Showing posts with label Psychology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Psychology. Show all posts


 "Start with Why: How Great Leaders Inspire Everyone to Take Action" is a book written by Simon Sinek. The book explores the concept of starting with a clear sense of purpose or "why" in order to inspire and motivate others.


Simon Sinek is a self-professed optimist determined to create a better and brighter future for humanity. An influential speaker and coach, Sinek has helped organizations around the world, such as Microsoft, American Express, the United Nations, and the Pentagon, inspire their employees. He is also the author of Leaders Eat Last and Together is Better.



Summary & Key Learnings

Chapter 1: Assume You Know
Chapter 2: Carrots and Sticks
Chapter 3: The Golden Circle
Chapter 4: This is Not Opinion, This is Biology
Chapter 5: Clarity Discipline, and Consistency
Chapter 6: The Emergency of Trust
Chapter 7: How a Tipping Point Tips
Chapter 8: Start With Why but Know How
Chapter 9: Know Why. Know How. Then What?
Chapter 10: Communication is about Listening
Chapter 11: When Why Goes Fuzzy
Chapter 12: Split Happens
Chapter 13: The Origin of a Why
Chapter 14: The New Competition


Sinek argues that many individuals and organizations focus primarily on "what" they do (the products or services they offer) and "how" they do it (the strategies and tactics they employ). However, he suggests that truly great leaders and organizations start by defining and communicating their underlying purpose, their "why" — the reason they exist and the values that drive them.

Sinek draws upon examples from successful companies and influential leaders, such as Apple and Martin Luther King Jr., to illustrate the power of starting with why. He explains that by communicating the deeper purpose behind their actions, these leaders inspire loyalty, engagement, and commitment from both employees and customers.

The book emphasizes the importance of understanding and articulating one's purpose as a foundation for decision-making, innovation, and long-term success. It encourages readers to reflect on their own "why" and provides practical strategies for incorporating this mindset into personal and professional endeavors.

Overall, "Start with Why" serves as a guide for individuals and organizations seeking to create a strong sense of purpose and inspire others to action by communicating that purpose effectively.


Chapter 1: Assume You Know

In the first chapter of "Start With Why," Sinek explores the impact of our assumptions on our actions. He provides examples that illustrate how considering the bigger picture can influence our behavior and drive long-term results. A notable example is the comparison between American and Japanese car manufacturers. In American factories, workers use a rubber mallet to make final adjustments to the doors, while in Japan, the doors are designed to fit perfectly right from the start.

This comparison serves as a metaphor for leadership. Sinek introduces two types of leaders: those who resort to manipulation to achieve their desired outcomes, and those who begin with the end result in mind and allow everything else to naturally fall into place.


Chapter 2: Carrots and Sticks

Sinek explains that there are two approaches to attracting customers: inspiring with carrots or manipulating with sticks. Unfortunately, many businesses today rely on manipulative sales tactics. These tactics involve leveraging price, promotions, fear, aspirations, peer pressure, and novelty. While pricing and promotions are widely recognized forms of manipulation, fear, aspirations, peer pressure, and novelty can be more subtle and discreet.

It's crucial to recognize that these manipulative tactics offer short-term solutions that ultimately lead to a cycle of ongoing manipulation. If businesses continue down this path, it will negatively impact their long-term profitability. However, there is an alternative approach, which is explored in chapter three.


Chapter 3: The Golden Circle

The core of Simon Sinek’s “Start With Why” is his discovery of The Golden Circle. There are three parts of The Golden Circle: Why, How, and What.

freshsales_start_with_why_summary_golden_circle

Why: Only a few individuals or organizations can effectively articulate the purpose behind their actions. It goes beyond mere profitability and delves into the core of why they exist and what drives them. Why is about finding your company's purpose, the reason you wake up every morning, and the compelling factor that should resonate with others.

How: Some individuals and organizations have a clear understanding of how they go about achieving their goals. Whether it's referred to as a "unique selling proposition" or a "differentiating value proposition," the Hows explain the distinctive ways in which they operate and what sets them apart.

What: Every company, regardless of size or industry, knows what they do. They can easily describe the products or services they offer or their role within the organization.

When we begin with Why, we approach the Golden Circle from the inside out. Why becomes the driving force for purchase decisions, while the Whats represent tangible evidence of that underlying belief. The Whats serve as rational justifications for why we prefer one company over another.

Simon Sinek highlights Apple as an example. According to him, Apple is not inherently different from its competitors on a technical level. However, Apple communicates from a place of Why. Their purpose is to challenge the status quo and empower individuals, which permeates everything they say and do. This consistency is what leads people to perceive Apple as authentic.


Chapter 4: This Is Not Opinion, This Is Biology

Chapter four delves into the inherent human need for belonging, which motivates us to seek out others who share our same "Why." Interestingly, the Golden Circle framework aligns with the natural functioning of our brain.

Freshsales_start_with_why_summary_brain


Neocortex: The neocortex, which aligns with the "What" level in the Golden Circle, is associated with our rational and analytical thinking abilities, as well as language processing. It enables us to sift through extensive amounts of facts and figures. However, it alone does not stimulate behavior or drive decision-making processes.

Limbic Brain: Our limbic brain, which encompasses the middle two sections, plays a vital role in our emotions, including trust and loyalty. It aligns closely with the "Why" level within the Golden Circle framework. This region of the brain governs human behavior and decision-making processes.

As individuals, we naturally gravitate towards people and organizations that share our beliefs and values. When companies prioritize starting with their "Why," their core beliefs, they tap into our innate desire to associate ourselves with products that reflect our values. These products make us feel special, fostering a sense of belonging and a connection to a larger community of like-minded individuals.

In contrast, many companies initially focus on the "Whats" and "Hows" because those are the demands expressed by their customers. Customers often request superior quality, competitive prices, round-the-clock service, and a multitude of features. These requests are often backed by data and seem scientifically sound. However, Simon Sinek argues that this approach may not be as effective. The brain regions responsible for decision-making differ from those that articulate the underlying "Why" behind those decisions. Consequently, traditional methods like focus groups and questionnaires may offer limited value in truly understanding the "Why."

To illustrate this point, Henry Ford's famous quote is often cited: "If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said a faster horse."


Chapter 5: Clarity, Discipline, and Consistency

In chapter five, the significance of the Golden Circle is further explored, emphasizing the crucial aspect of maintaining the correct order.

The three degrees of certainty:
When our judgment is solely based on tangible elements or rational measurements, the highest level of confidence we can express is: "I think this is the right decision."

However, when we rely on our instincts, the highest level of confidence we can convey is: the decision feels right, even if it contradicts all the facts and figures.

The ability to articulate the "Why" behind our decisions provides the emotional context that enhances confidence. When we are clear about our "Why," we can offer the highest level of confidence by stating: "I know it's right." In such cases, not only does the decision feel right, but we can also rationalize it and articulate it effectively.

In business, the objective should not be to engage with anyone who simply desires what you offer. Instead, the focus should be on connecting with individuals who share your beliefs and values. By aligning with those who believe what you believe, businesses can forge more meaningful relationships and drive greater impact.

Chapter 6: The Emergency of Trust

Trust is cultivated when individuals and organizations demonstrate motives that extend beyond self-interest. Achieving alignment between the Why, How, and What of a company is a powerful method to foster trust.

When companies adopt a mentality of producing commodities, they face a persistent struggle to differentiate themselves from competitors. Engaging in a race to keep up with the competition and match them feature-for-feature only perpetuates a culture centered around the "What" of their offerings.

“Why” and flexibility
Companies that prioritize communicating their "Why" have a distinct advantage in the market because consumers are inspired by the underlying purpose behind their actions. A comparison between Apple and Dell highlights this difference. While both companies manufacture computers, Apple has successfully expanded its product line to include iPads and iPhones.

On the other hand, Dell's brand identity is centered around "What" they do – computers. As a result, consumers may feel less inclined to purchase other products, such as tablets or smartphones, from Dell. Despite Dell's attempts to diversify, they eventually refocused on their core business.

Simon Sinek also emphasizes the significance of the First Mover Advantage when the "Why" is at the forefront. For instance, consider the case of Creative versus Apple in the mp3 player market. Creative had the technical capabilities to produce an mp3 player and was the first to do so. However, they marketed their product primarily as a "5GB mp3 player," emphasizing the features or "What" it offered. In contrast, Apple positioned the iPod as "1000 songs in your pocket," tapping into the emotional and aspirational "Why" behind owning the product.

By highlighting the "Why," Apple effectively captured consumers' attention and loyalty, surpassing competitors like Creative, despite their technical advantages.

