the effort and organization it takes to sell your products.To leverage your distribution most effectively, you always need to consider the potential of each client before deciding how much effort you’re willing to put into making the sale.For example, Thiel co-founded the data analytics company Palantir, where a single closed sale usually brings in several million dollars. Here, the CEO has to personally do the selling, because clients spending such sums expect a certain amount of personal involvement from the seller’s executives.In another business where single sales deals only bring in a few hundred thousand dollars apiece, it wouldn’t be an efficient use of time for the highly paid CEO. However, the CEO would still need a solid sales team to represent the company. Another way to enhance your distribution is to use strategies. Many of us dislike salespeople because we associate selling with manipulation, and no one likes to be manipulated. But while certain obvious manipulation techniques may not be successful in sales, there are certain strategies that will work on anyone – so you should make them work for you.

Often the trope suggests that a product should sell itself. However, Thiel argues that the delivery system for a company’s service or good is of equal importance to the product itself. Thiel gives a brief lesson on sales. If the CLV (Customer Lifetime Value) is greater than the CAC (Customer Acquire Cost) then you can learn how to sell with profit. The more expensive the product, the greater the sales costs then the more important to the sale.


Some products may require a team of salesmen who make sales look effortless to the programmers (2 hours lunches, etc). Other products may be less than $1,000 where they simply can use orthodox advertising. Sometimes the product may be such a big sale that the CEO or other officers may need to participate directly in the sale of the product. Regardless, the distribution system must be considered a fundamental aspect of a successful business.

Then there are dead zones. The target is usually SMEs (small-medium enterprise, B2B) and they require unique marketing. Look around, if you don’t see a salesperson, you’re the salesperson



12. Man and Machine

This chapter can be summarised as the computer complimenting humans as a tool of technology vs robots taking over the workforce. There is a great fear that robots will inevitably make humans ineffective. Thiel argues that this is not the case. Instead, he believes that computers will empower the human race rather than make them obsolete.



Thiel offers an example of the complementary relationship computers will have with robots.
  1. In the summer of 2000 Paypal was losing $10Mn/Mo because of credit card fraud. It was nearly impossible for the human resources to flag and resolve every single transaction with brute force alone,
  2. Thiel hired an elite team mathematicians to solve the problem algorithmically,
  3. This solution worked, temporarily,
  4. The latest solution was to assemble a highly specialized team of human analysts to review most suspicious transactions flagged by the algorithm,
  5. This hybrid system was named “Igor” after the Russian fraudster who claimed he will never be caught, and
  6. Paypal records first profit in 2002 vs quarterly loss of $29.3Mn one year before.

This hybrid solution has been used by the FBI for detecting fraud and later inspired the creation of Palantir. The system uses sophisticated AI/ML to help create high-risk and high-probability flag cases to be reviewed by the human analyst in greater detail, “keeping the human in the loop”.



13. Seeing Green

Between 2005 and 2009, an investment bubble was at its height in Silicon Valley. The underlying industry was clean technology, or cleantech, which encompasses products and services that promote things like the sustainable use of natural resources and the use of renewable energy sources. Thousands of companies had been started in the industry, financed by over $50 billion in investments. Unfortunately, since then many companies have failed, taking the investors’ money with them. So why did they fail? Because they simply didn’t analyse and understand the market opportunity.

To avoid this, every company should ask seven crucial questions about the market and itself:
  1. The Engineering question: Can you create breakthrough technology instead of incremental improvements? Cleantech companies didn’t understand that to prevail over established energy companies, they needed technology ten times better than theirs, not just slightly better.
  2. The Timing Question: Is now the right time to start your particular business? Some cleantech companies believed the industry was on the cusp of a period of rapid, exponential advances in, for example, solar-panel technology, and that this would allow them to flourish. But in fact clean technology has advanced slowly and linearly.
  3. The monopoly question: Are starting with a big share from a small market? Cleantech companies were part of the trillion-dollar energy industry, which meant dog-eat-dog competition for even small shares of the market. A smaller market where you have a good chance of building a monopoly fast is a much better bet.
  4. The people question: Do you have the right team? Cleantech companies were often run by non-technical executives who had no idea how to build great products.
  5. The distribution question: Do you have a way to deliver your product? Many cleantech companies, like electric vehicle start-up Better Place, believed their technology was so good that they didn’t need proper distribution channels. After spending $800 million of investors’ money and selling just 1,000 cars, it ended up filing for bankruptcy.
  6. The durability question: Will your market position be defensible 10 and 20 years into the future? Many solar-technology companies were surprised when Chinese companies began churning out similar products at a much lower cost. This should have been entirely foreseeable from the outset.
  7. The secret question: Have you identified a unique opportunity that others don’t see? At the time, everyone agreed cleantech was going to be huge. But truly successful companies have secrets: they spot opportunities not everyone can see.

Innovative companies like Tesla typically have answers to almost all of these key questions, whereas most cleantech companies had zero. This is why they failed.


Thiel states, “One of the few cleantech companies that have found success is Tesla. This is because they got all of the basic issues right. This shows that the problem was never with the idea of cleantech by itself, rather the problem was how most of the cleantech startups ran their firms.”

Many social-driven businesses fail to differentiate themselves from other entities and products and place emphasis on the wrong goal: “To do something good”. Set after the goal to do something different instead (maybe as a monopoly on a smaller scale). The success may come to you similar to it did to Musk with Tesla.



14. The Founder's Paradox

In the last chapter, Thiel draws up some interesting graphs that suggests that the average person falls in the middle of the spectrum and also believes that the inverse of the function is true for the founders. He is basically suggesting that founders tend to have “extreme” qualities. 

Across the board, founders tend to be slightly strange, especially founders of successful companies. Whether they’ve been a bit off since birth or have become that way to emulate past great founders, almost every successful founder is somewhat . . . unusual. Consider Paypal’s founding team: almost every member was a bit of an oddball. In fact, as teenagers, four of them even had the unusual hobby of building bombs! This kind of originality is important because founders do far more than just start a company: they give it a vision. And this contribution is indispensable; no matter how refined a company’s management strategies are, it must have a vision to pursue.

Think about Steve Jobs’s return to Apple in 1997. He’d been been kicked out over a decade earlier, and, in 2001, he launched the iPod, which analysts brushed off as nothing but a cool gadget for Mac users. But the true genius of Jobs’s plan was revealed when Apple launched the iPhone and iPad, creating a family of Apple’s “post-PC devices” distinguished by their sleek looks and exclusive features. Jobs had effectively made Apple the most valuable company in the world by following a carefully thought-out plan based on his vision. As this success story shows, even a strong company, if it wants to perform at the highest level, needs the originality and vision of its founder.




He talks roughly about some philosophy about believing strongly in your own abilities. Basically, be humble that's all.


Conclusion: Stagnation or Singularity?

Debating the contents of the future with high-level accuracy is a feeble task. However, we can anticipate four likely scenarios.

Four scenarios for the future:
  1. Recurrent collapse (likely considering the ebb flow cycle as seen in history: William Durant),
  2. Plateau (technological stagnation),
  3. Extinction (man-made or natural), and
  4. Takeoff (essentially hybrid where technology pushes advancement forward exponentially).

So, effectively we can decide how to shape the future. How will you do your part?


© Christine Calo 2021. Please do not reproduce without the expressed consent of Christine Calo. Powered by Blogger.