“Why” and hiring
When employees belong, they will guarantee your success. And they won’t be working hard and looking for an innovative solution for you, they will be doing it for themselves.

The goal is to hire those who are passionate about your “Why”, your purpose, cause or belief, and who have the attitude that fits your culture. Once that is established, only then should their skillset and experience be evaluated.

Great companies do not hire skilled people and motivate them; they hire already motivated people and inspire them. Companies with a strong sense of “Why” are able to inspire their employees. Such employees are more productive and innovative, and the feeling they bring to work attracts other people eager to work there as well.


Chapter 7: How a Tipping Point Tips

freshsales_start_with_why_summary_law



How can you distinguish between a passing fad and an idea with the potential to create lasting change in people's lives?

The Law of Diffusion of Innovations stated by Everett M. Rogers provides insights into the bell curve of product adoption. This curve illustrates the percentage of the market that embraces a product, starting with the Innovators (2.5%), followed by Early Adopters (13.5%), Early Majority (34%), Late Majority (34%), and Laggards (16%).

Those who eagerly line up for hours or days outside an Apple store to purchase the latest iPhone are early adopters, situated on the left side of the adoption curve. On the far right, we find individuals who are never satisfied and lack loyalty. For businesses, it is wise to understand this segment better to avoid wasting time and resources attempting to convert them. While some may engage in business initially, they are prone to quickly switch to competitors if offered a better deal.

Therefore, the primary objective of a business should be to have absolute clarity about their "Why" and connect with individuals who share their beliefs. Once a critical mass of the 15-18% on the left side of the bell curve is attained, they will influence and inspire others to follow suit.


Chapter 8: Start With Why But Know How

Energy serves as a motivator, while charisma serves as an inspiration. Energy is observable, quantifiable, and can be imitated. However, true charismatic leaders possess something more profound: a clear understanding of their "Why" and an unwavering belief in a purpose or cause greater than themselves.

To illustrate this, Simon Sinek highlights the contrasting examples of Bill Gates and Steve Ballmer. Steve Ballmer exudes energy, which can captivate people momentarily. In contrast, despite his shy and awkward demeanor, Bill Gates possesses charisma. When Bill Gates speaks, people listen attentively, holding their breath. The lessons he imparts leave a lasting impact, lingering in people's minds for weeks, months, or even years. Charisma has the power to command loyalty, while energy alone does not possess the same effect.

In essence, while energy may provide short-term motivation, it is charisma that truly inspires and fosters enduring devotion.

“Why” and “How” Types
Every "Why" type of leader is supported by a "How" type of leader who brings the vision to life.

"Why" types are visionary individuals with vivid imaginations. They tend to be optimistic, believing that anything they can imagine is achievable. They focus on intangible aspects that most people can't see, such as the future. On the other hand, "How" types are more practical and realistic. They concentrate on tangible elements that are visible to most people, and they excel at building them.

Interestingly, Simon Sinek notes that while "How" types can be successful, they rarely create billion-dollar businesses that have a transformative impact on the world. While a "How" type may not necessarily require a "Why" type to succeed, a "Why" type always needs a "How" type to avoid becoming a visionary without tangible results.

The differentiation between "Why" and "How" types also extends to the vision and mission statements of an organization. The vision represents the founder's intent and the underlying "Why" behind the company's establishment. In contrast, the mission statement describes the practical steps or "How" the company will fulfill that vision.

When both the vision and mission are clearly defined, it helps "Why" and "How" types of leaders to have well-defined roles within the partnership.


Chapter 9: Know Why. Know How. Then What?

In the early stages of a company, the founder has direct and frequent contact with the external world. However, as the company grows, the leader's role evolves. They no longer need to be the loudest voice broadcasting through a megaphone; instead, they become the source of the message that flows through the megaphone.

The "Why" of a company resides in the part of the brain responsible for emotions and decision-making, rather than language. On the other hand, the "Whats" exist in the part of the brain associated with rational thinking and language.

The leader serves as the inspiration and represents the emotional aspect of why the company does what it does. They embody the limbic brain. The actions and words of the company, on the other hand, reflect the rational thinking and language of the neocortex.

Many companies struggle to differentiate themselves and effectively convey their true value to the outside world. When humans find it challenging to express emotions in words, we rely on metaphors, imagery, and analogies to communicate how we feel. This is where symbols come into play. Tangible representations are created for those who share our beliefs, allowing us to express ourselves. When executed effectively, this is what marketing products and services are all about—a means for organizations to communicate their message to the world beyond.


Chapter 10: Communication is about Listening

Symbols play a crucial role in making abstract concepts tangible. The significance of symbols lies in the meanings we assign to them. A logo, for instance, transforms into a symbol when it inspires individuals to use it as a means of self-expression.

Consider the case of Harley Davidson: The brand represents not just a company, but the values and way of life embraced by its enthusiasts. The logo transcends being solely about Harley Davidson itself; it becomes an embodiment of an entire set of values that its followers identify with. The symbol no longer solely represents the company; it represents the people who passionately embrace Harley Davidsons for what they symbolize to them.


The Celery Test
Determining what is beneficial for your own business versus your competition can be challenging. To address this, Sinek introduces "The Celery Test."

Imagine if people advised you to acquire cookies, Nutella, celery, fruits, and ice cream in order to grow. Should you follow their suggestions and obtain all of these items? The answer is no. Gathering such a variety of products would be time-consuming, costly, and lack focus. Instead, Sinek proposes filtering these options through your "Why."

For instance, if your "Why" centers around leading a healthy lifestyle, you would likely choose only the fruits and/or celery. By aligning your decisions with your "Why," you save resources, time, and, most importantly, you remain dedicated to your cause.

Chapter 11: When Why goes Fuzzy

In this chapter, Sinek delves into the stories of companies that have lost sight of their original purpose, their "Why." Notably, he highlights Volkswagen and Walmart as examples.

Volkswagen, a brand synonymous with the "car of the people," has always been associated with reliable and affordable vehicles for everyone. The iconic VW Beetle symbolized freedom and a carefree lifestyle. However, when Volkswagen introduced the super-expensive VW Phaeton priced at $70,000, it contradicted their own underlying purpose and failed to resonate with customers.

Walmart presents a more profound case. Founded by Sam Walton with the vision of helping people and communities by offering affordable products, the company initially focused on its mission. Unfortunately, after the passing of its founder, Walmart became fixated solely on low prices, disregarding its commitment to supporting people and the communities it served. This shift led to a cutthroat approach towards suppliers, employees, and the communities involved. Walmart encountered significant challenges when it deviated from its original "Why."

Sinek emphasizes that discovering clarity in one's "Why" is not the most difficult aspect. The true challenge lies in having the discipline to trust one's intuition over external advice and remaining steadfast in upholding one's beliefs and cause.


Chapter 12: Split Happens

Every company begins with an idea. In the early stages, ideas are driven by passion—the powerful emotion that can sometimes lead us to act irrationally.

However, for passion to flourish and endure, it requires both structure and implementation ("Hows"). Many companies falter because the interdependence between the "Hows" and the "Whys" is often overlooked or undervalued. Both elements are essential for success.


Chapter 13: The Origin of a Why

You may have heard the importance of conducting market research before starting a business. The common approach involves understanding your target audience and carving out a niche for your venture. However, Simon Sinek offers a different perspective on this matter. Sinek suggests that the "Why" of your business does not stem from looking ahead and strategizing how to achieve your goals. It doesn't solely rely on market research or extensive interviews with customers and employees. Instead, it originates from an entirely different direction, diverging from your current position. Discovering your "Why" is a process of exploration, rather than something you create from scratch.

Your "Why" resides within you. Once you uncover and comprehend your "Why," the most challenging task is to remain authentic to it.


Chapter 14: The New Competition

When you find yourself in a world where you're constantly pitted against others, competing with everyone, it becomes challenging to receive support from others. However, when you shift your mindset and compete against yourself, you'll find that everyone wants to assist you.

Consider how we typically approach business. We're always in competition with someone else, striving for better quality, more features, and superior service. We continuously compare ourselves to our competitors, often feeling unsupported in our endeavors.

But what if we changed our perspective? What if, instead of focusing on surpassing others, we dedicated ourselves to surpassing our own achievements? What if our driving force was to leave the organization in a better state than when we first entered?

All organizations begin with a "Why," a purpose that motivates their existence. However, only the truly exceptional ones maintain a clear understanding of their "Why" year after year. Those who forget their founding purpose engage in a daily race to outdo others, rather than striving to surpass themselves.

Remember, your greatest competition is yourself.


In Summary

How to inspire . . . and how not to

The book discusses the concepts of inspiration and manipulation in influencing behavior. Manipulation involves using incentives and deals to push consumers to make purchases, but it doesn't foster loyalty. In contrast, inspiration is highlighted through the example of Apple, which doesn't rely on incentives but instead focuses on starting with the "why" to deeply connect with customers and build a committed following. Apple's success is attributed to its ability to inspire rather than manipulate.

The key takeaways are:
  • There are two main ways to influence behavior: inspiration and manipulation. Many companies rely on manipulation, using incentives and deals to push customers to make purchases. However, this approach doesn't create long-term loyalty.
  • Manipulation may attract customers for the short term, but it doesn't create a genuine connection. When faced with better offers, customers who were manipulated will easily switch. Inspiring customers, on the other hand, builds a deep connection and loyalty.
  • Apple serves as an example of an inspirational company. Despite not offering competitive deals, Apple's customers are highly committed and even behave irrationally when it comes to their brand. Apple's success is attributed to starting with the "why" and communicating a clear purpose that resonates with customers.
  • Understanding the "why" behind what you do is crucial. People don't just buy products or services; they buy into the purpose and values behind them. Starting with the "why" and inspiring others with a genuine sense of purpose can lead to greater loyalty and engagement.


Apple and the Golden Circle

The book discusses the historical context in which Apple's spiritual core took shape and introduces Simon Sinek's concept of the Golden Circle. The Golden Circle consists of three concentric circles: why, how, and what. The why represents the mission and purpose of a business, while the how explains the unique approach or values that drive it, and the what refers to the products or services offered. Apple's mission is to think differently and challenge the status quo, and this why resonates with customers on an emotional level, leading to their loyalty and support. Knowing and communicating the why of a company is crucial for attracting customers, engaging employees, and achieving long-term success.

The key takeaways are:

  • The Golden Circle concept, consisting of the why, how, and what, helps explain the success of great leaders and organizations. The why represents the mission and purpose, the how is the unique approach or values, and the what is the products or services offered.
  • Apple's mission to think differently and challenge the status quo is its why. This resonates with customers on an emotional level and creates strong loyalty and support.
  • Knowing and communicating the why of a company is crucial for attracting customers and engaging employees. It helps create a sense of purpose and filters out those who are not aligned with the mission.
  • Starting with why rather than what is important for long-term success. Products and services are a result of the why, not the other way around. The why drives the company and its offerings, creating a deeper connection with customers.


How to start with why

This book emphasises the importance of knowing and effectively communicating the why of a company. It highlights that many founders and leaders struggle to articulate the purpose of their organizations, which hinders their ability to attract customers and engage employees. The content provides practical tips to address this challenge:
  1. Finding your why: Explore your past and identify patterns that reveal what you were known for and what made you special. This self-reflection can help uncover your purpose and guide your company's mission.
  2. Clearly communicating your why: Utilize the Golden Circle framework by starting with why, followed by how, and then what. Communicate your purpose and beliefs before explaining the methods and products. This approach resonates with customers and employees on an emotional level.
  3. Focus on the why as a leader: Concentrate on inspiring and guiding others while delegating the operational aspects to capable senior executives. Regularly reinforce the why to keep employees connected to the mission and maintain clarity in decision-making.
By understanding and effectively communicating the why, companies can attract loyal customers, engage passionate employees, and achieve long-term success.

"Start With Why" highlights the importance of inspiring others as a leader with a story. The story involves two stonemasons working on a construction site. When asked if they like their job, the first stonemason expresses dissatisfaction, focusing on the difficulties and lack of purpose. In contrast, the second stonemason, despite acknowledging the challenges, expresses love for the job because he sees it as building a cathedral.

The story emphasizes that both stonemasons are doing the same work, but the second one has a sense of purpose and inspiration. As a leader, the content suggests that it is your role to remind everyone why they are doing something and provide them with a sense of purpose. By giving them "cathedrals" or a meaningful goal, you can inspire and motivate your team.


Image Source: “Find Your Why” by Simon Sinek


 


"Nudge" by Richard H. Thaler and Cass R. Sunstein is a book that explores the concept of nudges and how they can be used to influence people's choices for the better. A nudge refers to any aspect of the choice architecture that alters people's behavior in a predictable way without forbidding any options or significantly changing their economic incentives.

Richard H. Thaler (b. 1945) is a professor of Behavioral Science and Economics at the University of Chicago. Cass R. Sunstein (b. 1954) is a professor at Harvard Law School and serves as an advisor to president Barack Obama.




Summary & Key Learnings

The book argues that small changes in the way choices are presented can have a significant impact on people's decisions. By understanding the two systems that drive human thinking—the automatic system (quick and instinctual) and the reflective system (slow and deliberate)—the authors explain how human behavior is influenced by both conscious and unconscious factors.

Thaler and Sunstein introduce the concept of libertarian paternalism, which suggests that it is possible to influence people's behavior in a way that improves their overall well-being without limiting their freedom of choice. They believe policymakers have a responsibility to design choice architectures that nudge individuals toward better decisions.

Throughout the book, the authors present various examples and case studies to illustrate how nudges can be applied in different contexts. They discuss topics such as encouraging saving through the Save More Tomorrow program, improving school choices for parents, personalising social security investments, and even privatising marriage contracts.

The key premise of the book is that by carefully designing the choice architecture and considering the automatic and reflective systems at play, policymakers can help people make better decisions in areas such as finance, health, education, and more. The book advocates for the use of nudges to create an environment that leads to improved outcomes and individual well-being.


We often make bad decisions based on either too little or overly complex information.

Why do we so often make decisions that aren’t really the best choices for us? In many cases, we simply have too little or too much information, or we can’t foresee the consequences of our actions. It’s only when we have, and can process, the right amount of information that we are in a place to make rational decisions.

For example, when we have to choose an ice cream flavor at an ice cream shop, we usually make that decision rather quickly. We see which flavors there are and we know from experience that strawberry ice cream tastes better than mango, i.e., we have all the necessary information and can process it rapidly.

However, we feel differently in more serious situations, like when deciding whether to take out a loan. After all, there are all different kinds of loans: purchases on account, deferrals, consumer loans, securities, preliminary financing, interim financing, and many more. Some of them have a fixed interest rate, others a variable; all of them have different additional costs. And this information isn’t exactly laid out in plain writing. Usually, it’s hidden in the small print on the bright and colorful advertisement.

In other words, even when we are privy to all the relevant information, it can still be difficult to sort it all out and compare the services objectively. Situations like this can make us feel completely overwhelmed.


Human beings act mainly on gut feelings.

When we see a laughing baby, we can’t help but smile. That “decision” to smile is made unconsciously; our response occurs entirely on its own. But when we want to figure out the answer to 347 x 12, we confront this task in a conscious way, because finding the answer requires an effort and takes some time. These examples illustrate two different systems of thought: In the case of the baby, we are using our Automatic System, i.e., our gut instinct. In the case of the math problem, we are using the rational or Reflective System. We don’t have the time or energy to reflect upon every little action we take on an average day, which is why we often let our Automatic System govern our actions. It works well a lot of the time – but not all the time.

Grounded in simplifications, the Automatic System is often supported by a weak scaffolding of spontaneous emotions and subjective experiences. For instance, when we estimate our own likelihood of suffering from a stroke, the first thing we think about is the amount of people we know who’ve already had one. If we don’t know anybody who’s had a stroke, we automatically assume that there’s only a low risk that we’ll have one. And so, even if our own risk is actually extremely high, we don’t take any precautions. In other words, our gut feeling has led us first to a misjudgment and then to an unwise decision.


Sometimes we make faulty decisions because we succumb to temptation or act without thinking.

If you offer a long-time smoker a cigarette while she’s in the process of quitting, it’ll be difficult for her to resist the temptation. Although she’d like to quit and knows how bad it is for her, she’ll probably end up bumming a smoke. The reason for this unwise response is a lack of will: despite her intentions, the temptation is simply too great. A certain degree of thoughtlessness also takes hold of us in such situations.

For example, experiments have shown that bigger portions cause us to eat more. If we have a big portion in front of us, we eat more of it than we should – even if it doesn’t taste good. In one experiment, researchers sent their test subjects to the movies. Before they entered the theater, the subjects received a bag of stale popcorn – half got a small bag, the other half a medium-sized bag. Although most of the participants later stated that the stale popcorn didn’t taste good, they ate a lot of it anyway – and the people with the big bags ate even more of theirs.


Some companies exploit the human tendency to make the wrong decisions.

If companies want to be successful, they have to sell products and earn profits. And to do that, they have to fulfill their customers’ needs. Whether that has positive or negative consequences on customers doesn’t matter to some companies – their main concern is whether customers are buying. Sometimes companies don’t just satisfy the needs that customers already have – they can create new needs in their customers too.

For example, many people can’t help themselves in the face of temptation and don’t think twice about the consequences when making spur-of-the-moment decisions. Companies use this knowledge to tempt their customers into buying more than they originally intended. This is the core approach of companies that promote XXL-sized portions instead of normal ones, and the availability of these over-sized portions is one of the reasons why so many people eat far too much.

Trial subscriptions to periodicals are another case where companies exploit human weakness. You can sign up and receive the periodical for free for a certain amount of time, but, if you don’t terminate your subscription within the cancellation period, it is automatically renewed, and you continue receiving the periodical – and paying for it.


Nudges are subtle changes in context that help us avoid making bad decisions.

How can we keep ourselves from making the wrong decisions? With nudges, or little pushes in the right direction. Nudges are not “no-nos” or clever advertising messages. Rather, they are subtle actions that make it easier for us to act in the way that is best for us without dictating a specific behavior. Simply put, nudges leave us free rein while making it easier for us to choose the right thing. Displaying fruit in clearly visible spots and putting junk food in less prominent ones in a cafeteria is a nudge: we have the choice between buying an apple and a candy bar, but the arrangement of the products prompts us to go for the healthier apple.

Of course, nudges can also be used for less righteous purposes, e.g., by companies who want to suggest certain purchasing decisions. Companies have been using nudges for a long time – in supermarkets, for example, the shelves at eye level usually contain the most expensive goods. But the example of the fruit being prominently displayed in the cafeteria shows that nudges can also help people choose healthier and better alternatives.



Defaults are highly effective nudges that cause people to automatically do what’s best for them.

Considering that we don’t rack our brains every time we make a decision, decision-making situations should be designed so that automatic responses produce a positive outcome. The e-mail service Gmail does just that with its attachment reminder. If words like “please find attached” are written in e-mail text but no file has been attached, the e-mail program automatically recognises it and asks the user, “Did you want to send an attachment?” This little nudge can save people a lot of time and trouble.

Companies could choose a similar system to assist their employees to make wise decisions about, e.g., enrolling in company pension-scheme programs. Since most people are naturally inclined to laziness and don’t really want to change their status quo, enrolling in a company pension-scheme program should not be optional. It would be much better to set up the program so that all employees are automatically enrolled in the scheme – and have to explicitly object if they do not want to be. Companies should choose defaults guaranteeing that employees do the right thing even when the employees do nothing at all.


Nudges are most useful when we have too many choices or when the future is at stake.

The most opportune time to use nudges is in situations where it’s particularly difficult for us to make the right decisions. Making the wrong decision is easy when we have an immediate pay-off and don’t feel the negative consequences until later. We take that second piece of cake and drink that cocktail after work because they give us pleasure in the moment and we only feel the negative effects later – when we step on a scale at the end of the month, or wake up the next morning with a headache.

Another cause of bad decision-making is when we don’t have previous experiences to refer to. At some point or another, we have to decide on which insurance company we want to use. Since we only make this decision once or twice in our lives, we can’t refer to earlier experiences to assess which insurance company would be best for us. And even after choosing a health insurance company, there is yet another decision to be made: which policy? For example, if an insurance company offers many different policies, but some customers who just want general coverage are having difficulty choosing which policy would be best for them, the company could offer a recommended “default policy” – say, one that covers more than 80% of a person’s entire medical costs. This helps the less insurance-savvy customers choose a policy that covers a wide range of treatments for the most common medical problems.



Many people use nudges to achieve their goals.

At the end of each year, many of us come to the conclusion that, yet again, we didn’t manage to stick to our New Year’s resolutions: the number on the scale is higher than last year and the ashtray is still full. And yet some people are successful. How did they do it? Generally, the people who are able to stick to their resolutions do so by using nudges to keep them from making the wrong decisions throughout the year: they place bets with their friends, take advantage of public weigh-ins, or use Internet programs tailored to help them monitor their progress and stay on target.

On the website Stickk.com, more than 100,000 people have signed so called commitment contracts with themselves to achieve their goals. After signing up on the website, you state your goal, set milestones with specific deadlines, and have the option to put money on your success. If you achieve your goal, you get your money back. If not, your money goes to whatever institution or person you initially selected (one particularly motivating recipient, for example, might be the rival team of your favorite football team). This successful website is an example of how nudges can be harnessed to help you modify your behavior and fulfill your ambitions.



States and other institutions should use nudges to encourage wise decisions.

Nudges encourage individuals to make better decisions – and this often benefits more than just the individual alone. An entire society benefits when the majority of its members make wise decisions. If fewer people smoke or are overweight, healthcare costs decrease – and everybody wins.

Even though a nudge may cost us something at first, the longer term benefits are generally not long in coming. In the area of environmental protection, the mere act of instating a public obligation to report carbon emissions has the power to change peoples’ behavior. This obligation doesn’t explicitly forbid companies to exceed a certain limit of pollutant emissions. Instead, it acts as a nudge by creating incentives to voluntarily cut down on emissions (especially because environmentalists frequently use such information to publicly denounce polluters). The reporting obligation thus creates a sort of emission-cutting competition – without using any legal coercion.

As the dollar-a-day program shows, nudges can also reduce the amount of unwanted teenage pregnancies. Many young mothers who’ve already had a child as a teenager often get pregnant again shortly thereafter. In order to tackle this issue, several US cities pay teenage mothers one dollar for every day they don’t get pregnant. This program is actually cheaper for taxpayers than the costs of supporting the children of the young mothers.

Companies also use nudges to keep their customers from making mistakes. If we forget to put on our seat belt in a car, the car beeps at us until we buckle up. If our gas tank is almost empty, a warning light blinks to remind us to stop and fill it up. These little things don’t force us to fasten our seat belts or fill our gas tanks: they do, however, prevent us from accidentally forgetting.


People often make unwise decisions, but the slightest of changes – so-called nudges – can give people incentives to make better decisions. That’s why countries and private institutions should also use nudges.

The questions this book answered:

How and why do we make the wrong decisions?
  • We don’t always make decisions that are best for us in the long run.
  • We often make bad decisions based on either too little or overly complex information.
  • Human beings act mainly on gut feelings.
  • Sometimes we make faulty decisions because we succumb to temptation or act without thinking.
  • Some companies exploit the human tendency to make the wrong decisions.

How can nudges help us deal with this problem?
  • Nudges are subtle changes in context that help us avoid making bad decisions.
  • Defaults are highly effective nudges that cause people to automatically do what’s best for them.
  • Nudges are most useful when we have too many choices or when the future is at stake.

How can each and every one of us use nudges?
  • Many people use nudges to achieve their goals.
  • States and other institutions should use nudges to encourage wise decisions.


 

'Influence' explains in detail the fundamental principles of persuasion. How do you get people to say yes? How do other people get you to say yes? How are you manipulated by sleek salesmen, clever marketing folks and sneaky confidence tricksters? This book will help you understand the psychology behind their techniques, enabling you to unleash your own persuasive powers, while also defending against their tactics of manipulation.

Influence has been authored by Robert B. Cialdini, PhD a Professor Emeritus of Psychology and Marketing at Arizona State University. He also acted as a visiting professor at Stanford University and the University of California at Santa Cruz. Influence is based on 35 years of evidence-based research into the phenomena of influence, manipulation and persuasion. Dr. Cialdini also runs a consultancy based on teaching and implementing the ethical business applications of his research.




Summary & Key Learnings

Chapter 1 - Levers of Influence: (Power) Tools of the Trades
Chapter 2 - Reciprocation: The Old Give and Take
Chapter 3 - Liking: The Friendly Thief
Chapter 4 - Social Proof: Truths Are Us
Chapter 5 - Authority: Directed Deference
Chapter 6 - Scarcity: The Rule of the Few
Chapter 7 - Commitment and Consistency: Hobgoblins of the Mind
Chapter 8 - Unity: The "We" Is the Shared Me
Chapter 9 - Instant Influence: Primitive Consent for an Automatic Age

This book teaches you the 6 fundamental principles of manipulation and the most relevant persuasion techniques that compliance professionals employ. It will help you defend yourself from deceit, but also put these techniques to use yourself, should you need to flex some persuasive muscle. In many situations, we humans like to avoid thinking about how we should react by using predictable shortcuts to guide our decisions. Compliance professionals like advertisers, con artists and salespeople take advantage of these preprogrammed human reactions to elicit the response that’s in their best interests, not ours. Specifically, they leverage the principles of reciprocation, scarcity, consistency, social proof, liking and authority. Since we cannot stop using these shortcuts that mostly serve us well, we must instead learn to defend ourselves against the manipulators who abuse them.


Chapter 1 - Levers of Influence: (Power) Tools of the Trades

Ethologist, researchers who study animal behavior in the natural environment, have noticed that among many animal species, behaviour often occurs in rigid and mechanical patterns. Called fixed-action patterns, these mechanical sequences are noteworthy in their similarity to certain automatic responses by humans. For both humans and subhumans, the automatic-behaviour patterns tend to be triggered by a single feature, or trigger feature, can often prove valuable by allowing an individual to decide on a correct course of action without having to analyse carefully and completely each of the other pieces of information in the situation.

The advantage of such shortcut responding lies in its efficiency and economy; by reacting automatically to a normally informative trigger feature, an individual preserves crucial time, energy, and mental capacity. The disadvantage of such responding lies in its vulnerability to silly and costly mistakes; by reacting to only a piece of the available information (enven a usually predictive piece), an individual increases the chances of error, especially when responding in an automatic, mindless fashion. The chances of error increase even further when other individuals seek to profit by arranging (through manipulation of trigger features) ti stimulate a desired behaviour at inappropriate times.

Since dealing with the complexities of life means having to rely on shortcuts, we must identify and defend ourselves against the manipulators who would trick us into wrongly using those shortcuts. The following chapters introduce the 6 basic psychological principles that we use as shortcuts, and which can be exploited for persuasion which are: reciprocation, scarcity, consistency, social proof, liking and authority.

Perceptual contrast is the tendency to see 2 things that are different from one another as being more different than they actually are. It is a lever of influence used by some compliance practitioners. For example, real estate agents may show prospective home buyers one or 2 unattractive options before showing them a more attractive home, which then seems more attractive than it would have if shown first. An advantage of employing this lever of influence is that its tactical use typically goes unrecognised.


Chapter 2 - Reciprocation: The Old Give and Take

According to sociologists and anthropologists, one of the most widespread and basic norms of human culture is embodied in the rule of reciprocation. The rule requires that one person try to repay, in form, what another person has provided. By obligating the recipient of an act to repayment in the future, the rule allows one individual to give something to another with confidence that it is not being lost. This rule forms the foundation of all societies, for it allowed our ancestors to share resources, safe in the knowledge that they would be reciprocated later. 

And if someone does us a favor and we do not return it, we feel a psychological burden. This is partially because, as a society, we are disdainful of those who do not reciprocate favors; we label them as moochers or ingrates and fear being labeled as such ourselves. The desire to reciprocate is intense that people are so keen to rid themselves of the burden of reciprocity that they will often perform much larger favors in return for small ones.

So how can you fight back?

Reciprocity plays a fundamental role in the way societies and social relationships work, so you can’t forego the principle entirely. But you can learn to identify and resist deliberate attempts to abuse it.

Start by getting into the habit of asking yourself if the favors you receive are really genuine, or if they could be attempts to manipulate you. Think about whether you actually want to donate your money to that nonprofit organization, or if you only feel obliged because they handed you a gift on the street. And don’t worry about not reciprocating “favors” that are really manipulation attempts in disguise; favors warrant favors in return, but tricks do not.


Chapter 3 - Liking: The Friendly Thief

People prefer to say yes to individuals they like. Recognising this rule, compliance professionals commonly increase their effectiveness by emphasising several factors that increase their overall likability.

One feature is physical attractiveness.
Although i has long been suspected that physical beauty provides an advantage in social interaction, research indicates the advantage may be greater than supposed. Physical attractiveness engenders a halo-effect that leads to the assignment of other traits such as talent, kindness, and intelligence. As a result, attractive people are more persuasive both in terms of getting what they request and changing others' attitudes. 

A second factor that influences liking and compliance is similarity.
We like people who are like us, and we are more willing to say yes to their requests, often in an unthinking manner. 

Another factor is praise.
Compliments generally enhance liking and, hence, compliance. 2 particularly useful types of genuine compliments are those delivered behind the recipient's back and those selected to give the recipient a reputation to live up to, by continuing to perform the desired behaviour.

Increased familiarity through repeated contact with a person or thing is yet another factor that normally facilitates liking. 
This relationship hold true principally when the contact takes place under positive rather than negative circumstances. One positive circumstance that works especially well is mutual and successful cooperation. A fifth factor linked to liking is association. By connecting themselves on their products with positive things, advertisers, politicians, and merchandisers frequently seek to share in the positivity through the process of association. Other individuals as well (sports fans for example) appear to recognised the positive effect of simple connections and try to associate themselves with favorable events and distance themselves from unfavorable events in the eyes of observers.

How do we protect ourselves against likability manipulation? 
A good step is to ask ourselves whether we have come to like someone or something unusually strongly in a short time. If so, this could be due to some form of manipulation, and alarm bells should ring.


Chapter 4 - Social Proof: Truths Are Us

The principle of social proof states that one important means people use to decide what to believe or how to act in a situation is to examine what others are believing or doing there. The principle of social proof can be used to stimulate a person's compliance with a request by communicating that many other individuals (the more, the better) are or have been complying with it. Therefore, simply pointing to the popularity of an item elevates its popularity.

Social proof is most influential under 3 conditions:

1st condition is uncertainty.
When people are unsure, when the situation is ambiguous, they are more likely to attend to the actions of others and to accept those actions as correct. In ambiguous situations, for instance, the decisions of bystanders to offer emergency aid are much more influenced by the actions of other bystanders than when the situation is a clear-cut emergency.

2nd condition under which social proof is most influential involves "The many."
People are more inclined to follow the lead of others in proportion to the others' number. When we see multiple other performing an action, we become willing to follow because the action appears to be more (1) correct/valid, (2) feasible, and (3) socially acceptable.

3rd condition is similarity.
People conform to the beliefs and actions of comparable others, especially their peers - a phenomenon we can call peer-suasion. 

When communicators are not able to use existing social proof because their idea, cause, or product does not have widespread support, they may be able to harness the power of future social proof by honestly describing trending support, which audiences expect to continue.

Recommendations to reduce our susceptibility to faulty social, proof include cultivating a sensitivity to counterfeit evidence of what similar others are doing and recognising that the actions of similar others should not form the sole basis for our decisions.


Chapter 5 - Authority: Directed Deference

Renowned psychologist Stanley Milgram conducted a study in the 1960s showing that volunteers would administer potentially lethal electric shocks to others simply because they were told to do so by an authority figure. Although no one was harmed, the experimenters were surprised by the results. In the Milgram studies, we see evidence of strong pressures for compliance with the requests of an authority. Acting contrary to their own preferences, many normal, psychologically healthy individuals were willing to deliver dangerous levels of pain to another person because they were directed to do so by an authority figure. 

From birth, we’re taught to always obey figures of authority, be they teachers, doctors or police officers. Unfortunately, this tendency to comply with authority is so ingrained and powerful that we don’t bother to think or challenge perceived authority figures before obeying them. It is adaptive to obey the dictates of genuine authorities because such individuals usually possess high levels of knowledge, wisdom, and power. For these reasons, deference to authorities can occur in a mindless fashion as a kind of decision-making shortcut.

When reacting to authority in an automatic fashion, people have a tendency to do so in response to mere symbols of authority rather than to its substance. 3 kinds of symbols effective in this regard are titles, clothing, and trappings such as automobiles. In studies, individuals possessing prestigious forms of one or another of the symbole (and no other legitimising credentials) were accorded more deference or obedience by those they encountered.

Authority influence flows from being viewed as either in authority or an authority. But the first of these types, merely being in charge, has its problems. Ordering people to do things often generates resistance and resentment. The second type of authority, being viewed as highly informed, avoids this problems, as people are usually willing follow the recommendations of someone who knows more than they do on the matter at hand.

The persuasive effect of being seen as an authority is maximised by also being seens as a credible such authority - one perceived as both expert (knowledgeable on the relevant topic) and trustworthy (honest in the presentation of one's knowledge). To estable their trustworthiness, communicators may admit to a (usually minor) shortcoming of their case, which ca be swept aside later by the presentation of outweighing strengths.

It is possible to defend ourselves against the detrimental effects of authority influence by asking 2 questions:

Is this authority truly an expert?
How truthful can we expect this expert to be?

The first directs our attention away from symbols and toward evidence for authority status. 
The second advises us to consider not just the expert's knowledge in the situation by also his or her trustworthiness. With regard to this second consideration, we should be alert to the trust-enhancing tactic in which communicators first provide mildly negative information about themselves. Through this strategy, they create a perception of honesty that makes all subsequent information seem more believable to observers. 


Chapter 6 - Scarcity: The Rule of the Few

According to the scarcity principle, people assign more value to opportunities that are less available. The use of this principle for profit can be seen in such compliance techniques as the "limited number" and "deadline" tactics, wherein practitioners try to convince us that if we don't act now, we will lose something of value. This engages the human tendency for loss aversion - that people are more motivated by the thought of losing something than by the thought of gaining something of equal value.

When does scarcity become a powerful influence on our decision-making?

Two conditions need to be fulfilled:

  1. First, we tend to want something more if its availability has decreased recently than if it has remained steady over time. This is why revolutions tend to happen when living conditions deteriorate sharply rather than when they are consistently low; the sudden drop increases people’s desire for something better, so they take to the streets.
  2. Second, competition always sets our hearts racing. Whether in auctions, romances or real-estate deals, the thought of losing something to a rival often turns us from reluctant to overzealous. This is why, for example, real estate agents often mention to buyers that several other bidders are also interested in a given house, whether true or not. In fact, a competitive situation can induce a “feeding frenzy” for a scarce good, even among seasoned negotiators.

To counter the eagerness that arises from scarcity, we should always consider whether we want the item in question because of its use to us (for example, its taste or function), or merely because of an irrational wish to possess it. When scarcity is being used against us, the answer will often be the latter.


Chapter 7 - Commitment and Consistency: Hobgoblins of the Mind

Psychologists have long recognised a desire in most people to be and look consistent within their words, attitudes, and deeds. This tendency for consistency is fed from 3 sources. 
  1. First, good personal consistency is highly valued by society.
  2. Second, aside from its effect on public image, generally consistent conduct provides a beneficial approach to daily life.
  3. Third, a consistent orientation affords a valuable shortcut through the complexity of modern existence. By being consistent with earlier decisions, one reduces the need to process all the relevant information in future similar situations; instead, one merely needs to recall the earlier decision and to respond consistently with it.
Within the realm of compliance, securing an initial commitment is the key. After making a commitment (that is, taking an action, stand, or position), people are more willing to agree to requests in keeping with the prior commitment. Thus, many compliance professionals try to induce people to take an initial position that is consistent with a behaviour they will later request from these people. Not all commitments are equally effective in producing consistent future action. Commitments are most effective when they are active, public, effortful, and viewed as internally motivated (voluntary), because each of these elements changes self-image. The reason they do so is that each element gives us information about what we must truly believe.

Commitment decisions, even erroneous ones, have a tendency to be self-perpetuating because they can "grow their own legs." That is, people often add new reasons and justifications to support the wisdom of commitments they have already made. As a consequence, some commitments remain in effect long after the conditions that spurred them have changed. This phenomenon explains the effectiveness of certain deceptive compliance practices such as "throwing the low-ball."

Another advantage of commitment-based tactics is that simple reminder of an earlier commitment can regenerate its ability to guide behaviour, even in novel situations. In addition, reminders do more than restore the commitment's vigor, they appear to intensify it by strengthening one's related self-image.

To recognise and resist the undue influence of consistency pressures on our compliance decisions, we should listen for signals coming from 2 places within us: our stomachs and our heart or hearts. 

  • Stomach signs - appear when we realise we are being pushed by commitment and consistency pressures to agree to requests we know we don't want to perform. Under these circumstances, it is best to explain to the requester that such compliance would constitute a brand of foolish consistency in which re prefer not to engage.
  • Heart-of-heart signs - are different. They are best employed when it is not clear to us that an initial commitment was wrongheaded. Here, we should ask ourselves a crucial question: "Knowing what I now know, if I could go back in time, would I make the same commitment?" One informative answer may come as the first flash of feeling registered. 

Commitment and consistency tactics are likely to work especially well on members of individualistic societies, particularly those who are over 50 years old, who, hence, should be particularly wary of their use. 


Chapter 8 - Unity: The "We" Is the Shared Me

People say yes to someone they consider one of them. The experience of "we"-ness (unity) with others is about shared identities - tribe-like categories that individuals use to define themselves and their groups, such as race, ethnicity, nationality, and family, as well as political and religious affiliations.

Research into "we"-groups has produced 3 general conclusions.
  1. Members of these groups favour the outcomes and welfare of fellow members over those of nonmembers,
  2. "We"-group members also use the preferences and actions of fellow members to guide their own, which enhances group solidarity.
  3. Finally, such partisan tendencies have arisen, evolutionarily, as ways to advantage our "we"-groups and, ultimately, ourselves.
These 3 constants have surfaced in a wide range of domains, including business, politics, sports, and personal relationships.

The perception of belonging together with others is one fundamental factor leading to feelings of "we"-ness. This perception is generated by commonalities of kinship (amount of genetic overlap) as well as by commonalities of place (including one's home, locality, and region). 

The experience of acting together in unison or coordination is a second fundamental factor leading to a sense of unity with others. Shared musical experience is one way people can act together and feel consequent unity. Other ways involve repeated reciprocal exchange, joint suffering, and co-creation.

It may be possible to use the unifying effects of belonging together and acting together to increase the odds of getting together as a species. It would require choosing to share, with out-group members, family experiences in our communities, and friendship experiences in our social interactions.

Other kinds of connections involving national identity, mutual enemies, joint emotional experience, and shared perspective can also lead to feelings of unity with out-group members; unfortunately, they are often short-lived. However, focusing concentrated, repeated attention on such connections may make them more enduring by increasing their perceived importance.


Chapter 9 - Instant Influence: Primitive Consent for an Automatic Age

Modern lift is different from that of any earlier time. Owing to remarkable technological advances, information is burgeoning, alternatives are multiplying, and knowledge is exploding. In this avalache of change and choice, we have had to adjust. One fundamental adjustment has come in the way we make decisions. Although we all wish to make the most thoughtful, fully considered decision possible in any situation, the changing form and accelerating pace of modern life frequently deprive us of the proper conditions for such a careful analysis of all the relevant pros and cons. More and more, we are forced to resort to another decision-making approach - a shortcut approach in which the decision to comply (or agree or believe or buy) is made on the basis of a single, usually reliable piece of information. The most reliable and, therefore, more popular such single triggers for compliance are those described in the book. they are commitments, opportunities for reciprocation, the compliant behaviour of similar others, feelings of liking or unity, authority directives, and scarcity information.

Because of the increasing tendency for cognitive overload in our society, the prevalence of shortcut decision-making is likely to increase proportionately. Compliance professionals who infuse their requests with one or another of the levers of influence are more likely to be successful. The use of these levers by practitioners is not necessarily exploitative. It only becomes so when the lever is not a natural feature of the situation but is fabricated by the practitioner. In order to retain the beneficial character of shortcut response, it is important to oppose such fabrication by all appropriate means.



'How Innovation Works' by Matt Ridley, offers a systematic examination of this incredibly important but poorly understood phenomenon. What is innovation? According to Ridley, it is much more than invention (something often mistaken for innovation). Invention is the act of discovering an idea; it is merely a beginning, an inception point. Innovation is much more, it is when the invention is taken into the world and made practical. Innovation is the creative reconfiguration of multiple inventions and ideas into something new. Innovation is the act of fully exploring the consequences of that new thing and disseminating and integrating it into society and general use. 

Matt Ridley argues that we need to see innovation as an incremental, bottom-up, fortuitous process that happens as a direct result of the human habit of exchange, rather than an orderly, top-down process developing according to a plan. Innovation is crucially different from invention, because it is the turning of inventions into things of practical and affordable use to people. It speeds up in some sectors and slows down in others. It is always a collective, collaborative phenomenon, involving trial and error, not a matter of lonely genius. It still cannot be modelled properly by economists, but it can easily be discouraged by politicians. Far from there being too much innovation, we may be on the brink of an innovation famine.

Matt Ridley, 5th Viscount Ridley, is a British science writer, journalist and businessman. He is best known for his writings on science, the environment, and economics.


Key learnings

Innovation isn’t an instantaneous creative act practiced by lone geniuses. It’s actually a long, messy, and complicated process. Innovation occurs when chance encounters and serendipitous insights are shared, remixed, and built upon by countless individuals. New inventions are slowly and incrementally improved over time as people find practical uses for novel ideas. If we want more innovation in the future, we need to foster the open exchange of knowledge and take big risks as individuals, organizations, and nations.


Innovation is a complex, messy, and collective process

The Industrial Revolution – the giant leap in productivity that kicked off the modern era – began when humans first harnessed the power of steam to automate work. To do this, they used a new machine called the atmospheric steam engine. So, who do we thank for this astounding achievement? A man named Denis Papin. Or, wait, maybe we should thank Thomas Savery. Or, hold on, maybe a fellow called Thomas Newcomen deserves our praise? The truth is, all three men deserve some credit, but none of them can claim all of it. That’s because, around 1700, Papin, Savery, and Newcomen all produced their own working models of the atmospheric engine. To this day, it’s unclear who was truly first or how much each inventor influenced the others.

We often associate a new invention with a single creator. However, that’s an oversimplification of how innovation operates. Even the most creative people don’t work in a vacuum. They’re always influenced by the tools, technologies, ideas, and social structures that surround them. This often means multiple forces contribute to an innovation, even when one person takes the credit. Let’s consider the case of the atmospheric steam engine. This relatively simple device heats and cools water in a metal cylinder. The changing pressure caused by steam creates movement that can be used for work, like pumping water out of mines. Could Papin, Savery, or Newcomen have invented this completely on their own? Not really. The basic ideas behind the device were already hot topics of discussion in scientific circles at the time. Papin and Savery, both educated men, refined their thinking by exchanging letters and papers with other inventors. Moreover, Newcomen, who built the most successful version of the engine, relied on previous advances in blacksmithing technology to complete his machine. Thus, each man’s invention was also a product of their backgrounds and influences.

This principle applies to all innovation. While Thomas Edison gets credit for inventing the light bulb in 1879, the truth is, more than 20 other creators patented similar contraptions in earlier decades. All these thinkers were responding to ideas and technologies circulating at the time. Of course, some of these attempts were better than others, but none of these innovations happened in complete isolation.


Medical innovations offer high risks and even higher rewards

While the atmospheric steam engine kicked off the Industrial Revolution, medicine evolved with its own innovative procedures, like the following: Step one: Find someone recovering from smallpox. Carefully scrape some pus off one of the many open lesions caused by the disease. Step two: Using a knife or needle, cut an open wound into your own skin. Not too deep, but deep enough to draw blood. Step three: Rub the infected pus into your wound.

This technique is called engraftment. In most cases, it’ll make you immune to smallpox. If it seems gross and dangerous now, just imagine how it appeared to a European in the 1700s. They didn’t have a scientific understanding of why it worked, yet it did work. So, as the century progressed, the practice caught on. It saved countless lives and eventually led to the discovery of modern-day vaccines.

An interesting fact about innovation is that the biggest revelations don’t always come from deliberate discovery or sound scientific theory. Instead, they develop piecemeal over time through random chance, as well as trial and error, as people look for practical solutions to their problems. In the medical field, this is a particularly risky process, but it has resulted in many life-saving practices.

Consider Jersey City’s water supply. In 1908, rapid industrial development tainted the city’s water with unsanitary runoff. The result was serious outbreaks of cholera and other diseases. In a rush to fix the problem, Dr. John Leal added chloride of lime, a disinfectant, to the water. At the time, adding chemicals to drinking water was considered repulsive. Local citizens were outraged. But Leal had heard rumors of it working in European cities, so he tried it anyway. Within months, the experiment paid off, and disease rates plummeted. Soon, communities all around the country were following Jersey City’s example.

Are such open-ended experiments occurring today? Of course. Take the example of electronic cigarettes, also known as vaping. For many, picking up a vaping habit is the first step toward quitting smoking. Since tobacco use is a major cause of death, this could save many lives. Yet, we don’t fully know the health effects of vaping, so their use remains controversial. In some countries, like the United Kingdom, government agencies encourage their use. In contrast, other countries, like Australia, have banned it. Which country takes the right stance on this innovation? That remains to be seen.


Travel innovation is all about incremental improvements

The Salamanca, the Puffing Billy, the Sans Pareil. These names sound silly now, but in the early 1800s, each represented a small step toward improving the way we move. You see, at the dawn of the nineteenth century, the horse was the king of transportation. However, inventors believed a machine, the steam-powered locomotive, could take its place. The tricky part was figuring out how to build one. So, engineers tried a great deal of different designs, giving each new prototype a bold new name. Not every device succeeded, but some made subsequent improvements in speed, safety, or reliability. By 1829, the Rocket, a locomotive built by Robert Stephenson, was capable of transporting 13 tons of cargo at 30 miles an hour – and the world was on its way to a railway boom.

Throughout history, humans have always looked for faster, more reliable ways to travel. However, no new mode of transportation ever emerged in a completely perfect form. For example, the sleek, efficient machines that carry us around today are the result of countless individuals making innumerable small design improvements over time.

Look at the evolution of today’s automobiles. Most rely on the internal-combustion engine for power. Isaac de Rivaz, a Franco-Swiss artillery officer, built this machine’s earliest ancestor back in 1807. It ran on hydrogen and oxygen and was loud, clunky, and prone to explosions. In 1860, a Pennsylvanian man named Jean Joseph Lenoir updated the design to run on petroleum. This was a step-up, but the device was still very inefficient.

Next, in 1876, Nikolau Otto, a grocery salesman, refined the machine by adding a four-step cycle of compression and ignition. Dubbed the four-stroke engine, this model allowed for smoother operation. This design was adopted by the German inventor Karl Benz. In 1894, he amped up the engine’s power and used it to drive a three-wheeled machine called the Motorwagen.

While the Motorwagen was a hit with the rich, it remained a novelty. It took another inventor, Henry Ford, to bring the automobile to the masses. In 1909, his assembly-line manufacturing process made the Model T car affordable to more people. Soon, cars were one of the most popular forms of transportation around. It took decades of slow, steady improvement, but the engine had finally conquered the horse.


Some innovations aren’t solid things but simply good ideas

The humble potato is the basis for so many popular snacks and dishes we love today, but this wasn’t always the case. At least, it wasn’t in Europe. That took some innovation. First cultivated more than 8,000 years ago in the Andes Mountains of South America, the potato didn’t arrive in the Old World until the mid-1500s. However, for decades, Europeans regarded potatoes with suspicion. The church in England banned them. People in France believed they caused leprosy. Still, slowly, people learned to love this robust, nutrient-rich crop. The idea of eating potatoes first caught on in Belgium. Then the idea spread throughout the entire continent. By the 1800s, most European countries had made the potato a new staple of their cuisine.

Often, the concept of innovation gets reduced to invention. That is, we think of innovation as the process of making new tangible items like labor-saving machines or electronic gizmos. However, some of the most influential innovations of all time aren’t objects at all. Instead, they’re ideas that open up new ways to approach the world or solve problems.

One intangible innovation you use every day is the Arabic numeric system, more commonly known as numbers.
Yes, even the idea of using 1s, 2s, and 3s was once revolutionary. This counting system was first developed by Indian scholars around 500 AD. It was then adopted by Arab traders in the ninth century, and finally found a foothold in Europe in the 1200s thanks to an Italian author known as Fibonacci. Fibonacci advocated for using Arabic numerals because they were more practical than the Roman numerals popular at the time. Their key advantage was their positional system. While the Roman numeral V always means five, the Arabic five changes value based on its position in a sequence. So, a five followed by a zero means 50, a value ten times greater.

This seems like a small change, but it opens a whole new world for mathematics. With Arabic numbers, it’s possible to do more advanced calculations like multiplication, division, and algebra. It’s also much easier to keep financial records and do accounting. Adopting the idea of Arabic numbers was an innovation essential to launching Europe into a new age of trade, commerce, and scientific discovery.



Our desire to communicate drives rapid innovation

Baltimore, Maryland, 1843. The Whig Party holds a convention and nominates Henry Clay for president. It’s big news, and usually, it would take a train more than an hour to deliver the results to Washington, DC. But, this year, the message arrives in seconds. How? Thanks to the telegraph, a brand-new invention installed by Samuel Morse. It transmits information by sending electrical signals through a suspended wire. It’s the first practical innovation in the emerging field of electrified communication technology. The telephone arrives a few years later, in 1876. The wireless radio soon follows in the 1890s.

By the turn of the century, distant people are more connected than ever before. However, this is just the beginning. Over the following decades, innovations in communication and information technology will revolutionize the world. Before Morse tapped out the first dots and dashes through a telegraph, communication was either conducted face-to-face or through physical objects like letters and books. Ideas spread more slowly, and accessing information depended on which printed materials you could actually get your hands on. However, the advent of electronic communication like the telegraph, telephone, and eventually computers changed everything – and fast.

It’s hard to overstate how quickly new communication technology was adopted. The first telegraph line was completed in 1844. By 1855, there were 42,000 miles of lines in the United States alone. By the end of the 1870s, telegraph cables stretched across the Atlantic and Pacific oceans. Broadcast radio has a similar trajectory. It began with a single station in 1900 and grew to be the dominant form of public communication by the 1930s.

Computers also became an essential part of daily life at an astounding rate. This is partially due to how quickly computer technology improved and miniaturized. A computer’s processing ability is determined by how many transistors it has. Incremental improvements make transistors smaller and easier to produce, steadily allowing for more transistors to be housed in less space. This phenomenon is sometimes called Moore’s Law. So, in 1975, the average computer chip had 65,000 transistors. Today, that number is in the billions, and they’re much cheaper.

With the internet now connecting all the world’s computers, sharing information is easier than ever. This innovation has changed the political landscape by giving a huge amount of power to those who control communication technology. Now, the world’s most influential companies are search engines like Google and social media empires like Facebook.


Innovation relies on chance, collaboration, and recombination

The non-stick pans in your kitchen, the Gore-Tex coats worn in extreme environments, the fluorine gas chambers in the first atomic bombs. What do these all have in common? They’re all innovations based on polytetrafluoroethylene or PTFE. PTFE was first synthesized in 1938 – by accident. A scientist researching refrigerants stored tetrafluoroethylene gas at sub-zero temperatures. The chemical solidified into a hard substance that was unusually stable and heat-resistant. It didn’t work as a refrigerant, but other scientists found that in other contexts, it could be used for so much more. This story of PTFE is useful because it demonstrates the complex way innovation actually works.

Every story of innovation is different, but if you look closely, you’ll see they often follow a similar pattern. Many of the greatest innovations begin with a bit of serendipity. Someone has a lucky break, an unusual insight, or random occurrence. Then, others pick up on the discovery and apply it to new situations. Through trial and error, they apply the new idea or invention in different contexts until they find a practical use.

Consider the modern practice of using DNA as forensic evidence in criminal cases. No one set out specifically to create this innovation. Instead, it began in 1977, when Alec Jeffreys, a scientist at Leicester University, tried to develop a method using DNA to diagnose diseases. While collecting samples, he saw that DNA was a lot like fingerprints – that is, everyone’s genetic code was different. A chance discovery.

Meanwhile, the local police were struggling to solve a grisly murder. They wondered if Jeffery’s discovery could help solve the mystery. So, the scientist and the police worked together. They began collecting and analyzing more than 5,000 genetic samples from local suspects. They then compared them to DNA found at the crime scene. Eventually, they found a match. Case closed.

Because so much innovation follows this same pattern, it’s possible to identify conditions where it’s more likely to happen. Innovation thrives when people can cross paths, mingle, and exchange ideas. That’s why, throughout history, universities, trading hubs, and major cities have consistently produced novel innovations. By bringing different people with different expertise, perspectives, and cultures together in one place, these contexts foster the type of interactions that push innovation forward.


Innovation doesn’t always come from the top down

In 1924, the British government wanted to build a civilian airship capable of traveling across oceans. This raised the question: should the task be handled by the government or by private industry? They decided to try both approaches. Parliament contracted a government lab and a private firm, Vickers, to build two ships. How did this experiment play out? Well, by 1930, Vickers had designed the R100, a light, fast, and efficient aircraft. It traveled to Canada and back with no problems. Meanwhile, the government lab built the R101, a heavier, more costly ship. On its maiden voyage to Karachi, Pakistan, it only made it to France before crashing, killing 48 passengers.

These two very different outcomes illustrate an important point. When it comes to innovation, direct government oversight and control isn't always the answer. There’s a popular notion that innovation requires guidance and funding directly from the state. This argument posits that private industry, in a constant quest for easy profits, will avoid the costly research and development necessary to create truly new ideas. Instead, firms will hoard their patents and simply rehash old products. But is this true? Not exactly. While it’s true that government-directed research makes great discoveries, it often takes the ingenuity of private enterprise to turn them into practical innovations. Consider the internet. The basic components of computer networking were created by the Defense Advanced Research Project Agency, an American government lab. However, the world wide web didn’t take off as a household necessity until private firms like Cisco began to experiment with the technology in the 1980s and 1990s.

This dynamic occurs because big government projects often aren’t sensitive to the needs or desires of everyday people. Additionally, they can be slow to adopt new, outside-the-box ideas. However, big companies can also suffer this tendency. That’s why even giant firms are sometimes usurped by plucky start-ups.

Remember Kodak? This company was once the undisputed master of the photography industry. Film cameras were their flagship product. So, in 1975, when one of their scientists built an early version of a digital camera, his innovation was ignored. The higher-ups just didn’t see the potential in his bulky, electronic gizmo. Yet, smaller companies did. And they developed their own products, which took over the market. Thus, Kodak missed the digital photography revolution and filed for bankruptcy in 2012.


Innovation will always face resistance

Take a stroll through your grocery store’s dairy aisle. Here, you’ll see a wide selection of both butters and margarines sitting side-by-side in perfect harmony. The choice of spread is up to you. This wasn’t always the case. When margarine was first invented in 1869, it caused an uproar. The oily spread was both cheaper and more stable than butter. The dairy industry, fearing the competition, launched a vicious campaign against it. The National Dairy Council even faked studies showing it was dangerous. By the 1940s, two-thirds of American states had banned this innocuous staple.

Of course, the fervor eventually subsided, and margarine became an accepted foodstuff. Yet, this butter battle shows that even harmless new creations can stoke controversy. When a truly novel idea or invention arrives on the scene, it will often be rejected. This is because everyday people often fear change. Also, established industries don’t want to risk losing their supremacy. This is why horse breeders fought against tractors, ice-harvesters tried to stifle refrigeration technology, and some musicians initially wanted to ban radio stations from playing recorded music.

One way interest groups try to slow innovation is by sowing fears about safety and security. Consider the case of genetically modified organisms or GMOs. GMOs, such as vitamin-A-enriched golden rice, have the potential to bring cheaper nutrition to people all over the world. Yet, groups ideologically opposed to genetic modification, like Greenpeace, lobby hard against their production, citing sometimes flimsy evidence that these foods are dangerous.

Another way innovation is held back is through the overly aggressive application of intellectual property laws. When applied correctly, these laws, such as copyrights and patents, incentivize innovation by giving creators exclusive use of their ideas for a short time. This allows the original innovators to profit.

Yet, as we know, innovation requires sharing ideas and building on the work of others. Unfortunately, copyrights have been steadily extended, making this process more difficult. In the United States, a copyright used to last 14 years. In 1976, it was extended to last the life of the author plus 50 years. In 1998, 50 was extended again to 70 years. These laws no longer benefit the original creator post-mortem, but they do keep good ideas locked away from potential new uses.


Innovation is lacking in the West but booming elsewhere

In much of the world, the past few centuries have been filled with astounding leaps in innovation. In mere generations, Western countries have gone from largely agrarian economies to electrified, industrialized powerhouses. Even now, every day seems to bring novel developments in sectors like communications and computer technology.

Yet, alongside these changes, other sectors are strangely stagnant. In the realm of transportation, not much has changed. In 1958, the average commercial aircraft traveled at 600 miles per hour. Today, they move at roughly the same rate. There have been upgrades around the margins to aspects like fuel efficiency, but the fundamentals are untouched.

The business world, too, is less dynamic. In the United States, new businesses made up 12 percent of the economy in 1980. In 2010, they only accounted for 8 percent. Across the Atlantic, things are even staler. Looking at Europe’s 100 most valuable businesses, only two of them are younger than 40 years old. Most industries seem more focused on protecting current profits than bold new ideas.

So, where is innovation occurring? Mostly in rising nations like China. For the past few decades, this country has poured resources and manpower into urbanization and new technologies. Now Chinese firms like Tencent and Alibaba are at the forefront of growth industries like social media and financial services. Moreover, Chinese universities are making huge strides in fields like gene editing and artificial intelligence.

Can the Western world keep up? Maybe. It would require a renewed spirit of innovation. Companies will need to take more risks, workers will need to put in more hours, and governments will need to foster the free and open exchange of ideas that fueled past booms. All that, plus a little luck, will put innovation back on the agenda.


Image - Bright spark: detail of an 1879 illustration depicting Thomas Edison's lightbulb 
CREDIT: Getty Images
© Christine Calo 2021. Please do not reproduce without the expressed consent of Christine Calo. Powered by Blogger.